Which Insurance Agency Should You Choose in Lexington, KY?

Review 21 local insurance agencies in Lexington, KY and check what each business offers. Read customer feedback, compare agency information, and shortlist providers who can help with the types of personal or business insurance you need.
Heritage Insurance is a full-service independent insurance agency serving Central Kentucky since 1990. We specialize in auto, home, life, business, and workers' compensation insurance, offering tailored solutions through partnerships with reputable carriers. Our client-focused approach prioritizes personalized service, competitive pricing, and comprehensive coverage to meet individual and business needs.
Auto Insurance Life Insurance Business Insurance
Strong Insurance Agency is a family owned and operated independent insurance agency serving Kentucky and Tennessee since 2009. We specialize in providing comprehensive insurance solutions including home, auto, business, life, and health insurance. Our experienced team offers personalized service to help clients find customized coverage that meets their specific needs and budget.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Business Insurance
Excellent customer service Go above and beyond Super great plan
7 reviews
Keith Renfro
19 Years
7 reviews
Keith Renfro provides comprehensive personal and business insurance solutions in Central Kentucky. Specializing in auto, home, renters, life, and commercial insurance, our agency focuses on protecting residents and businesses with tailored coverage. With 17 years of experience and 24/7 client support, we deliver personalized service to meet evolving insurance needs.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Renters Insurance
Quick policy setup Exceptional service Knowledgeable staff
Andrew Wade
14 Years
Emergency
6 reviews
Andrew Wade
14 Years
Emergency
6 reviews
Andrew Wade provides comprehensive insurance solutions including auto, home, life, and business coverage through State Farm. We specialize in personalized risk assessment and policy optimization for Lexington residents and businesses. Our customer-centric approach combines 24/7 emergency support with annual policy reviews to ensure ongoing protection alignment.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Kind helpful staff Professional and knowledgeable Quick policy adjustments
6 reviews
Adam McDonald
Emergency
6 reviews
Adam McDonald provides comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions in Lexington, KY. Our agency offers auto, home, life, business, and specialty insurance products, along with financial services and investment options. We combine national resources with local expertise to deliver personalized coverage solutions.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Great agent Excellent customer service Quick and easy process
Brian Shelton
17 Years
Emergency
6 reviews
Brian Shelton
17 Years
Emergency
6 reviews
Brian Shelton provides comprehensive insurance solutions including auto, home, life, and business coverage across central Kentucky. Our Lexington-based agency combines personalized service with State Farm's national resources, offering bilingual support and financial services. With 15+ years of local expertise and 500+ five-star reviews, we focus on tailored risk management for individuals and businesses.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Exceptional service Best rates around Fantastic customer service
Cambridge Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Lexington, Kentucky offering personalized personal and commercial insurance solutions. We provide auto, home, life, and business insurance policies tailored to individual needs while maintaining strong carrier relationships. Our agency combines local expertise with comprehensive coverage options to protect clients from financial risks.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Commercial Auto
Al Torstrick Insurance Agency is an independent insurance firm in Lexington, KY, offering personalized coverage solutions for personal, business, and employee benefits needs. With over six decades of experience, we help clients secure tailored insurance plans from top-rated carriers at competitive rates. Our team prioritizes client relationships, community involvement, and comprehensive protection across multiple states.
Personal Auto Insurance Home Insurance Business Auto Insurance
Efficient and friendly Quick to respond Best coverage possible
5 reviews
Michelle Oberto
Emergency
5 reviews
Michelle Oberto provides comprehensive insurance solutions in Lexington, KY, specializing in auto, home, life, business, and health coverage. Our agency combines State Farm's national resources with personalized service tailored to individual needs. With 12 years of experience and a 4.8/5 Google rating, we deliver reliable protection while prioritizing community connections and exceptional customer care.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance
Awesome team Saved money Professional and helpful
4 reviews
Clear Title
22 Years
4 reviews
Clear Title provides comprehensive real estate title services and closing solutions across Kentucky. Specializing in title searches, owner's and lender's insurance, and professional closing coordination, we ensure secure property transactions for homeowners, realtors, and mortgage professionals. Since 2004, our experienced team has maintained Kentucky's highest standards for accuracy, efficiency, and client satisfaction in real estate transactions.
