Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
13 Years
experience
Your Trusted Italian Restaurant in Bethpage, NY
Villa Maria Pizza has been serving Bethpage and Levittown, New York with authentic Italian cuisine since 2013. Founded by Chef Michael Goldsborough, a Culinary Institute of America graduate with extensive experience as a former NYC Executive Chef, we specialize in handcrafted pizzas, pastas, and Italian dishes made from scratch using the freshest ingredients. Our commitment to quality extends to our catering services, which accommodate events of all sizes with menus tailored to satisfy diverse palates. Located in the heart of Long Island, we offer dine-in, takeout, and catering options while maintaining a welcoming atmosphere that reflects Italian culture. Our lunch and dinner specials, including weekly deals and family-style meals, emphasize affordability without compromising flavor.

With decades of culinary expertise, we ensure every dish meets exacting standards of taste and presentation. Our team prioritizes exceptional service, whether customers visit our Bethpage location or order for pickup and delivery. Recognized for excellence in food and service, we remain dedicated to providing memorable dining experiences. Our menu features classic Italian favorites like baked ziti, chicken parmesan, and our award-winning meatball heroes, all prepared with care. From casual meals to large-scale catering, Villa Maria Pizza combines tradition with innovation to serve the Long Island community.
Services
Pizza Pasta Catering Lunch Specials Family Dinners Meatball Heroes Baked Entrees Takeout Dine-In Delivery
Details
  • Year established: 2013
Highlights and features
  • We offer decades of culinary expertise from a Culinary Institute of America graduate.
  • Our menu features handcrafted Italian dishes made from scratch daily.
  • We provide full-service catering for events from 10 to 1,000 guests.
  • Our family-style meals serve 4-6 people with generous portions.
  • We maintain consistent quality recognized by local food awards.
What people say
Best pizza around Excellent food Flawless service Never disappointed Outstanding catering
Services
Pizza
Our handcrafted pizzas feature house-made dough topped with premium ingredients. Available in classic combinations or custom creations, each pizza uses fresh mozzarella, house-made tomato sauce, and high-quality toppings. Perfect for individual meals or sharing with family and friends.
Catering
Full-service catering for events of all sizes includes made-to-order menus with Italian favorites. We provide delivery, setup, and serving staff for weddings, corporate events, and private parties. Menus accommodate dietary preferences and large group quantities.
Lunch Specials
Daily lunch specials feature rotating Italian dishes from 11:30 AM to 3 PM. Options include heroes, pastas, and combo meals with garlic knots and salad. Special pricing available for dine-in, takeout, and delivery orders during lunch hours.
Family Dinners
Family-style dinner specials serve 4-6 people with generous portions of pizza, pasta, and side dishes. Available for pickup or delivery with 45-60 minute notice. Includes options like baked ziti, penne alla vodka, and garlic knots.
Baked Entrees
Traditional baked Italian entrees feature house-made pasta and premium ingredients. Options include chicken parmesan, eggplant parmesan, baked ziti, and stuffed shells. Available for dine-in, takeout, or catering events.
People
Michael Goldsborough
Owner Chef
Chef Michael Goldsborough, a Culinary Institute of America graduate with decades in NYC fine dining, creates our authentic Italian menu. His expertise ensures every dish combines traditional techniques with modern presentation standards.
Questions
What catering options do you offer for large events?
We provide full-service catering for events from 10 to 1,000 guests with customizable menus featuring our signature Italian dishes and dedicated service staff.
Are your lunch specials available for takeout?
Yes, all lunch specials from 11:30 AM to 3 PM are available for takeout, dine-in, or delivery with no additional charges.
What are your most popular menu items?
Our award-winning meatball heroes, handcrafted pizzas, and baked entrees like chicken parmesan consistently receive the highest customer ratings.
Do you offer delivery services?
Yes, we deliver to Bethpage, Levittown, and surrounding areas with a 45-60 minute estimated preparation time for all delivery orders.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, cash, and mobile payment options for both in-restaurant and online orders.
Reviews (4)
Raven M.
Jan 15, 2022 Report
My only regret is that I didn't order from them right when we moved to the neighborhood! The food is so delicious! They offer great specials and everything we have ordered has been yummy and large portions! The garlic knots are so good! And the pizza crust is crunchy and delish! This pizzeria is by far the best we've had since moving to the area in 2019. It has become a weekly go-to for us! Totally recommend!
Sheri Rosen
Dec 31, 2021 Report
Picked up a chicken roll with very little chicken in it. Husband said it was not good. Please make sure the customer is getting the food that they paid for. Now he does not want to order from you again.
Jarrett Krupp
Sep 20, 2021 Report
Picked up a pie with meatballs & it was excellent! The gentleman who answered the call on my order was friendly & courteous. This is the way a classic pizzeria should be. Was my first time at Villa Maria's but definitely won't be my last. Well worth making the trip from East Meadow!
Lady Of Winterfell
Jun 17, 2021 Report
Ordered delivery through slice received a burnt pizza underneath was black the garlic knots were soaked with grease. Im very disappointed ordered because my friend recommended it. Wont order here again