Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
49 Years
experience
Experience Classic Steakhouse Dining in Churchville
Established in 1977, The Johnson House has become a cornerstone of Rochester's dining scene through dedication to quality, tradition, and hospitality. Our open-hearth grill prepares premium cuts of steak, fresh seafood, and classic entrees using methods unchanged since our founding. The restaurant's historic three-story brick building, originally constructed in 1885, maintains its original charm with features like a baby grand piano and fireplace. We specialize in creating memorable dining experiences through our private party rooms that accommodate events from 30 to 70 guests. Our family-owned operation continues the legacy of Mike and Peggy Naughton, who transformed this 1946 liquor license holder into a regional culinary destination.

The menu showcases time-tested favorites like Chateaubriand and Steak Stilton alongside seasonal specials. Our commitment to excellence extends to live weekend music performances and meticulously maintained dining spaces that reflect our Irish heritage. With three generations of family involvement, we maintain hands-on oversight of every aspect from food preparation to guest relations. The 2020 dining room renovation preserved historic elements while incorporating modern comforts, ensuring our tradition of hospitality endures for future generations.
Services
Steak Entrees Seafood Dining Private Parties Appetizers Desserts Wine Selection Cocktail Menu Kids Menu Live Music Takeout Service
Details
  • Year established: 1977
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned since 1977 with three generations working daily operations
  • Original open-hearth grill preparing steaks and seafood since opening
  • Three private party rooms accommodating events from 30-70 guests
  • Live weekend piano music performed in the dining room since 1985
  • Historic 1885 building maintains original architectural features and charm
What people say
Exceptional service Historic ambiance Quality steaks Private event spaces Live weekend music
Services
Steak Entrees
Our signature open-hearth grilled steaks feature premium cuts including filet mignon, porterhouse, and New York strip. All meats are seasoned with our proprietary blend and cooked to order. The menu showcases both traditional favorites and unique combinations like Steak Stilton with blue cheese topping.
Private Parties
Three dedicated party rooms accommodate events from 30 to 70 guests with customized buffet menus. The spaces combine historic charm with modern amenities including audio-visual equipment. Staff provides full-service coordination from menu selection to room setup.
Seafood Entrees
Fresh seafood options include twin lobster tails, jumbo shrimp, and sea scallops prepared to order. Signature dishes feature broiled rainbow trout and Norwegian salmon with specialty sauces. The seafood platter offers multiple preparations in one serving.
Live Music
Weekend piano performances by Sue at the baby grand create a sophisticated dining atmosphere. Music selections complement the restaurant's historic ambiance while maintaining appropriate volume for conversation.
Desserts
Classic desserts include house-made apple pie, carrot cake with cream cheese frosting, and New York cheesecake. Seasonal specialties feature bourbon pecan pie and chocolate ganache cake. All desserts use traditional recipes unchanged since opening.
People
Peggy Naughton
Founder
Co-founder who ran the restaurant after her husband's passing in 2006. She maintained family traditions while overseeing daily operations until her passing in 2024.
Mary Naughton
Operator
Daughter of founders who managed renovations and continues family operations. She maintains the restaurant's historic character while implementing modern improvements.
Eileen Merberg
Manager
Family member involved in daily management and guest relations. She preserves the restaurant's legacy through hands-on operational oversight.
Meaghan Naughton
Staff Member
Third-generation family member contributing to restaurant operations. She represents the ongoing legacy of family involvement in the business.
Questions
What makes Naughton's Johnson House unique?
Our 1885 historic building features an original open-hearth grill and maintains family ownership since 1977 with three generations working daily.
Do you offer private dining options?
Three private party rooms accommodate 30-70 guests with customized buffet menus and full-service event coordination available.
What are your signature dishes?
Signature items include Prime Chateaubriand for two, Steak Stilton with blue cheese, and our house-made desserts like bourbon pecan pie.
Is takeout available?
Takeout service is offered Monday-Saturday from 4:30-5:30pm with full menu availability for pickup orders.
What entertainment options exist?
Live weekend piano performances by Sue at the baby grand create a sophisticated atmosphere while maintaining conversational volume levels.
Reviews (4)
William Ramage
Nov 26, 2021 Report
After living out here for 8 years we finally made it. Hopefully next trip will be closer to 8 days. We really enjoyed the food and service.
Michael Cyr
Nov 17, 2021 Report
In 14 years I have never had a bad meal. It's laid back and comfortable. It may not have the cache that some other Rochester restaurants have, but who cares? This is a family favorite.
LarryandKaren Collins
Nov 06, 2021 Report
The service and food is the best! My husband and I had prime rib and the broiled seafood platter and was cooked to perfection!
Diana
Sep 28, 2021 Report
Had such an enjoyable experience. Sat at the bar and had drinks. Socialized with bartender (Amber) and owner for a bit before we sat. The owner shared stories about the pictures on wall. Once seated our waitress was very friendly and accomodating. Atmosphere was very relaxing. Food was great as well. Left very relaxed and satisfied with the complete experience. Will definately be back