Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Experience Exceptional Dining at Top of the Bay Bistro
Top of the Bay Bistro has been a cherished dining destination in Cherry Grove, Fire Island since 1973. Our establishment combines all-American charm with breathtaking views of the Great South Bay, offering a unique blend of historic ambiance and modern culinary excellence. Under the leadership of Executive Chef Xavier Alcequiez, we present a diverse menu of American Nouveau cuisine featuring locally sourced ingredients and creative presentations. Our team of experienced professionals is dedicated to creating memorable dining experiences through exceptional service and attention to detail. With a rich legacy spanning decades, we've hosted everyone from longtime residents to celebrity guests, maintaining our reputation as Fire Island's premier dining spot.

Our commitment to quality extends to weekly specials like lobster night and live piano bar performances that enhance the vibrant atmosphere. The restaurant's distinctive Mississippi showboat-inspired decor and panoramic sunset views create an unforgettable backdrop for casual dining or special occasions. We maintain rigorous standards for food safety and service excellence while preserving the historic character that makes our establishment unique. Our staff undergoes continuous training to ensure every guest receives personalized attention and superior hospitality. From our kitchen to your table, we prioritize fresh, flavorful ingredients prepared with culinary expertise that honors both tradition and innovation.
Services
American Nouveau Cuisine Waterfront Dining Live Entertainment Private Events Weekly Specials Historic Tours
Details
  • Year established: 1973
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 50 years of culinary excellence in a historic Fire Island landmark
  • Our executive chef creates innovative American Nouveau dishes with local ingredients
  • We provide unparalleled waterfront views and unique Mississippi showboat ambiance
  • Our team maintains rigorous service standards with personalized guest attention
  • We host weekly live entertainment and special events in a vibrant atmosphere
What people say
Breathtaking sunsets Creative menu Talented musicians Historic charm Attentive service
Services
American Nouveau Cuisine
Our signature American Nouveau menu blends traditional flavors with contemporary presentation. Chef Xavier Alcequiez crafts dishes using fresh, locally sourced ingredients including Atlantic salmon, short ribs, and seasonal produce. The menu features creative combinations like honeydew arugula salad and truffle lobster mac & cheese, balancing innovation with familiar comfort.
Waterfront Dining
Dine with panoramic views of the Great South Bay from our elevated deck. The restaurant's unique location offers unobstructed sunset vistas and prime people-watching opportunities in Cherry Grove's vibrant heart. Our Nouveau-style decor complements the natural beauty with modern elegance and historic charm.
Live Entertainment
Enjoy nightly entertainment featuring talented performers like Lydia Sabosto at our piano bar. The tradition of live music continues weekly specials and seasonal events. Our sound system ensures clear acoustics while maintaining conversational comfort for diners.
Private Events
Host weddings, parties, or corporate events in our distinctive venue. The restaurant accommodates special bookings with customized menus and dedicated staff. Our historic setting provides memorable backdrops for photography and celebration.
Weekly Specials
Experience rotating culinary features including Wednesday lobster night and Sunday piano bar. Seasonal menus highlight local harvests while maintaining classic favorites. Special events showcase guest chefs and collaborative culinary creations throughout the year.
People
Xavier Alcequiez
Executive Chef
Classically trained chef with expertise in American Nouveau cuisine. Creates innovative dishes using fresh, locally sourced ingredients while maintaining traditional culinary techniques. Leads kitchen operations with focus on quality and presentation.
Ron King
Owner
Long Island native and real estate developer who revitalized the historic venue in 2007. Preserves the restaurant's legacy while implementing modern improvements. Oversees operations with commitment to maintaining the establishment's unique character.
Lydia Sabosto
Piano Entertainer
Talented musician featured in weekly live performances. Brings musical expertise and audience engagement to enhance the dining atmosphere. Contributes to the restaurant's reputation for exceptional entertainment experiences.
Questions
What type of cuisine does Top of the Bay Bistro serve?
We specialize in American Nouveau cuisine featuring fresh seafood, premium cuts, and seasonal ingredients with creative presentations.
Are reservations required?
Reservations are recommended for dinner Friday-Sunday. Call 631.597.6028 or text 516.316.4686 for bookings.
What are your operating hours?
We serve dinner Friday-Sunday from 5pm until closing. Special event hours may vary seasonally.
Can I host a private event at the restaurant?
Yes, we accommodate weddings, parties, and corporate events with customized menus and dedicated staff.
Is there live entertainment?
Enjoy nightly live music including our popular Sunday piano bar with Lydia Sabosto and special guest performers.
Reviews (4)
William L. Jones Jr
Sep 28, 2021 Report
The Braised Short Rib is absolutely on point.. fabulous service, fantastic view
Andrew Provost
Sep 18, 2021 Report
Best food in FIP/Cherry Groove. Expensive but worth it for a change of pace. Highly recommend the muscles. And the mussels.
Andrea Guerrero
Aug 03, 2021 Report
Wonderful ambiance and great option for fine dining on fire island. We had the rock shrimp, sea scallops, and roasted chicken. Everything was delicious - Reservations are recommended.
John Langan
Jul 23, 2021 Report
Weve eaten at Top of the Bay for years. In fact, my husband and I met there on a quasi blind date 19 years ago. This past week we spent our first week long summer -post pandemic vacation in Cherry Grove. We were fortunate enough to eat at TOB 4 times! Each dining experience was better than the previous one. Food is top rate, service is better than any restaurant on mainland Long Island, and the bartender will keep you coming back night after night. Its by far the best eating establishment on fire island.