Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
34 Years
experience
Your Local Pizza & Ice Cream Destination in Sparta, OH
Since 1992, our family-owned establishment has been a cornerstone of Sparta, OH, serving authentic Italian cuisine crafted with homemade recipes and fresh ingredients. We take pride in being more than just a place to eat our mission is to create memorable dining experiences through quality meals and a welcoming atmosphere. Our commitment to excellence is evident in every aspect of our operation, from our signature pizzas baked fresh daily to our 16+ homemade ice cream flavors. We understand the importance of convenient dining options, which is why we offer carry-out, drive-thru, and dine-in services. Our team combines generations of culinary expertise with a passion for hospitality, ensuring every guest receives exceptional service.

We actively engage with our local community, supporting events like little league celebrations and serving as a gathering place for residents of Marengo, Chesterville, and Mt. Liberty. Our kitchen follows time-honored traditions while embracing innovation, as demonstrated by our gluten-free pizza options. While adapting to changing circumstances including recent adjustments to our dining room operations we remain dedicated to maintaining the high standards that have earned us customer loyalty for over two decades.
Services
Pizza Pasta Subs Ice Cream Gluten-Free Options Salads Carry-Out Drive-Thru Private Catering Family Meals
Details
  • Year established: 1992
Highlights and features
  • We offer 23+ years of experience serving authentic Italian cuisine in Morrow County.
  • Our kitchen uses family recipes passed down through generations for authentic flavor.
  • We provide gluten-free pizza options for dietary needs with minimal additional cost.
  • Our 16+ homemade ice cream flavors create unique dessert experiences locally.
  • Our staff combines culinary heritage with modern hospitality standards.
What people say
Fresh ingredients Best pizza Friendly staff Amazing bread Homemade quality
Services
Pizza
Our brick-oven pizzas use fresh ingredients and family recipes dating back generations. Customers can customize with numerous toppings or choose from signature combinations. The dough and sauce are made daily in-house, ensuring consistent quality and authentic flavor that has made us a local favorite for over two decades.
Ice Cream
We offer 16+ house-made ice cream flavors, ranging from classic vanilla to seasonal specialties. Our desserts complement meals perfectly, with popular options like pumpkin pie ice cream. While soft serve is available, traditional hard ice cream remains our standout offering that draws customers from neighboring communities.
Gluten-Free Options
Our kitchen provides gluten-free pizza crusts for an additional $2. This accommodation maintains the same quality standards as regular menu items while catering to special dietary requirements. The option demonstrates our commitment to serving diverse customer needs while maintaining traditional flavor profiles.
Catering Services
We provide full-service catering for private parties, including family gatherings and sports team celebrations. Our menu includes party-sized specialty pizzas, pasta platters, and custom sub arrangements. While serving staff isn't available during events, we ensure timely order preparation and presentation that meets our usual quality standards.
Dining Options
We offer multiple service formats to accommodate different needs, including carry-out, drive-thru, and dine-in. The dining room operates with self-service during food orders, creating a hybrid experience that balances safety with traditional restaurant atmosphere. Each service format maintains our commitment to fresh, quality ingredients.
Questions
When are you reopening for full service?
We plan to reopen fully on the 15th. Please confirm current hours by calling ahead before visiting our Sparta location.
What pizza options do you offer?
We serve classic and signature pizzas with house-made dough/sauce, plus gluten-free crusts available for $2 extra.
Do you have ice cream flavors?
We offer 16+ in-house made ice cream flavors, including seasonal specialties like pumpkin pie ice cream.
What service options are available?
We provide carry-out, drive-thru, and dine-in options with self-service during food orders.
Can you accommodate large groups?
Yes! We cater private parties with advanced orders, perfect for little league celebrations and family gatherings.
Reviews (7)
Rob Courtney
Dec 13, 2021 Report
The Highland Sub has to be the best sandwich in Ohio.
Fantastic service: the entire staff went above and beyond when they absolutely didn't have to to make this a great visit. Very impressed!
Dustin Eades
Oct 24, 2021 Report
Stopped in while working in the area. Awesome service with a smile. Really lovely smile too! food was good and made with care. Definitely recommended!!
Ray Neighbarger
Oct 20, 2021 Report
Milk shake is just cold chocolate milk. The ice cream part my order was made 15 min before the rest was made. Staff either doesn't care or is untrained.
John Sheldon
Oct 11, 2021 Report
Love this place food is always good ! I usually get a pepperoni with extra cheese but their subs are also the bomb The staff is absolutely amazing ! Everytime I go they are super friendly and polite. Definitely recommend this place for anyone looking for a great pizza or sub !!
Jayson Waits
Sep 11, 2021 Report
Have stopped here in the past while passing through for ice cream. This was first time getting lunch and ate outside. Food was really good especially my pizza. Of course we topped it off with ice cream!
Howard Shaw
Aug 24, 2021 Report
The pizza and subs are definitely fresh. You can taste the difference in the food. My wife abd and I really like it and have been back already.
Laura Shepherd
Jul 29, 2021 Report
Small, side of the road ice cream stand. Workers were kind. They seemed new. Good ice cream. We did not try the food. But they had several drive through food pick-ups while we were there. Picnic tables outside for eating.