Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
41 Years
experience
Authentic Pizza & More Since 1985 in Batavia, NY
Ficarella's Pizzeria has been serving Batavia, NY since 1985, establishing itself as the oldest family-run pizzeria in the area. Our commitment to quality ingredients and traditional recipes has made us a local favorite for pizza, subs, pasta, and specialty dishes. We offer dine-in, pickup, delivery, and a unique drive-thru window for convenient service. Our menu features hearth-baked pizzas, specialty subs, fresh salads, and daily lunch specials crafted with care. We proudly support local suppliers like Mumford Dairy & Meat, ensuring fresh, regional ingredients in our dishes. Our loyalty program rewards customers with points for every order, including free birthday pizzas.

With extended hours seven days a week, we cater to both casual diners and sports enthusiasts through themed events and group viewing experiences. Our team prioritizes friendly service and consistent quality, creating an inviting atmosphere for families and individuals alike. From classic pepperoni to innovative specialty pizzas, we maintain culinary excellence across our diverse menu. Celebrating over four decades in business, we continue evolving while honoring our founding principles of hospitality and craftsmanship.
Services
Hearth Baked Pizza Pan Pizza Specialty Pizza Chicken Wings Calzones Cold Subs Hot Subs Pasta Dinners Fish Fries Lunch Specials
Details
  • Year established: 1985
Highlights and features
  • We've served Batavia since 1985 with consistent quality and family values
  • Our pizza drive-thru window offers unique convenience for busy customers
  • We support local agriculture through partnerships with regional suppliers
  • Our loyalty program rewards customers with free food for every purchase
  • We maintain strict quality control across our diverse menu of 100+ items
What people say
Best pizza in town Great food, service Outstanding atmosphere Fast and polite service Never had a bad meal
Services
Hearth Baked Pizza
Our signature hearth-baked pizzas feature fresh dough cooked in traditional ovens, available in seven sizes from 10" to 32-slice party trays. Customers choose from 20+ toppings including premium meats and fresh vegetables. Each pizza uses house-made sauce and high-quality mozzarella cheese for authentic flavor.
Chicken Wings
We offer 16 sauce options for traditional and boneless wings, including house favorites like Boss Sauce and Kickin' Bourbon. Wings come in six portion sizes from half-orders to 50-piece buckets. All orders include celery and blue cheese, with extra sauces available for additional charges.
Specialty Subs
Our specialty subs feature premium ingredients like Angus beef, grilled chicken, and house-made meatballs on fresh-baked bread. Signature options include the A1 F Bomber with steak and onion rings and the Southwest Steak Bomber with melted mozzarella. Available in two sizes with customizable cheese options.
Pasta Dinners
Homemade spaghetti sauce accompanies all pasta dinners, which include garlic bread and side salad. Options range from classic spaghetti with meatballs to Chicken Parmesan and stuffed rigatoni. Customers may add grilled vegetables or chicken upgrades to select dishes for additional charges.
Fish Fries
Friday fish fry specials feature North Atlantic haddock prepared three ways: baked, traditional fry, or sandwich style. All fish fry orders include coleslaw, bread, lemon, and tartar sauce. Additional seafood options include clam strips and honey-battered shrimp baskets available daily.
Questions
What are your current operating hours?
We're open Monday-Wednesday 3 PM-10 PM and Sunday/Thursday-Saturday 11 AM-10 PM.
Do you offer gluten-free pizza options?
Yes, we provide gluten-free crust and cauliflower crust pizzas with standard toppings available.
Can I earn rewards for repeat orders?
Our loyalty program awards points for every purchase, redeemable for free menu items including pizza and wings.
Do you have catering options for large groups?
We offer party-sized pizzas, subs, and platters for events with advance ordering available through our website.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, mobile payments, and cash for both online and in-person orders.
Is your drive-thru window always open?
Our unique pizza drive-thru operates during regular business hours with full menu availability.
Reviews (6)
Keith Gierke
Dec 26, 2021 Report
Recognize the greatness,
I love pizza and there is only two joints in town that have good zaa. Ficarella's and "Unmentioned." This is a Ficarella review. I have seen the reviews here and I am astonished at what some people have said. Your subs are giant, deals are good and not to mention, best boneless wings in town. so you had a pizza underdone.... what if there was a new worker? Perhaps next time go to the store for you issues instead of the internet. Good job to all that make it possible.
Stephanie Steigerwald
Sep 21, 2021 Report
I love the food bit next time make the door hours match your website! We sat outside your business for an hour waiting for you to open at 11am on a Tuesday to find out on your website you changed to 3pm. Were not from area. Thanks!
Jonnyonwheels
Aug 21, 2021 Report
After just moving out to Batavia we decided to try Ficarellas after getting their flier in the mail (and being able to order online). Pizza and wings were piping hot when they arrived at my door. Ordered right in the middle of peak dinner time (5:45p)on a Thursday and it showed up in an hour. Driver was friendly and polite. Fresh dough, good sauce(flavor & amount), good amount of cheese and pepperoni, bottom crust had a little more chew than expected but not bad, could just be the hearth oven or b/c they were busy? Wings were good, mild sauce was tangy and not too much heat. Will definitely
Chad Higgins
Aug 20, 2021 Report
All the food here is outstanding and I am always greeted with polite and extremely friendly staff whether ordering by phone or in person. By far best Pizzeria experience in Batavia ny. Would highly recommend!
Liz Lawrence
Jul 17, 2021 Report
Absolutely hands down the most genuine restaurant I have ever been to. As out of towners we showed up at 9:55PM, not realizing they close at 10PM. They invited us to dine in with the full open menu, smiles on their faces, the most personable employees. Their food was excellent! Just an overall great atmosphere! Thank you for being so accommodating, very much appreciated!
- The Blovat and Lawrence family- Ilion NY
John Satella
Jul 03, 2021 Report
Ordered the party deal on Sunday and everything was cooked to perfection. Pizza was very tasty and the dough was perfect. Wings were cooked perfect and the amount of sauce was just right...they weren't swimming in sauce and they weren't dry. Best pizza place in Batavia hands down. I don't think I've ever had a bad meal here and i've been coming here for over 15 years.