Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Authentic Italian Pizza & Catering in Wantagh, NY
Prince Umberto Pizzeria has been proudly serving the Wantagh, NY community since 1970, offering authentic Italian cuisine crafted with tradition and care. Our menu features a wide array of classic dishes, from hand-tossed pizzas and calzones to hearty pastas, fresh seafood, and housemade entrees. We specialize in catering services for events of all sizes, providing freshly prepared trays of Italian favorites that impress guests and elevate any occasion. With decades of experience, our team prioritizes quality ingredients, time-honored recipes, and exceptional service to deliver meals that taste like home.Whether dining in, taking out, or ordering for a large gathering, we ensure every customer experiences the warmth and generosity of Italian hospitality. Our commitment to excellence extends to gluten-free options, competitive pricing, and a family-friendly atmosphere where everyone feels welcome. We operate with transparency, ensuring clear communication about our hours, pricing, and catering requirements, including a 24-hour notice for large orders. Our dedication to freshness, speed, and community has made us a trusted staple in Wantagh for over five decades.
Services
Pizza
Calzone
Pasta
Catering
Seafood
Gluten-Free Options
Family Specials
Delivery
Dine-In
Takeout
Details
- Year established: 1970
Highlights and features
- We have served Wantagh since 1970 with authentic Italian recipes.
- Our catering requires 24-hour notice for personalized service.
- Gluten-free pizza and calzone options available.
- We guarantee freshness in all ingredients and meals.
- Family-friendly atmosphere with competitive pricing.
What people say
Excellent pizza
Efficient service
Services
Pizza
Hand-tossed and Sicilian-style pizzas made with fresh mozzarella, housemade marinara, and premium toppings. Options include vegetarian, stuffed, and gluten-free varieties. Every pie reflects decades of Italian tradition and a commitment to quality ingredients.
Catering
Catering services for parties and events with trays of Italian favorites like baked ziti, lasagna, and chicken parmigiana. Requires 24-hour notice for order customization. Serves 818 guests with competitive pricing and delivery.
Pasta
Classic pasta dishes including al dente spaghetti, linguine, and baked specialties. Toppings range from garlic and oil to seafood fra diavolo. All pastas are made to order using traditional Italian methods and fresh ingredients.
Calzone
Folded pizzas filled with ricotta, mozzarella, and premium meats or vegetables. Baked to golden perfection, offering a handheld alternative to traditional pizza with the same authentic Italian flavor.
Seafood
Fresh seafood entrees like shrimp scampi, calamari marinara, and seafood platters for two. Prepared using time-tested Italian recipes that highlight the natural taste and texture of each ingredient.
Questions
What is Prince Umberto Pizzeria's catering notice period?
We require a 24-hour notice for catering orders to accommodate your event's needs.
Do you offer gluten-free pizza options?
Yes, we provide gluten-free pizza and calzone options for dine-in, takeout, or catering.
What areas do you deliver to?
We deliver within Wantagh, NY, and surrounding areas for individual orders and catering.
What payment methods are accepted?
We accept cash and major credit cards for all orders and catering services.
Are there family specials available?
Yes, we offer family specials starting at $39.95 plus tax, available Sunday to Thursday.
What are your operating hours?
We are open Sunday–Thursday 10 AM–9 PM, Friday–Saturday 11 AM–10 PM.
Reviews (6)
Karen F.
Jan 12, 2022
Report
I love this place... Been going here for years and highly recommend you try it. This is my "go to" place for Grandma Pizza! It's delicious! I also love their Margherita Pizza. My husband loves their regular pizza (but usually gets it with mushrooms or pepperoni). Their crust is flavorful and delicious - which is so important for good pizza.
Ming Cheng
Sep 30, 2021
Report
Tried tonight based on reviews we read. We ordered two pizzas and garlic knots. The dough for all three was sour, like sour dough. We threw away most of the food. So disappointed.
Common Sense
Sep 23, 2021
Report
Catered my daughter's party absolutely incredible service delivered everything promptly and most importantly all 10 trays were delicious and worth every cent.Keep up the great work Umberto....
Sean D.
Jun 27, 2021
Report
Great pizza! Haven't been back in a while but went the other day and the quality still holds up the same it did years ago.
James Ohagan
Apr 20, 2021
Report
Stopped in today for first time and had a reg slice. It was amazing. Probably best reg slice I've had in area since I've been hear 15 years. Counter guy was friendly as well.
Mr. Hands On
Mar 25, 2021
Report
Great tasting pizza. A crispy thin crust with a very flavorful sauce makes this pie unbelievable. Would recommended highly especially on Wednesdays when they have an amazing offer. Call to find out their pizza special!!
