Business Details
Authentic Italian Pizza & Restaurant in Bethpage, NY
At Ciminelli's Pizza, we take pride in serving authentic Italian cuisine crafted with fresh ingredients and traditional recipes. Our commitment to quality extends from our hand-tossed pizzas to our homemade pasta dishes, all prepared to deliver bold flavors and memorable dining experiences. We offer both dine-in and takeout options, complemented by a welcoming atmosphere where families and friends can gather comfortably. Our catering services provide gourmet Italian meals for events of all sizes, whether on or off premises. With decades of experience in Bethpage, we have built a reputation for excellence through consistent attention to detail and customer satisfaction.Our menu features classic favorites like Sicilian, Grandma, and Neapolitan pizzas, alongside specialty dishes such as chicken parmigiana and creamy fettuccine alfredo. We maintain a clean, smoke-free environment with professional service to ensure every visit is enjoyable. From our kitchen to your table, we prioritize taste, quality, and hospitality in every meal we serve. Our dedication to the community has made us a trusted local favorite for authentic Italian flavors. Whether you're planning a casual dinner or a special event, Ciminelli's Pizza delivers the perfect combination of tradition, flavor, and service.
Services
Gourmet Pizza
Italian Cuisine
Catering Services
On/Off Premise Catering
Wine List
Gift Certificates
Highlights and features
- We have decades of experience serving authentic Italian cuisine in Bethpage.
- Our commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients ensures exceptional taste in every dish.
- We offer versatile on/off-premise catering for weddings, parties, and corporate events.
- Enjoy a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for family dinners and social gatherings.
- Consistently praised for our Sicilian, Grandma, and Neapolitan pizza varieties.
What people say
Authentic Italian food
Quality ingredients
Welcoming atmosphere
Sicilian pizza
Neapolitan pizza
Services
Gourmet Pizza
Handcrafted pizzas with premium ingredients and bold flavors that redefine deliciousness. Our menu features Sicilian, Grandma, and Neapolitan varieties baked to perfection. Each slice combines traditional techniques with modern creativity for an unforgettable dining experience.
Catering Services
On/off-premise catering for weddings, parties, and corporate events. We provide gourmet Italian meals including chicken parmigiana, pasta dishes, and custom pizza stations. Our professional team ensures seamless service and exceptional taste for any occasion.
Italian Cuisine
Homemade Italian dishes like creamy fettuccine alfredo, baked ziti, and meatball heroes. Every meal is prepared with fresh ingredients and traditional recipes to deliver authentic flavors. Perfect for dine-in, takeout, or family-style sharing.
Wine & Cocktails
Curated wine list and specialty cocktails to complement your meal. From Prosecco-based drinks to classic martinis, our menu offers refreshing options for every palate. Pair your pizza with a Lynchburg Lemonade or Taste of the Good Life.
Gift Certificates
Flexible gift options for birthdays, holidays, or special occasions. Recipients can enjoy our gourmet pizzas, Italian entrees, or catering services. Available in any denomination for dine-in, takeout, or event bookings.
Questions
What types of pizza do you offer?
We serve Sicilian, Grandma, and Neapolitan pizzas with hand-tossed crusts and premium toppings. Custom combinations are also available.
Do you provide catering services?
Yes, we offer on/off-premise catering for events with options like pizza stations, pasta dishes, and chicken parmigiana.
What are your operating hours?
We're open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM for dine-in, takeout, and catering orders.
Is your restaurant family-friendly?
Yes, our smoke-free dining area with comfortable seating is perfect for families and groups of all sizes.
Do you have wine and cocktails?
Our beverage menu includes wine, specialty cocktails like Lynchburg Lemonade, and Italian sodas to pair with your meal.
Can I order online?
Yes, use our website to place takeout orders or book catering services for your next event.
Reviews (5)
Jerry Loretta
Dec 16, 2021
Report
We came with 16 relatives for a funeral luncheon.Anthony was kind prompt personable & he was sooooo helpful with all r orders!!! Great food & servicewell definitely return soon.
Robin Pagan
Dec 15, 2021
Report
Anthony is an exceptional waiter. The food is awesome. And there is plenty of parking available. Highly recommend Ciminelli's for lunch or dinner. And ask for Anthony!
Emanuel Joseph
Jul 17, 2021
Report
Moved into the area a year ago and never heard of this restaurant. Friends put me on to La Piazza in Plainview which is great. Until my neighbor mentioned Ciminelli's and asked why do I keep going to La Piazza when they are always busy. He invited me to go with him one day and my family and others have been hooked. Have your pie made "well done". The texture, and sauce are amazing. The owners son Tony, knew it was my first time and I mentioned how
my wife loved grandma slices. He gave me a free slice and sicilion packed up and said give this to her. My wife was very pleased and loved it. Thank
my wife loved grandma slices. He gave me a free slice and sicilion packed up and said give this to her. My wife was very pleased and loved it. Thank
Renee Laplaca
Jun 20, 2021
Report
Waited an hour for the food and live up the road. When you call they put your info in the computer. first night they put the wrong address, next time I called in an order they put in the wrong town sending the driver to farmingdale. I had guest over it was a bad experience when I called the manager asking where my food was that it was a hundred dollar order he said "we got all new drivers they get lost easy". 20 years in the industry myself that's not how you handle a complaint. Food was ok but the wait for the price ridiculous. We're not going back.
Cassandra Greco
Feb 16, 2021
Report
Went to Ciminelli's Pizza & Restaurant in Bethpage for a local Valentines Dinner last night and it was amazing! The table was set up and restaurant was decorated beautifully for the holiday! The bread/garlic sticks they give to start are fresh out of the oven warm and so delicious. We got a small salad and mini rice balls for appetizers. Baked cheese ravioli (one with tomato and one with vodka sauce) for the main course. Chocolate lava cake and hot tea to end the night. The wait staff was extremely attentive. I think it was possibly the owner there (maybe a manager/higher up) who provided all
