Which Restaurant Should You Choose in Bethpage, NY?

Review 3 local restaurants in Bethpage, NY and check what each location offers. Read customer feedback, compare menus and dining details, and shortlist places that serve the type of cuisine or dining experience you want.
Ciminelli's Pizza is a family-owned Italian restaurant in Bethpage specializing in handcrafted pizzas, homemade pasta, and catering services. We use fresh ingredients and traditional recipes to create authentic flavors in a welcoming environment. Our offerings include dine-in, takeout, and on/off-premise catering for events of all sizes.
Gourmet Pizza Italian Cuisine Catering Services
Authentic Italian food Quality ingredients Welcoming atmosphere
Villa Maria Pizza is a family-owned Italian restaurant in Bethpage, NY, serving handcrafted pizzas, pastas, and Italian dishes since 2013. We specialize in made-from-scratch meals using fresh ingredients and offer catering for events of all sizes. Our menu features weekly specials, family dinners, and award-winning meatball heroes, combining tradition with modern culinary techniques.
Pizza Pasta Catering
Best pizza around Excellent food Flawless service
Mangoes Mexican Bar & Grill is a family-owned restaurant specializing in authentic Mexican cuisine. We offer a diverse menu featuring traditional dishes, daily lunch specials starting at $7.50, and catering services for private events. Our mission is to deliver high-quality food in a welcoming environment that celebrates Mexican culture through dining experiences and educational programs.
Appetizers Soups Salads
Massapequa (4.4 mi) Huntington (9.0 mi) Franklin Square (10.5 mi) Commack (12.0 mi) Long Beach (14.2 mi) Smithtown (16.6 mi) Farmingdale (2.1 mi) Levittown (2.1 mi) Plainview (2.4 mi) Wantagh (4.4 mi)