Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
14 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Cuisine in Port Jefferson Station, NY
Old Town Pizza has been serving authentic Italian cuisine to the Port Jefferson Station community for years, combining traditional recipes with modern culinary techniques. Our family-owned business prides itself on creating a warm, inviting atmosphere where guests can enjoy hand-tossed pizzas, fresh salads, and house-made pasta dishes crafted with locally sourced ingredients. With decades of combined experience in the hospitality industry, our team ensures every meal is prepared to perfection, whether enjoyed in our dining room or at a private event.

We hold ourselves to the highest standards of quality and service, offering catering solutions for weddings, corporate events, and family gatherings of all sizes. Our commitment to excellence extends to our menu development, staff training, and customer care, making us a trusted name in Italian dining.
Services
Pizza Catering Pasta Salads Calzones Sandwiches Desserts Wings Seafood Burgers
Details
  • Year established: 2012
Highlights and features
  • We offer catering services for weddings, corporate events, and family gatherings.
  • Our menu features house-made pasta and sauces using traditional Italian recipes.
  • Family-owned operation ensures personalized attention to every detail.
  • Locally sourced ingredients guarantee fresh, high-quality meals.
  • Dine-in, takeout, and delivery options provide maximum convenience.
What people say
Amazing buffalo sauce Prompt delivery Great prices Delicious food Friendly staff
Services
Pizza
Hand-tossed Neapolitan-style pizzas with house-made dough and San Marzano tomato sauce. Toppings include imported mozzarella, house-cured meats, and seasonal vegetables. Available in classic combinations or custom creations.
Catering
Full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and private parties. Includes menu customization, on-site staff, and delivery. Features passed appetizers, buffet spreads, and plated entrees with Italian specialties.
Pasta
House-made pasta dishes including traditional lasagna, stuffed shells, and seafood linguine. Options range from classic marinara to creamy vodka sauces. Available in family-style portions or individual servings.
Salads
Freshly prepared salads with imported cheeses and house-made dressings. Includes classic Caesar, Caprese, and specialty options with grilled proteins. Served with garlic knots or focaccia bread.
Calzones
Baked dough pockets filled with mozzarella, ricotta, and choice of meats or vegetables. Served with marinara for dipping. Available in traditional or custom combinations.
Questions
Does Old Town Pizzeria offer catering services?
Yes, we provide full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and private parties with customizable menus and on-site staff.
What are the restaurant's operating hours?
We're open Monday-Saturday 10am-10pm and Sunday 11am-10pm for dine-in, takeout, and delivery.
Do you have gluten-free pizza options?
Yes, we offer gluten-free crust options for most pizza varieties to accommodate dietary restrictions.
Are reservations required for dining in?
Reservations are recommended for weekends but not required. We accept walk-ins during regular business hours.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, mobile payments, and cash for both in-restaurant and online orders.
Reviews (4)
Austin M.
Jan 30, 2022 Report
Food was really good, one of the few places that were open during the snow storm I got a large pie and a dozen garlic knots, only thing I can say is I was charged an extra 6$ after looking at the menu prices, should have been charged 24 and change not 29.68 but I'm sure it was accidental. Great pizza great food and great local location
Toni M.
Jan 03, 2022 Report
Ordered a pie New Year's Day as well as a couple of entrees and was brought this horrendous looking pizza 40 minutes later. Pizza was cold in the middle and totally overdone. I can understand being busy and a pie going slightly cold but this clearly was not the case. There was zero cheese pull and this was definitely a pie they baked the night before and was thrown in for a second time. Burnt and inedible.
Francina B.
Dec 24, 2021 Report
They have great food, but the customer service is terrible, they just hung up the phone, because I ask if they have something else to my to add. I call again 5 times, he just said to me, I tell you when you ready call back. He is a simple lier ... so rude
Liz M.
Dec 15, 2021 Report
Had the cauliflower pizza, crust was soggy and I live 5 minutes away. Could have used more sauce as it was dry. Staff was friendly and efficient.