Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
28 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Cuisine in Long Island
Casa di Fratelli brings over 25 years of culinary expertise to Long Island, offering an extensive menu of classic Italian dishes crafted with homemade pastas, fresh fish, and daily specials. Our chef-led team combines traditional recipes with innovative techniques to deliver a dining experience that emphasizes quality ingredients and authentic flavors. With a dedicated focus on hospitality, we cater to both on-premise events and off-site gatherings, ensuring every meal reflects our commitment to excellence.

Our menu features a diverse array of antipasti, entrees, and desserts, all prepared to showcase the richness of Italian cuisine. Whether dining in or ordering for an event, customers can expect a seamless blend of tradition and modernity in every bite.
Services
Italian Cuisine Lunch Dining Dinner Dining Catering Services Online Ordering Gift Cards
Details
  • Year established: 1998
Highlights and features
  • We have over 25 years of experience in Italian culinary arts.
  • Our menu features homemade pastas and desserts crafted daily.
  • We offer customizable catering for both on- and off-premise events.
  • Our seafood is sourced fresh daily for optimal quality.
  • We provide a diverse wine list and handcrafted cocktails.
What people say
Fresh ingredients Authentic recipes Delicious seafood Attentive staff Beautiful ambiance
Services
Catering Services
Our catering division provides customized Italian menus for weddings, corporate events, and private parties. Choose from family-style platters or plated courses, with options for both on-premise and off-premise events. With 25 years of experience, we ensure every catering order reflects the same quality and authenticity as our restaurant dining.
Italian Cuisine
A comprehensive menu featuring antipasti, homemade pastas, seafood, and meat entrees prepared using time-honored Italian techniques. Dishes include daily specials and house-made desserts like tiramisu and cannoli. Our commitment to fresh ingredients ensures authentic flavors in every meal.
Lunch Dining
Three-course prix fixe lunch options available Monday-Friday from 12:00-15:00. Menu includes soup or salad, pasta or entree, and dessert. Special selections rotate daily while maintaining traditional Italian roots.
Dinner Dining
Extensive dinner menu served nightly featuring premium seafood, veal, beef, and vegetarian options. Wine pairings and artisanal cocktails available. Reservations recommended for weekend evenings and special events.
Online Ordering
Convenient online platform for takeout orders of antipasti, entrees, desserts, and catering trays. Full menu available for pickup during regular business hours. Customization options available for large parties.
People
Giovanni Valle
Head Chef
With over 25 years in Italian cuisine, Giovanni leads our kitchen with expertise in traditional recipes and modern presentation techniques.
Carlos Valle
Co-Owner
Carlos manages daily operations and guest relations, ensuring every visit reflects our family's commitment to hospitality.
Antonio Valle
Executive Chef
Antonio specializes in seafood preparation and menu development, bringing decades of experience from Italy's coastal regions.
Questions
Do you offer gluten-free menu options?
Yes, we provide gluten-free pasta alternatives for many dishes upon request.
Can I book a private event at Casa di Fratelli?
We host private events for up to 100 guests with customizable menus and dedicated service.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept cash, Visa, MasterCard, and American Express for all services.
Do you serve lunch on weekends?
Lunch service is available Saturday 3:00-10:00 PM and Sunday 12:00-8:00 PM.
Are gift cards available for purchase?
Physical gift cards can be purchased at our restaurant or by calling 516-385-3700.
Do you offer outdoor seating?
Seasonal patio seating is available based on weather conditions and reservations.
Reviews (7)
Jane Billian
Jan 26, 2022 Report
What a wonderful time we had for a birthday celebration last evening. The staff was pleasant and very efficient. The food was delicious. The seven of us had different dishes and all was scrumptious. Also had the pleasure to listen to Rob and Patty Meade who was great. Wonderful time had by all!
Gary L.
Jan 24, 2022 Report
This is a gem in the neighborhood serving Italian classics and more. Ordered linguine white clam, veal parm, and sole Frances. All were delicious except for the overdone spaghetti and linguine. Recommend the fish because the lemon butter sauce was a nice touch. Enjoy
Pat F.
Jan 23, 2022 Report
Pulling up to this place the exterior looks unassuming. Once you walk in, it's the total opposite. I was happily surprised with the vibe. On this Friday evening in October 2021, the dimly lit bar area was already filled to capacity. The dining room, with its contemporary decor, had tables filled with happy, chatty diners. Towards the back of the dining room, our team of smiling, co-workers congregated and milled around the fairly spacious 18 person table setup. This restaurant is the type that if one table is celebrating a birthday or special occasion all patrons are a part of that celebration
Robinsue B.
Dec 29, 2021 Report
Great restaurant- good food, nice staff and huge portions! I had the lobster ravioli, a special that week, and it was amazing. The lobster flavor came out so well in the sauce, as well. My son had the chicken Parmesan and the portion was humongous, he could've eaten it for two more meals! The marinara on the chicken Parmesan was also really good, and had a nice "homemade" feel to it. They also give out a unique bruschetta with focaccia bread which was a great start to our meal. There menu is huge, so there's something for everyone. Free Parking available at the back too!
Merlene Reyes
Dec 11, 2021 Report
Had an amazing dinner for our son's college graduation. Ambiance was beautiful. Service and food were absolutely amazing! We all finished our plates which almost never happens! Portions were extremely generous and price was great! Will definitely come again!
LadyTyrol
Nov 29, 2021 Report
Ill preface my comments by first saying that my motto is I dont care the cost of a restaurant meal but it had better be excellent. My friend and I dined here Sunday evening only because of the good reviews. We were both disappointed with our appetizers. We both said they were good but nothing out of the ordinary. My friends entree was a pasta dish which was very watery with no flavor & a few pieces of chicken thrown in. I ordered chicken Marsala which I thought was good but really how can anyone screw up that dish? After a few minutes of our eating our appetizers the waiter told
N. R.
Nov 27, 2021 Report
I highly recommend this place if you're looking to host a private party in the area. They have great packages to choose from and the owner was very accommodating throughout the planning process. The food was delicious (and good size portions), the ambiance/table set up was perfect and our two servers were great. Will definitely return to Casa di Fratelli both for dinner and for private parties!