Title Searches Closing Services Title Insurance
Prompt and exceedingly helpful Fast and accommodating Thorough explanations of process
Renee Jackson Insurance Agency provides comprehensive personal, business, and employee benefits insurance solutions tailored to protect clients from unexpected risks. Specializing in home, auto, life, and commercial insurance, we deliver personalized service backed by nearly 30 years of industry experience. Licensed across 12 states, we combine local knowledge with access to multiple carriers to ensure optimal coverage for diverse client needs.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Renters Insurance
Knowledgeable and reliable Properly insured Personalized service
Summit Insurance Group offers comprehensive insurance solutions including home, auto, business, life, toy, Medicare supplement, and group health insurance. Based in Lexington, Kentucky, we serve clients across Kentucky, Maryland, Ohio, Tennessee, and West Virginia with personalized service and competitive rates. Our veteran-owned agency prioritizes community trust, affordability, and expert guidance to protect clients' financial security.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Business Insurance
Saved over $1,200 annually Quick claim response Personalized policy solutions
4 reviews
Dawn Stice
Emergency
4 reviews
Dawn Stice provides comprehensive auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions in Lexington, KY. Our agency combines local expertise with State Farm's nationwide resources to deliver personalized coverage and exceptional customer service. With 50 years of combined experience, we prioritize transparency, community involvement, and 24/7 client support.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Prompt claims resolution Personalized policy guidance 24/7 availability
Carpenter-Warren Insurance Agency provides comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions in central Kentucky. Established in 1927, we specialize in home, auto, life, disability, business, and workers' compensation insurance tailored to individual client needs. Our family-owned agency maintains strong carrier relationships while delivering personalized service through direct agent-client communication.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Life Insurance
Tiffany Thacker offers personalized auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions in Lexington, KY. Led by experienced agent Tiffany Thacker, we provide tailored coverage and exceptional service. Our focus on individual client needs ensures comprehensive protection for families and businesses.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance
Best people an insurance agency Super helpful Amazing customer service
High Street Title provides comprehensive title services including commercial title work, foreclosure titles, and document retrieval since 1986. Specializing in fast turnaround times with 24-hour service availability, we serve clients nationwide from our Lexington, Kentucky headquarters. Our team combines industry expertise with personalized service to deliver accurate title insurance and reports for residential and commercial properties.
Commercial Title Work Foreclosure Titles Document Retrieval
Same day turnaround Professional group Highest service rating
Kentucky Insurance & Investment Group is an independent insurance agency offering personalized home, auto, life, health, and business insurance solutions. We partner with multiple carriers to provide competitive pricing and comprehensive coverage tailored to individual and commercial needs. Our experienced team delivers expert risk management guidance across Kentucky and seven additional states.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Life Insurance
Best choice for insurance needs Very satisfied with assistance Easy to work with
Kentucky Home Life Insurance provides life insurance solutions including whole life, term policies, and specialized coverage for seniors and children. We serve Kentucky residents through independent agents, offering guaranteed premiums, cash value accumulation, and flexible protection options. Our policies prioritize long-term financial security and adaptability to lifes changing circumstances.
Whole Life Insurance 10 Year Level Term 20 Year Level Term
CROWN TITLE provides title insurance, real estate closing services, and property transaction solutions to clients across Kentucky. We specialize in deed preparation, title examinations, escrow management, and right-of-way negotiations. Our experienced team ensures secure, compliant transactions for government agencies, corporations, and individual property buyers.
Title Insurance Real Estate Closings Deed Preparation
Jeff Briggs
46 Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
Jeff Briggs
46 Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
Jeff Briggs in Lexington, KY provides auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions with personalized service since 1980. Our experienced team offers tailored coverage options and 24/7 support for policyholders across Central Kentucky. We combine industry expertise with local knowledge to protect families and businesses through comprehensive insurance planning.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance
Great service Quick response Helpful staff
Not rated yet
Insurance Care
30 Years
Not rated yet
Insurance Care is an independent insurance agency in Lexington, KY, specializing in life and health insurance solutions for individuals and small businesses. Since 1996, we have provided personalized coverage options, leveraging over 30 years of industry expertise to help clients navigate complex insurance decisions. Our client-first approach ensures tailored solutions that protect families and businesses while maintaining transparency and ethical standards.
Health Insurance Medicare Insurance Life Insurance
Nicholasville (11.7 mi) Versailles (12.3 mi) Frankfort (22.9 mi) Richmond (23.2 mi) Harrodsburg (26.7 mi) Lancaster (29.3 mi) Berea (34.5 mi) Stanford (36.2 mi) Shelbyville (40.8 mi) Ewing (43.8 mi)