Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Hometown Pizza Destination Since 1971
Since 1971, Eagles Pizza has been a cornerstone of New Albany, Ohio, serving as a hometown family restaurant dedicated to quality food and community connection. Our menu features handcrafted pizzas, fresh subs, hearty dinners, and custom catering options for events of all sizes, all made with premium ingredients and time-tested recipes. The historic building, originally constructed in 1856 as a country store, blends old-world charm with modern comfort, offering both dine-in and carry-out experiences.

Our team, many of whom have worked here for years, takes pride in maintaining the traditions established by the Keesee family while adapting to modern tastes. From our signature thin-crust pizzas to our gluten-free options, every dish reflects our commitment to excellence. We specialize in creating memorable meals for casual gatherings, corporate events, and holiday celebrations, serving the New Albany area with the same dedication that has made us a local institution for over five decades.
Services
Pizza Subs & Sandwiches Catering Dine-In Carry-Out Gluten-Free Options Party Pans Boneless Wings Kids Meals Dessert Pizza
Details
  • Year established: 1971
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned since 1971 with deep roots in New Albany's history
  • Offering gluten-free pizza options and diverse menu selections
  • Catering services for events up to 25 guests with 24-hour notice
  • Historic dining location preserving original 1856 architectural features
  • Team members with decades of combined experience in hospitality
Services
Pizza
Our handcrafted pizzas feature premium toppings on thin-crispy or Chicago-style pan crusts. Signature options include All The Way with seven ingredients and Taco Pizza with seasoned hamburger and crisp lettuce. Gluten-free crusts available for custom creations.
Subs & Sandwiches
Freshly made subs with quality meats and cheeses on our signature Villa sub bun. Choose from 14 varieties including Meat Ball, Sausage, and Turkey subs with house-made toppings and sauces.
Catering
Full-service catering for gatherings up to 25 guests. Offerings include party pans of baked spaghetti, salads, and boneless chicken wings. Available with 24-hour notice for corporate events, weddings, and family reunions.
Dine-In
Historic dining room accommodating up to 60 guests in a preserved 1856 building. Experience original architectural features while enjoying made-to-order meals in a family-friendly atmosphere with seating for casual visits.
Gluten-Free Options
Dedicated gluten-free menu items including pizza crusts and Ham/Salami, Turkey, or Cheese Subs. Clearly labeled options ensure safe dining for guests with dietary restrictions while maintaining full flavor.
Questions
Does Eagles Pizza offer catering services?
Yes, we provide catering for events up to 25 guests with party pans of baked spaghetti, salads, and boneless chicken wings. Orders require 24-hour notice.
Are gluten-free options available?
Yes, we offer gluten-free pizza crusts and subs. Please inform staff about dietary restrictions when ordering.
What are the restaurant's historical origins?
Our building opened as a country store in 1847 and became Eagles Pizza in 1971. The preserved structure features original walls and tin ceilings.
What payment methods are accepted?
We accept cash and all major credit cards. Checks are no longer accepted for payments.
Do you have dine-in capacity?
Yes, our historic dining room accommodates up to 60 guests with regular operating hours for lunch and dinner.
Videos
Reviews (5)
Robert B.
Jan 30, 2022 Report
Always great pizza at Eagles Pizza. The prices are great people are great they even have cakes from rush bakery so if you need a birthday cake they have them in all flavors. If you have yet to try this location in New Albany you are missing out for sure they have something for everyone on their menu and it's kind of like eating at an historical pizza place where people still act the way they did before the pandemic. Thank God for a place like eagles pizza still in this world
Julie H.
Dec 27, 2021 Report
Consistency is key to good food and Eagles Pizza never disappoints! Barbecue chicken pizza is perfect! Great ingredients and perfectly baked, crispy. Salad is fresh and they don't skimp on the Marzetti salad dressing. We've been here 5 years and never get tired of Eagles Pizza!
Macie P.
Dec 22, 2021 Report
I always have a great experience at Eagles for takeout. I actually have never dined in, but I would like to at some point. I love thin crust pizzas, and eagles does a great job with theirs. The crust is flaky and crispy. I love asking for it well done and having the extra crispy pepperonis. Overall, Eagles has had timely service with good quality pizza each time that I have visited.
Nik S.
Nov 26, 2021 Report
This is one of those small places that someone recommended a few years ago and it was amazing. I have never been disappointed with anything I have ordered. This is the first place I ever tried a bacon pizza and it has yet to be matched. The crust is great and there's not too much and not too little. It's a good place for a dinner out with friends or family.
Dylan S.
Sep 21, 2021 Report
Working at a job site with a customer, they swore by this pizza and these subs, they were not wrong! The sandwiches were so flavorful and huge! Not pictured was the delicious meat lovers type pizza. It was on a slightly thick crust so everything stayed on the pizza. Bummed out i'm only here for a day because i'd love to try another pizza from there!