Which Jeweler or Watch Store Should You Choose in Sarasota, FL?

Review 11 local jewelers and watch stores in Sarasota, FL and check what each business offers. Read customer feedback, compare store information, and shortlist retailers or repair specialists that carry the products or provide the services you need.
A. Tifaney & Son is a Sarasota-based jewelry business specializing in buying and selling diamonds, estate jewelry, and luxury watches. With 30 years of expertise, we offer accurate appraisals and competitive pricing for rare and unique pieces. Our GIA-certified gemologist ensures clients receive fair value for their assets.
We Buy Jewelry We Sell Jewelry 24 Hour Estimates
Highest prices Wonderful staff No pressure sales
7 reviews
Diamond Vault
48 Years
7 reviews
Diamond Vault is a family-owned jewelry store in Sarasota, FL, specializing in fine diamond jewelry, luxury watches, and custom design services. With over 40 years of experience and a team of GIA-certified gemologists, we provide heirloom-quality pieces and personalized solutions for engagement rings, estate jewelry, and bespoke creations. Our commitment to quality, integrity, and exceptional customer service has established us as a trusted leader in Southwest Florida's jewelry industry.
Engagement Rings Custom Design Diamond Appraisals
Best jeweler in town Professionalism and kindness Stunning jewelry
7 reviews
McCarver Moser
47 Years
7 reviews
McCarver Moser offers premium jewelry shopping, custom design, and repair services in Sarasota, FL. We specialize in diamond engagement rings, designer wedding bands, and estate jewelry from historical periods. Our experienced concierge team provides appraisals, jewelry restoration, and watch repairs.
Engagement Rings Wedding Bands Diamond Jewelry
6 reviews
Unique Design Jewelers
26 Years
Emergency
6 reviews
Unique Design Jewelers offers custom jewelry creation, on-site repair services, and luxury watch sales. Our designers bring decades of expertise to each piece, specializing in personalized designs and restorations. With over 15 years of service, we combine heritage craftsmanship with modern techniques to meet client needs.
Custom Jewelry Design Jewelry Repair Watch Sales
Beautiful necklace Expertise of the jewelers Quality of service
Estate Coin & Jewelry Galleria operates as a dual-specialty store in Sarasota, Florida, offering expert services for buying and selling precious metals, numismatic items, and estate jewelry. The business combines decades of industry experience with certified grading expertise to deliver accurate valuations and personalized service. Their offerings include appraisal services, collection consultations, and acquisition of high-value collectibles.
Coin Appraisals Jewelry Sales Gold Evaluation
Excellent service Fair price offered Knowledgeable staff
Harry Roa Gallery is a Sarasota-based artisan jewelry design and fabrication studio offering custom creations using 14K/18K gold and platinum. The studio specializes in architectural-inspired pieces, award-winning craftsmanship, and repair services for heirloom and contemporary jewelry. With global clientele and decades of experience, it combines technical precision with artistic innovation to deliver personalized, high-quality designs.
Custom Jewelry Design CAD Renderings Gemstone Selection
Quality craftsmanship Art Deco inspired designs Attentive customer service
Carats Fine Jewelry And Watches offers luxury bridal jewelry, Swiss watches, and custom-designed pieces in Sarasota, FL. Our services include jewelry repair, appraisals, and concierge consultations. We combine family-owned tradition with cutting-edge craftsmanship to serve Florida's Gulf Coast.
Engagement Rings Estate Jewelry Wedding Bands
Gorgeous and fits perfectly Friendly customer service Unparalleled craftsmanship
A&F Pawn Jewelry & Loan, operating in Bradenton since 1993, specializes in high-payout gold and jewelry transactions, pawn loans, and a curated selection of pre-owned electronics and luxury items. Our family-owned business combines expertise in valuation with a commitment to customer-centric service, offering no-credit-check loans and flexible layaway options. We serve Bradenton and Sarasota residents with honesty, competitive pricing, and a focus on building long-term trust.
Pawn Loans Gold Buying Jewelry Repair
Excellent pawn shop Best prices around Treated with kindness
Amar Jewelry specializes in custom jewelry design, professional appraisals, and pre-owned jewelry purchases in downtown Sarasota. Our services include creating bespoke pieces from high-quality materials, providing accurate jewelry valuations, and buying diamonds, gemstones, and luxury watches. We offer on-site jewelry repair and watch battery replacement services.
Custom Jewelry Design Jewelry Appraisals Pre-Owned Jewelry Purchase
Sarasota Antique Buyers specializes in purchasing and selling high-value antiques, offering appraisal services, and facilitating estate liquidations. With over 22 years of expertise, we provide fair evaluations for sterling silver, fine art, jewelry, and collectibles. Our trusted network ensures seamless transactions for single items or entire estates.
Antique Buying Appraisals Estate Liquidations
Painless estate sale process Accurate appraisals Extensive industry connections
Jewelry by Cole is a premier custom jewelry design and repair service specializing in handcrafted gold and gemstone creations. With over 35 years of expertise, we combine traditional goldsmithing techniques with modern technology to produce award-winning custom engagement rings, wedding bands, and unique jewelry pieces. Our integrated showroom and manufacturing facility in Sarasota, Florida, offers direct client engagement with the crafting process, ensuring quality and affordability through on-site expertise.
Custom Jewelry Design Jewelry Repair Diamond Acquisition
Award-winning designs Expert craftsmanship Custom creations stand out
Bradenton (11.5 mi) Port Charlotte (36.7 mi) Tampa (42.6 mi) Saint Petersburg (29.3 mi) Largo (42.5 mi) Brandon (44.1 mi) Clearwater (46.5 mi)