Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining & Catering in Mount Vernon
Since 1939, Mazza's has been a cornerstone of Mount Vernon, Ohio's culinary scene, rooted in Italian heritage and family tradition. Our hand-stretched Neapolitan-style pizzas, crafted with house-made dough and premium ingredients like Grande Mozzarella and organic California tomatoes, reflect decades of perfected technique. Recognized as a Top Ten Diners' Choice Winner and #2 Best Italian Restaurant in Greater Columbus for multiple years, we combine nostalgic charm with modern hospitality across our dining room, bar/lounge, and banquet facilities.

Our catering services extend this legacy to off-site events, offering made-from-scratch meals for gatherings of all sizes. With three generations of the Mazza family stewarding operations, we maintain a commitment to quality that has earned us visits from celebrities, politicians, and NFL Hall of Famers throughout our history.
Services
Neapolitan-style pizzas Catering services Banquet facilities Online ordering Rewards program
Details
  • Year established: 1939
Highlights and features
  • We offer 85 years of expertise in authentic Italian cuisine and hospitality.
  • Our Neapolitan-style pizzas use house-made dough and premium ingredients daily.
  • Recognized as Top Ten Diners' Choice Winner for multiple years.
  • Host events in our dedicated banquet room accommodating 15-80 guests.
  • Catering services available with customizable menus for any occasion.
What people say
Award-winning pizzas Exceptional service Historic charm Great catering Family recipes
Services
Neapolitan-style pizzas
Our hand-stretched Neapolitan-style pizzas feature house-made dough and premium ingredients like Grande Mozzarella and organic California tomatoes. Each pizza is crafted using traditional techniques passed down through three generations. The result is a perfectly balanced combination of authentic flavor and modern presentation that has earned us regional acclaim.
Catering services
We provide full-service catering for events of all sizes, offering made-from-scratch meals with 24-48 hour notice. Our menu includes party-sized pans serving 8-20 people with classic Italian dishes and our Famous Mazzas Salad. Dedicated catering managers ensure seamless execution for both on-site and off-site events.
Banquet facilities
Our banquet rooms accommodate 15-80 guests with customizable menus and full-service amenities. Features include premier audio/visual equipment, private dining managers, and chef-prepared meals. Ideal for weddings, corporate events, and family celebrations with both semi-private and private space options available.
Online ordering
We offer convenient online ordering for takeout and delivery through third-party platforms. This service provides 7-day availability for most menu items, with dedicated hours for digital orders. Customers can access our full menu including specialty pizzas and classic Italian dishes through our digital platforms.
Rewards program
Our rewards program offers instant cash back on purchases with exclusive VIP promotions. Members receive a $5 signup bonus and earn points redeemable for future visits. The program includes tiered benefits and special offers designed to reward frequent guests and enhance dining experiences.
Questions
What makes Mazza's Neapolitan-style pizzas unique?
Our pizzas use hand-stretched dough made daily and premium ingredients like Grande Mozzarella and organic California tomatoes, following traditional techniques perfected over 85 years.
Do you offer catering services for large events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering with customizable menus for events of all sizes, including party-sized pans serving 8-20 people with 24-48 hour notice.
What banquet facilities are available?
Our banquet rooms accommodate 15-80 guests with private dining options, chef-prepared meals, and premier audio/visual equipment for weddings, corporate events, and celebrations.
Are online ordering and delivery available?
Yes, we offer online ordering through third-party platforms for takeout and delivery seven days a week during specified hours.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards and digital payment options through our online ordering platforms, with specific methods available at our physical location.
How can I join the rewards program?
Sign up at our website or in-restaurant to receive a $5 bonus, earn cash back on purchases, and access exclusive VIP promotions.
Videos
Reviews (6)
Tyler Croskey
Jan 24, 2022 Report
First impression was the outside look promising. The inside however looked odd. The booths were cheap as you could feel everything the person behind you was doing. We noticed that the glasses on our table were disgusting and looked like they hadnt been cleaned. Our waitress was okay. The food was average as well. Sauce was watered down for the spaghetti and meatballs as well as the fettuccine Alfredo. Meatballs werent done. Might give it a try again. But not for a long time.
Joyce Van Horn
Jan 18, 2022 Report
Went for New Years dinner. Had live jazz band and special menu. We chose steak and stuffed lobster tail. The steak was good but there was only one bite of lobster in the tail. Tables were very close together which made me uncomfortable. Most patrons did not were masks at any time. Over all it was just a good night out for my husband and myself.
Steven Spragg
Jan 10, 2022 Report
Steak - 60% inedible fat. Prime Rib Sandwich - Garlic Bread good, Prime Rib well done and fatty, came with salad/Italian dressing on it
Hamburger - raw and cold in the middle
Fettuccine Alfredo - good
Fries - Good
Mozzarella Sticks - Good
Bread - Good
Drinks - Good
Never brought steak knife or steak sauce despite being requested. Water glasses were filthy, brought new ones that were roughly the same. Atmosphere is good. Would not come back.
Colin Reid
Oct 12, 2021 Report
Great food. The manager or owner came to the table personally, and challenged my 5 year old to finish his meal and he'd get a piece of chocolate cake. As promised, it wasn't on the bill, so we added it to the tip.
Keli Oberst
Oct 02, 2021 Report
We found our new fav restaurant in Mt. Vernon. Monday was our first time there and food was great, although I wish they had garlic sticks or rolls and plain garlic bread (not smothered in cheese) served with meals instead of plain bread. Our waitress Danielle was excellent even though she was very busy.
Arielle C.
Jul 20, 2021 Report
The Famous Salad, Eggplant Parm, and the Chicken Masala are incredible. 10/10 would definitely return.