Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
14 Years
experience
Your Trusted Coin & Jewelry Experts in Sarasota, FL
Estate Coin & Jewelry Galleria has been serving Sarasota, FL since 2012, combining over 65 years of expertise in numismatics and estate jewelry. Our team of certified professionals specializes in buying and selling gold, silver, bullion, vintage jewelry, and rare collectibles. We prioritize client confidence through transparent appraisals, fair market valuations, and personalized service. With deep industry connections and participation in major trade shows, we maintain rigorous standards for quality assessment. Our services include no-charge verbal offers, formal written appraisals for insurance purposes, and expert consultation for collections of all sizes.

The owners' backgrounds at leading grading institutions like NGC and PMG ensure authoritative evaluation capabilities. We maintain strict privacy protocols through appointment-only consultations while remaining accessible for urgent client needs. Our commitment to ethical practices is demonstrated through memberships in premier industry organizations including PCGS, ANA, and GIA. Client testimonials consistently highlight our professionalism, competitive pricing, and exceptional customer care. As active participants in both local and international markets, we provide up-to-date valuations reflecting current economic conditions.
Services
Coin Appraisals Jewelry Sales Gold Evaluation Silver Bullion Trading Estate Jewelry Acquisition
Details
  • Year established: 2012
Highlights and features
  • We offer 65+ years combined experience in numismatics and jewelry evaluation
  • Our team includes GIA-certified diamond graders and PMG/NGC alumni
  • We provide free verbal offers with no obligation for all potential consignments
  • We maintain active memberships in premier numismatic and jewelry organizations
  • We guarantee transparent transactions with documented valuation methodologies
Associations and certifications
  • NGC
  • PMG
  • PCGS
  • GIA
  • ANA
  • CSNS
  • IBNS
What people say
Excellent service Fair price offered Knowledgeable staff Smooth transaction process Highly recommend
Services
Coin Appraisals
Professional assessment of coins, currency, and bullion by NGC/PMG-certified experts. We analyze rarity, condition, and market trends to provide accurate valuations for insurance, estate settlements, or sales. Our process combines advanced grading technology with decades of hands-on experience.
Jewelry Sales
Curated selection of vintage and estate jewelry featuring GIA-graded diamonds and precious metals. Our inventory includes unique pieces from different eras, each authenticated and priced according to current market standards. We offer customization options for special orders.
Gold Evaluation
Comprehensive assessment of gold items including coins, bullion, and jewelry. We use industry-standard testing methods to determine purity and weight, providing immediate valuation based on live market prices and offering competitive purchase rates.
Silver Bullion Trading
Buying and selling of silver coins and bullion with transparent pricing tied to COMEX futures. We maintain current inventories of popular investment-grade products and offer guidance on portfolio diversification strategies using physical precious metals.
Estate Jewelry Acquisition
Specialized service for individuals liquidating inherited or unused jewelry. Our GIA-certified buyers provide fair market valuations considering material value, craftsmanship, and collectible premiums, with options for immediate sale or consignment.
People
Jerica
Owner
Industry veteran with 20 years experience in numismatics and jewelry. Former NGC Registry Set Coordinator, GIA Diamond Grading Certificate holder, and creator of Jessa J. Jewelry line. Specializes in estate jewelry and precious metal valuation.
Richard
Consultant
Seasoned numismatic expert with 50 years industry experience. Former PMG grading finalizer and owner of Sarasota's first coin shop since 2005. Handles high-value collections and provides expertise on rare currency and coins worth millions.
Shannon
Jewelry Specialist
Sarasota native combining real estate acumen with jewelry expertise. Focuses on client education and market alignment, ensuring informed decisions for both buyers and sellers of fine jewelry and collectibles.
Questions
What items do you buy?
We purchase gold, silver, bullion coins, estate jewelry, diamonds, vintage watches, and numismatic collections with particular expertise in certified pieces.
How are prices determined?
Valuations combine live market data, material composition analysis, and collectible premiums assessed by our GIA and NGC-certified professionals using industry-standard equipment.
Do you provide written appraisals?
Yes, we offer formal written appraisals for insurance and estate purposes conducted by our certified numismatic and jewelry experts.
Are appointments necessary?
While walk-ins are welcome, appointments ensure dedicated time with our specialists for more complex evaluations or larger collections.
What accreditations do you hold?
We maintain active memberships and certifications with NGC, PMG, PCGS, GIA, and the American Numismatic Association for quality assurance.
Reviews (6)
Temi Akojie
Dec 20, 2021 Report
So grateful to have met Jerica for my first ever Jewlery experience. This truly is an experience working with her. I wanted to step up my jewelry game and had no idea what to expect. Jerica was so incredibly patient explaining different types of Jewelry and answering all my questions. She made me feel relaxed and comfortable. Usually when I make a a purchase I have a bit of buyers remorse but with this purchase I felt so incredibly proud and confident because Jerica doesnt sell to you. She gives you exactly what you came in for and provides you enough info for you to feel comfortable with your
Linda Milone
Dec 12, 2021 Report
I had the pleasure of dealing with Jerica at Estate Coin and Jewelry. She was very courteous , fair and professional during our appointment. I will surely purchase jewelry from her shop in the future Thanks Jerica
E. Harrison
Jun 24, 2021 Report
The owner, Jerica, is very experienced and knowledgeable, but not only that, she also took the time to make sure we found exactly what we were looking for. I can tell she really loves what she does and cares about her customers!
Danielle & Luke Wilburn
Mar 01, 2021 Report
Great experience! Jerika is extremely knowledgeable, and walks you through the entire selling process. She and her associate were fun and friendly.
M. N. C. Mouse
Nov 06, 2020 Report
Professional and courteous. Willing to answer any and all questions I had. Absolutely wonderful experience from phone call to final handshake. Traded in my inherited coin collection to them and they took the time to go through every coin and check to make sure I was getting a fair price for each one.
Kayna Ruvalcaba
Jul 07, 2020 Report
I recently went in and met Jerica in regards to selling a diamond I had. She was not only friendly and knowledgeable but she gave me a very fair price for selling my diamond. I also met Rick while I was there and he was also very friendly. I went to multiple places for opinions and offers before selling and I am very glad to have chosen them to work with. Highly recommend them not only for selling your jewelry (or coins!) but for buying as well. They had beautiful items in the display cases.