Which Insurance Agency Should You Choose in Tallahassee, FL?

Review 19 local insurance agencies in Tallahassee, FL and check what each business offers. Read customer feedback, compare agency information, and shortlist providers who can help with the types of personal or business insurance you need.
Fuqua Insurance Agency provides tailored auto, home, and commercial insurance solutions to Florida residents and businesses. With 45 years of local expertise, we offer competitive rates through partnerships with top carriers while maintaining personalized service. Our community-focused approach ensures clients receive comprehensive coverage and dedicated support.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Commercial Insurance
Saved over $300 annually Professional and helpful agents Best rates around
Kingdom Tree Insurance Group provides comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions in Tallahassee, FL. As an independent agency, we partner with top carriers to offer customized coverage for homes, vehicles, businesses, and specialized assets. Our client-focused approach emphasizes transparency, competitive pricing, and dedicated support.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Business Insurance
Accurate and easy to understand Would definitely recommend By your side every step
6 reviews
A AAA Dan's Bail Bonds
21 Years
Emergency
6 reviews
A AAA Dan's Bail Bonds provides 24/7 bail bond services in Tallahassee, FL and Greater North Florida. With over 20 years of experience, our licensed agents specialize in criminal and felony bail bonds, offering immediate assistance and personalized case management. We prioritize rapid release from custody while maintaining strict client confidentiality.
Bail Bonds Felony Bail Bonds Jail Bonds
Precise and prompt Swift and efficient Professional, efficient, and fast
6 reviews
Dave Williams
Emergency
6 reviews
Dave Williams in Tallahassee offers personalized auto, home, life, and specialized insurance solutions to protect individuals and businesses. With decades of combined experience, our team delivers tailored coverage options and exceptional customer service. We prioritize transparency, responsiveness, and community-focused support to ensure clients feel secure in their insurance decisions.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Very professional and helpful Responsive and knowledgeable team Excellent service and guidance
Premier Insurance Agency provides comprehensive insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in Tallahassee, FL. We offer personalized coverage options for auto, home, life, and commercial insurance through multiple carriers. Our independent agency model ensures clients receive competitive rates and tailored protection plans.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance
Top-class service Save you money Maintain peace of mind
5 reviews
Bill Reardon
35 Years
5 reviews
Bill Reardon, a State Farm affiliate in Tallahassee, FL, offers personalized auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions. With 26+ years of experience, we specialize in tailored coverage, free quotes, and exceptional customer service for Florida residents.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Excellent customer service Quick issue resolution Saved money on policies
Doug Croley Insurance Services provides comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions in Tallahassee, Florida. Established in 1978, we operate as an independent agency representing over 100 carriers to offer customized coverage options. Our services span auto, home, life, business, and specialty insurance with a focus on client-centric service.
Personal Insurance Commercial Insurance Life Insurance
Tyre Insurance Agency provides tailored home, auto, business, and life insurance solutions in Tallahassee, FL. With over 30 years of expertise, our independent agency offers competitive rates alongside personalized service and same-day quotes. We prioritize understanding client needs to deliver reliable coverage and peace of mind.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance
State Farm Insurance Agent State Farm Insurance Agent Tiffany Surles offers personalized Auto, Homeowners, Life, and Business Insurance solutions to residents and businesses across Florida. With over 15 years of experience, we prioritize tailored coverage, competitive pricing, and 24/7 customer support to ensure clients receive reliable protection and exceptional service.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Patient, helpful Great service Knowledgeable agents
Dick Franklin
50+ Years
Emergency
3 reviews
Dick Franklin
50+ Years
Emergency
3 reviews
Dick Franklin provides comprehensive auto, home, life, and business insurance policies tailored to Tallahassee residents. Our services emphasize personalized coverage, bundling discounts, and 24/7 support. We combine local expertise with State Farm's nationwide resources to deliver reliable protection and exceptional service.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Marcie was amazing Excellent deal Helpful and efficient
Pichard Insurance Agency provides comprehensive home, auto, and business insurance solutions in Tallahassee, Florida and surrounding counties. Established in 1970, we operate as an independent agency representing multiple carriers to help clients compare coverage options. Our experienced team offers personalized service tailored to individual insurance needs across Leon, Gadsden, Jefferson, Wakulla, and neighboring counties.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Business Insurance
Excellent service Great folks Fully engaged staff
Waterhouse Insurance & Financial Services is a full-service insurance agency in Tallahassee, FL, offering auto, home, business, and life insurance policies. We specialize in providing tailored coverage solutions with competitive pricing through multiple carrier partnerships. Our licensed agents deliver personalized service to individuals, families, and businesses across Florida.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance
Excellent customer service Very helpful agents Great insurance rates
Jerrell Lowery provides comprehensive insurance solutions in Tallahassee, FL. We specialize in auto, home, life, and business insurance policies tailored to individual needs. Our State Farm-affiliated agency combines national resources with local expertise for personalized service.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance
Excellent service Competitive pricing Knowledgeable staff
Florida KidCare offers income-based health and dental insurance for children from birth through age 19. Our program provides comprehensive coverage including doctor visits, vaccinations, dental care, and mental health services. With options for all income levels and partnerships across Florida's healthcare network, we ensure accessible, affordable care for families.
Health Insurance Plans Dental Coverage Emergency Services
North Florida Title specializes in title insurance and real estate settlement services across Florida. We facilitate secure, efficient closings for residential, commercial, and investment properties, ensuring compliance with industry regulations. Our client-focused approach emphasizes transparency, competitive pricing, and personalized support for buyers, sellers, lenders, and realtors.
Title Insurance Real Estate Settlement Title Search
North Florida Agents Network supports independent insurance agencies in North Florida through strategic partnerships, providing access to carriers, mentorship, and revenue growth opportunities. We help agencies maintain independence while increasing profitability through aggregated resources and industry expertise. Our services include agency development, carrier appointments, and perpetuation planning for sustainable growth.
Agency Development Carrier Access Mentorship Programs
Game-changer for my agency Seamless transition process 20% higher revenues
Bridges Insurance provides personalized home, auto, commercial, and specialty insurance solutions across Florida. As an independent agency, we partner with top-rated carriers to offer competitive rates and comprehensive coverage tailored to individual needs. Our client-first approach emphasizes expert guidance, local expertise, and long-term relationships built on trust.
Auto Insurance Commercial Insurance Home Insurance
Very helpful Quick response time Amazing customer service
Thielen + Insurance, Bonds, & Investments offers boutique-style insurance planning and financial advisory services across Florida. Specializing in life insurance, health coverage, retirement planning, and commercial risk management, our agency combines personalized service with industry-leading expertise. With decades of experience supporting Florida families and businesses, we focus on creating tailored protection strategies that safeguard what matters most.
Commercial Auto Insurance Life Insurance Health Insurance
Andrew Jackson Insurance provides personalized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in Tallahassee, FL. We offer auto, health, life, disability, home, boat, RV, property, liability, and professional liability insurance. Our experienced team connects clients with top providers to create tailored coverage plans.
Medical Malpractice Insurance Auto Insurance Health Insurance
Woodville (8.8 mi) Cairo (30.7 mi) Thomasville (32.8 mi) Quitman (49.0 mi)