Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
27 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining Experience in Mastic, NY
Mama Lisa Restaurant was established in 1999 by Gaetano and Mose Costigliola, building on the legacy of their father Carlo Costigliola's successful Italian restaurant Umbertos. We specialize in authentic Italian cuisine crafted from family-style recipes passed down through generations. Our commitment to quality is reflected in our use of fresh, locally sourced ingredients from Mastic businesses, including bread, seafood, and vegetables.

We prioritize customer satisfaction through competitive pricing, minimal wait times, and exceptional service in both dine-in and takeout settings. As active members of the community, we proudly sponsor local sports teams, schools, and charitable events, reinforcing our dedication to supporting the Mastic area.
Services
Catering Dine-In Takeout Online Ordering Event Hosting Reservations Wine Selection Lunch Specials Children's Menu Private Parties
Details
  • Year established: 1999
Highlights and features
  • Family recipes perfected over three generations of Italian culinary expertise
  • Locally sourced ingredients supporting Mastic businesses and ensuring freshness
  • Custom catering services for events from intimate gatherings to large celebrations
  • Consistently recognized for exceptional service and authentic Italian flavors
  • Active community involvement through sponsorship of local schools and events
What people say
Delicious & fresh Service is amazing Warm & welcoming Best Italian food Outstanding
Services
Catering Services
We provide customized catering for weddings, corporate events, and private parties. Our team handles menu customization, table settings, and event logistics to ensure memorable celebrations. Clients receive personalized consultations to create tailored dining experiences that reflect their event's unique requirements.
Italian Dining
Our restaurant offers authentic Italian cuisine featuring family recipes passed down through generations. The menu includes house-made pasta, wood-fired pizzas, seafood specialties, and traditional entrees. Diners enjoy a warm ambiance with attentive service in a setting designed for both casual meals and special occasions.
Online Ordering
Customers can place takeout orders through our user-friendly online system. The platform allows menu customization, order tracking, and payment processing from any device. This service provides convenient access to our full menu for home or office consumption.
Reservations
We offer advance table reservations for dining guests. The system ensures availability during peak hours and accommodates special seating requests. Reservations are recommended for weekends and holiday periods to guarantee preferred time slots.
Wine Selection
Our curated wine list features Italian and international varietals selected to complement Italian cuisine. Options include red, white, and sparkling wines by the glass or bottle, with sommelier recommendations for food pairings.
People
Gaetano Costigliola
Co-Founder
Co-founded Mama Lisa Restaurant in 1999, continuing the family's Italian culinary legacy from Umbertos. Brings decades of restaurant management experience and traditional cooking expertise to maintain authentic Italian flavors.
Mose Costigliola
Co-Founder
Co-founder with extensive knowledge of Italian cuisine operations. Works closely with local suppliers to ensure ingredient quality while maintaining the family's commitment to traditional cooking methods and community values.
Carlo Costigliola
Founder of Umbertos
Established Umbertos restaurant in Patchogue over 15 years prior to Mama Lisa. His culinary legacy and business acumen laid the foundation for the family's continued success in Italian dining.
Questions
What Italian specialties do you offer?
We serve traditional Italian dishes including house-made pasta, wood-fired pizzas, seafood entrees, and meat specialties using family recipes passed down through generations.
Do you cater private events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and private parties with customized menus and event coordination.
Can I order food online?
Yes, our website offers a user-friendly online ordering system for takeout with menu customization and order tracking capabilities.
Are reservations recommended?
Reservations are recommended for weekend dining and holiday periods to ensure table availability during peak hours.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards and cash for both dine-in and takeout orders.
Do you have gluten-free options?
Yes, we offer gluten-free pasta, pizza crusts, and other menu items clearly marked in our restaurant and online.
Reviews (5)
Anthony G.
Jan 29, 2022 Report
I know people who don't like this place but it's not bad at all. Love there pizza, never sat down inside. Give it a try!
Themig
Jan 18, 2022 Report
Wife and I received a gift card for Mama Lisa and had no idea what to expect. All I can say is this became our favorite place to eat. The food is fantastic. Well prepared and fresh. Weve gone back around 20 times in a 6 month period and we do not live close. Friendly staff makes the experience even better. Kudos to the folks running this place. The Manager always makes us feel welcome but hes not overbearing. I recommend this place to everyone.
Marina D.
Jan 18, 2022 Report
Went on Monday food was amazing The chicken franchise is the best waiter was great ,it's a very nice experience
Michael Fuzie
Dec 25, 2021 Report
A very clean and professional feeling place. The menus is is simply phenomenal. You likely wont find anything you dislike. Combo# 4 has the best value though and gives you a little taste of everything. A great place to go whether you live in the community or are from out of town.
Larry L.
Nov 26, 2021 Report
Great food and excellent service. These guys do it right! Where some places get overwhelmed when they occasionally get busy Mamma Lisa is busy always and they are pros at getting your food out.