Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining Experience in Commack, NY
La Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria has been a cornerstone of authentic Italian cuisine since 1974, founded by Sicilian immigrant Nunzio Cusumano. Our commitment to homemade dishes crafted with fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes has made us a beloved local institution. Over five decades, weve preserved the integrity of our original pizza while expanding our menu to include award-winning Italian specialties. Our team, many of whom have served for over 20 years, brings unparalleled expertise to every plate, whether in our dining room, takeout service, or catering. Recognized as a quarter-finalist in the Newsday Pizza Smackdown 2022, we combine tradition with innovation to deliver exceptional culinary experiences.Our catering services elevate events with authentic Italian flavors, reflecting our deep roots in the community. We prioritize transparency, using scratch-made sauces and locally sourced ingredients to ensure quality. As a family-owned business, we treat every guest like family, blending old-world hospitality with modern service standards. Our dedication to excellence has earned us a reputation as a trusted leader in Italian dining on Long Island. Today, we continue to honor our heritage while embracing new generations of diners seeking genuine Italian tradition.
Services
Italian Cuisine
Catering Services
Award-Winning Pizza
Dine-In Dining
Takeout Orders
Details
- Year established: 1974
Highlights and features
- We offer over 50 years of family-owned Italian culinary expertise.
- Our pizza was recognized as a Newsday Pizza Smackdown 2022 quarter-finalist.
- We prepare fresh tomato sauce daily using traditional Sicilian methods.
- Our staff includes team members with over 20 years of service experience.
- We provide full-service catering with customized menus for any occasion.
What people say
Award-winning pizza
Fresh ingredients
Generous portions
Family atmosphere
Exceptional catering
Services
Italian Cuisine
La Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria delivers authentic Italian cuisine crafted with fresh ingredients and traditional recipes. Our menu features homemade pasta, seafood, veal, and chicken dishes prepared using methods passed down through generations. Each plate emphasizes quality and flavor, from our signature marinara sauce made daily to our hand-tossed pizzas with house-made dough. Diners experience the warmth of Italian hospitality in our welcoming atmosphere.
Catering Services
Our premier catering services bring La Scala's authentic Italian flavors to your events. We offer customized menus for weddings, corporate functions, and private parties with options ranging from antipasti platters to multi-course meals. Our experienced team handles all details, ensuring seamless service and presentation that matches our restaurant's excellence. Menus accommodate various group sizes and dietary preferences.
Award-Winning Pizza
La Scala's pizza features hand-stretched dough topped with house-made sauces and premium ingredients. Recognized as a Newsday Pizza Smackdown 2022 quarter-finalist, our menu includes classic Neapolitan styles and creative specialties. Options range from traditional Margherita to inventive combinations like Buffalo Chicken and Baked Ziti pizzas, all baked to perfection in our professional ovens.
Dine-In Dining
Our dining room offers an immersive Italian experience with attentive service and a warm atmosphere. Guests enjoy made-to-order dishes from our extensive menu, including daily specials and seasonal offerings. The space accommodates both intimate meals and larger gatherings, featuring decor that reflects our Sicilian heritage and decades-long community presence.
Takeout Orders
La Scala provides convenient takeout options for our full menu, including family-style portions. Orders maintain the same quality as dine-in meals through careful packaging that preserves temperature and texture. We partner with DoorDash for delivery services while maintaining direct ordering options for personalized service and faster fulfillment.
People
Nunzio Cusumano
Founder
Nunzio Cusumano founded La Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria in 1974 at age 21, bringing Sicilian culinary traditions to Long Island. He developed the original pizza recipe that remains unchanged today and expanded his success to multiple Italian restaurants across the region while maintaining hands-on involvement at La Scala.
Chris
Co-Owner/Manager
Chris joined La Scala in 2003, rising from busboy to co-owner by 2015. He oversees daily operations while maintaining the restaurant's commitment to quality and family values. Chris works alongside Nunzio to preserve traditional methods while adapting to modern dining expectations.
Questions
What catering options does La Scala offer?
We provide full-service catering with customizable menus featuring antipasti, salads, pasta, meats, and desserts. Options include buffet-style or plated meals for events ranging from small gatherings to large weddings.
How long has La Scala been in business?
La Scala Restaurant has served authentic Italian cuisine since December 1974, maintaining the same pizza recipe since our founding.
What are La Scala's signature dishes?
Our signature items include house-made tomato sauce, award-winning pizza, Lobster Ravioli, Chicken Francese, and Veal Marsala. The menu also features classic Italian desserts like cannoli and tiramisu.
Does La Scala accommodate dietary restrictions?
We offer gluten-free pasta options, vegetarian dishes, and can modify many recipes to accommodate dietary needs when notified in advance.
What payment methods does La Scala accept?
We accept major credit cards and cash payments for both dine-in and takeout orders.
Is La Scala available for private events?
Yes, we host private parties and events with dedicated coordination. Packages include venue rental, customized menus, and full-service catering for groups of 60+.
Reviews (4)
Fra Frareviews
Dec 24, 2021
Report
Carlos is a fantastic waiter, he is cordial, polite and extremely professional. Especially tonight that its Christmas Eve he is delivering overall excellence and devotion. La Scala Ristorante is a wonderful restaurant to dine at. It has beautiful decor, lovely employees and delicious food that is always served up fresh and hot. Couldnt be any happier with the service tonight. On behalf of the entire La Scale Ristorante and Carlos may your Christmas be merry and bright and have a safe, healthy and wonderful new year!
Stephanie Lanzi
Dec 22, 2021
Report
I ordered a large and put some in a bowl. Thought maybe what was in my bowl wasnt mixed up. Minestrone soup. No noodles, no beans, no other vegetables. Just chunks of carrots and potatoes. Not even the right color broth. Called to inform them to throw it out because its awful and they were looking to accommodate me in anyway. I declined because I wasnt in the mood for the bare minimum but they were very apologetic.
Lisa Watson
Nov 29, 2021
Report
We waited forever to be served!!! Like forever. People came in after my small party and were served before me! I was really on edge! But the garlic knots made the wait all worth it! Ive eaten many a garlic knot, and these so far are in the best Ive ever tasted!!! Hands down!
Cara Roth
Nov 25, 2021
Report
Very good! Several options and everyone was super helpful. We did the walk up pizzeria, which was great since it was fast. Wish the pizza would have been warmer, but we ate everything! Would recommend.