Business Details
46 Years
experience
Trusted Jewelry Buyer and Seller in Sarasota
A. Tifaney & Son has served Sarasota, Florida for 30 years as a trusted destination for buying and selling diamonds, estate jewelry, and luxury watches. Our expertise in valuing rare and one-of-a-kind pieces sets us apart, with GIA-certified gemologist Kirk Weisman leading our team. We specialize in providing accurate appraisals and competitive offers for items others undervalue. Our services extend across Tampa Bay, Naples, and the Gulf Coast, offering discreet transactions and personalized attention.With decades of experience, we ensure clients receive fair market value for their precious assets. Our inventory includes rare jewelry, engagement rings, and collectibles, all available at dealer-direct prices. We prioritize transparency, avoiding the markup practices of traditional retail stores. Clients benefit from same-day settlements and insured shipping options for their convenience. Our reputation as Sarasota's premier jewelry specialists is built on integrity and unmatched industry knowledge.
Services
We Buy Jewelry
We Sell Jewelry
24 Hour Estimates
Appraisals
Jewelry Pawn Services
Details
- Year established: 1980
Highlights and features
- We have 30 years of experience in estate jewelry valuation.
- Our team includes a GIA-certified gemologist for accurate assessments.
- We offer competitive offers for rare and unique pieces.
- 24-hour estimates available for time-sensitive transactions.
- Discreet, personalized service for high-value items.
Associations and certifications
- GIA
What people say
Highest prices
Wonderful staff
No pressure sales
Expert valuations
Quick service
Services
Jewelry Appraisals
Our GIA-certified gemologist provides accurate jewelry appraisals for insurance, legal, or tax purposes. We specialize in modern and antique pieces, including diamonds and sterling silver. Clients receive detailed documentation to ensure proper valuation of their assets.
Jewelry Buying
We purchase diamonds, luxury watches, estate jewelry, and rare collectibles at competitive prices. Our expertise in unique items ensures fair valuation beyond material worth. Transactions can often be completed the same day with immediate payment options.
24 Hour Estimates
Receive professional jewelry estimates within 24 hours through in-person visits or insured shipping. Our certified gemologist evaluates items remotely when necessary. This service helps clients understand their jewelry's market value efficiently.
Jewelry Pawn Services
We offer short-term loans secured by gold, diamonds, or luxury items with flexible terms. Clients can retrieve their assets or choose to sell permanently. This service provides quick cash access while maintaining ownership options.
Jewelry Sales
Our inventory features rare and estate jewelry at dealer-direct prices. We offer custom design services and carry established brands like Cartier and Rolex. Customers benefit from significant savings compared to traditional retail stores.
People
Kirk Weisman
Owner & GIA Certified Gemologist
With over 40 years in the jewelry industry, Kirk Weisman established Sarasota's premier valuation service. His expertise in rare jewelry appraisal and commitment to fair pricing has built lasting client relationships across Florida's Gulf Coast.
Questions
What types of jewelry do you buy?
We purchase diamonds, luxury watches, estate jewelry, gold, silver, rare collectibles, and designer pieces from single items to complete estates.
How quickly can I get paid for my jewelry?
Most transactions complete the same day with immediate payment via check or bankwire transfer after finalizing terms.
Do you offer jewelry appraisals?
Yes, our GIA-certified gemologist provides detailed appraisals for insurance, tax, or sale purposes with 24-hour estimates available.
Can I sell jewelry remotely?
Yes, we provide insured shipping instructions for remote transactions and offer virtual consultations to evaluate your items securely.
What areas do you serve?
We serve clients throughout Florida's Gulf Coast including Sarasota, Tampa Bay, and Naples regions with discreet, personalized service.
Do you buy damaged jewelry?
We evaluate all jewelry based on material value and potential restoration worth, including pieces requiring repair or professional attention.
Reviews (7)
Daniel Rodriguez
Feb 18, 2021
Report
An absolute pleasure to do business with! These folks are very knowledgeable and friendly, we had a great time!!
Janet Green
Nov 15, 2020
Report
Kirk has been our family favorite for almost 25 years! Honorable and knowledgeable are two descriptions for this Rock Man!
Brandon Stone
Jul 24, 2020
Report
Could not recommend this company more highly, most personable and genuine guy I have ever done business with
Mike Martin
Dec 18, 2017
Report
My father and I have been buying jewelry from Kirk for years. My father has been buying from Kirk for over 15 years. I have recently started buying and it has been an absolute pleasure. I would not shop anywhere else. Prices are very reasonable and Kirk is honest, No pushy sales tactics. Not to mention he has wide range of stones, necklaces, and rings. If you are looking for jewelry in the Sarasota area do yourself favor and stop in.
Phoebe Ray
Jun 04, 2017
Report
As some one who has collected my family's beautiful estate jewelry over the years , it was important to me to find a buyer who genuinely care's about the product. After shopping around the area I was so lucky to have found Kirk and his wonderful business . Not only was he sincere , patient and kind but he came in at the best price. After such a wonderful experience , I will not go anywhere else . Thank you Kirk I truly appreciate it !
Antonio Salgado
Nov 30, 2016
Report
I bought my fiancee's ring from Kirk and got a fantastic deal. I picked out diamond and had him set it in a 14k white gold setting. Beforehand, I have been shopping for several months all over the US (use to travel for work 100%) from LA' to NYC s diamond district. In closing, I will be back to buy more jewelry from Tifaney & Son in the near future
Kevin Henault
Oct 18, 2015
Report
I would like to thank Kirk for assisting me with an appraisal. I needed to get a ring appraised for a legal matter. He confirmed the ring was not valuable and took the time to write a letter. Since the ring had no value, he did not charge me for his time. I will be returning to him to purchase jewelry in the near future. I appreciate your kindness Kirk. Kevin H.