Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Authentic Italian Pizza & More in Powell, OH
Carlucci's Pizzeria has been a cornerstone of Powell's culinary scene for over 15 years, dedicated to crafting authentic Italian cuisine with unwavering attention to quality. Since taking ownership in December 2015, we have maintained the tradition of preparing everything in-house using the freshest ingredients. Our dough is made daily, meats are sliced fresh, and even our sausage is cooked in stone-deck ovens to ensure unparalleled flavor. We specialize in creating made-to-order pizzas with perfectly crisp crusts baked at 600 degrees, alongside hearty pastas, loaded strombolis, and specialty subs. Our commitment to quality extends to every menu item, from our handcrafted pepperoni cups to our housemade sauces and dressings.

We believe in the value of time-honored techniques and take pride in serving meals that reflect our deep culinary expertise. Located just north of Columbus, we welcome both locals and visitors to experience our dedication to Italian culinary traditions. Our operating hours are designed to accommodate both casual diners and those seeking late-night cravings, with weekend service extending until 11:00 PM. We invite you to taste the difference that fresh ingredients and traditional methods make in every bite.
Services
Stone-Oven Pizza Housemade Pasta Specialty Stromboli Italian Subs Appetizers & Wings
Highlights and features
  • We use fresh ingredients prepared daily in-house for optimal flavor
  • Our stone-deck ovens bake pizzas at 600 degrees for perfect crispness
  • We maintain traditional Italian recipes passed down through generations
  • Our menu features locally sourced Ezzo Sausage Co. pepperoni cups
  • We offer extended weekend hours to accommodate late-night cravings
What people say
Classic Italian pizza Welcoming energy Perfectly crisp Delicious Stromboli
Services
Stone-Oven Pizza
Hand-tossed pizzas baked in 600-degree stone ovens for perfect crispness. Available in four sizes with over 20 toppings including premium options like chicken and anchovy. Specialty pizzas feature unique combinations like Buffalo Chicken with bleu cheese crumbles and Mexican Taco with seasoned beef.
Housemade Pasta
Traditional pasta dishes served with salad and garlic bread. Features spaghetti with meatballs, penne with house sauce, and custom pasta options. All sauces and doughs are prepared daily using family recipes passed down through generations.
Specialty Stromboli
Fresh-baked strombolis filled with premium meats and cheeses. Choose from classic combinations like pepperoni and sausage or build your own with four toppings. Served with housemade pizza sauce for dipping, available in four sizes from 11" to 17".
Italian Subs
Authentic Italian sandwiches made on fresh-baked rolls. Options include the Big Punisher with six meats and extra cheese, Chicken Parmesan with fried chicken patties, and vegetarian options with fresh vegetables. All subs can be upgraded to double meat for an additional charge.
Appetizers & Wings
Over a dozen shareable starters including pepperoni chips from Ezzo Sausage Co., jumbo wings with eight sauce options, and housemade mozzarella sticks. Features traditional Italian favorites like fried mushrooms and modern twists like buffalo chicken poppers with crispy bacon.
Questions
What makes Carlucci's pizza crust unique?
Our dough is prepared daily and baked in 600-degree stone ovens, creating a perfectly crisp crust that can't be replicated by standard pizza ovens.
Do you offer gluten-free pizza options?
While we don't have gluten-free dough, we offer several naturally gluten-free menu items including salads, wings, and our pepperoni chip appetizer with ranch dip.
Can I customize my stromboli toppings?
Yes! Our build-your-own stromboli includes cheese plus any four ingredients of your choice, available in four sizes from 11" to 17".
What are your weekend operating hours?
We're open Saturday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM and Sunday from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM to accommodate both lunch and late-night cravings.
Do you serve lunch during the week?
Yes! From Monday through Thursday we serve lunch starting at 4:00 PM, with full menu availability including our specialty subs and pasta dishes.
Reviews (7)
Paige Erdeljac
Dec 27, 2021 Report
Easy 5 stars! The pizza is absolutely fantastic!! Easy to order over the phone or online. The staff are incredibly friendly every single time. I highly highly highly recommend this place!
Joseph R.
Dec 08, 2021 Report
One of the best pizza and stromboli places in the Columbus area. I used to come here like one a week and make a point to come here every time I visit. The best stromboli is their house stromboli with no onions. It's great because usually pizza places don't serve good sauce with stromboli but this sauce is some of the best in the world.
Brandon T.
Dec 06, 2021 Report
Great little neighborhood pizza joint. If you appreciate Columbus-style pizza this place should be on your list. Good service. Crust is solid, the cheese and sauce mix works and the toppings are great.
Margaret Kim Montgomery
Oct 31, 2021 Report
Just want to thank you at Carlucci's! I appreciate SO MUCH that when a mistake is made (which is rare)...you make it right! We recommend you to family, friends and all!
J. Duncan
Oct 17, 2021 Report
Hello, love your pizza and never had an issue. We usually like picking it up our selves but we got it delivered today. We got it this evening and the pizza was pretty much was folded onto itself and clumped. It was alittle cold too but thats expected with delivery We will return as customer But will probably refrain from ordering delivery again
Rajiv Gupta
Sep 23, 2021 Report
Hands down best pizza in Dublin definitely top 5 in columbus. Blows Masseys out of the water..... what makes them the best is that they are consistent EVERY time.
Jay Risheh
Sep 18, 2021 Report
Its my first experiences. The order came in 15 minutes earlier than promised
Unfortunately both pizzas are extremely burned. We had to scramble to make it up to the disappointed children.