Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
47 Years
experience
Your Trusted Pizzeria in Depew, NY
D'Agostino's Pizzeria has been a cornerstone of the Cheektowaga/Depew communities for over 45 years, dedicated to delivering exceptional food and service. Our commitment to consistency, quality ingredients, and customer satisfaction has made us a trusted name in the WNY region. We specialize in handcrafted pizza, subs, wings, and sides, all prepared with care to ensure every meal exceeds expectations. With decades of experience, we combine traditional recipes and modern techniques to create dishes that resonate with both longtime locals and new visitors. Our team prioritizes personalized service, ensuring every orderwhether for takeout or deliveryreflects our passion for Italian cuisine.

We continuously refine our menu to balance affordability with premium flavors, reinforcing our reputation as a go-to destination for gatherings, family nights, or solo indulgence. Our accolades, including 229 glowing reviews, underscore our dedication to excellence, from our Buffalo-style pizza to our attentive customer care. As a family-owned establishment, we remain rooted in the values that have sustained us since 1979: integrity, community, and culinary craftsmanship.
Services
Pizza Subs Wings Salads Catering
Details
  • Year established: 1979
Highlights and features
  • Weve served the Depew community for over 45 years with consistent quality.
  • Our menu features handcrafted pizza made with premium ingredients.
  • We offer exclusive deals and coupons for added value.
  • Family-owned with a focus on personalized customer service.
  • Ranked among the best in WNY for Buffalo-style pizza.
What people say
Outstanding customer service True Buffalo-style pizza Excellent steak hoagie Semi-sweet sauce and mild smokey pepperoni Fresh, delicious pizza
Services
Pizza
Our handcrafted pizzas feature semi-sweet sauce, mild smoky pepperoni, and premium toppings on a chewy yet crispy crust. Made with quality ingredients, they cater to traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike. Perfect for families or solo indulgence.
Subs
Steak hoagies with 'the works' and other subs combine fresh bread, savory meats, and house-made sauces. Each order is prepared to order, ensuring hot, flavorful sandwiches that highlight our commitment to authentic Italian flavors.
Wings
Crispy, juicy wings come in classic or specialty sauces, served with house-made sides. Available in 10, 20, or 50-piece portions, theyre ideal for sharing or pairing with pizza for a hearty meal.
Catering
Party packs and family meals include sheet pizzas, wings, and sides designed to feed groups. Options like the $79.99 Party Pack ensure hassle-free ordering for gatherings, with consistent quality and prompt delivery.
Salads
Handcrafted salads complement our main dishes, featuring crisp greens, house-made dressings, and premium toppings. They provide a lighter option while maintaining the same attention to quality and flavor.
Questions
What areas do you serve?
We serve the Cheektowaga and Depew communities for takeout and delivery.
Do you offer catering for events?
Yes! Our Party Packs and Family Meals feed groups, starting at $26.99.
Are there gluten-free options?
Currently, we don’t offer gluten-free menu items. Check back for updates.
What are your Sunday hours?
We’re open 11:00 AM–9:00 PM Sundays during football season, 3:00–9:00 PM off-season.
How do I use coupons?
Print coupons and present them in-person at pickup to redeem deals.
Reviews (7)
Jessica Bartella
Dec 22, 2021 Report
They always have good pizza. They're food in general is our favorite pizza place food in the area. I especially love their chicken pizza. Also they've never messed up any order of ours at all and we've been going here for about 4 years.
Laythanette Shine
Nov 21, 2021 Report
Our staff, family and friends truly enjoy the antipasto salad. The many layers of meat, cheese, tomatoes, olives, peppers, pepperoni, lettuce, and more brings the any party menu together. Thank you, USA Occupational Services
Ronnie M.
Nov 03, 2021 Report
The food was good.

Pizza: really liked the pepperonis. Not the greatest slice ever but did not the pepperonis going for them.

Wings: really crispy but some were a little too cooked. Skin curled, dried out on a couple of pieces, and easily broken bones (I am the strongest man in the World so that is easy for a person like myself). I would definitely eat here again. Likely pick it over the famous wing places because I think you get more, for less, with less crowd/time.
Megan B.
Oct 05, 2021 Report
If you're looking to support local, look no further! This is your hole in the wall type of place and we order extra crispy wings and they were crispy and amazing! Super crispy, saucy and delicious wings! We will be going back as our go to wing joint!
Jim Crego
Aug 17, 2021 Report
One if the best meals I've had. When I saw the prices I figured I should order extra since the serving sizes were probably on the small side. WRONG. I couldn't eat a personal pizza an order of fried ravioli and an order of garlic cheese bread. So much food!!!! Boy was it good. I'm staying overnight for an early morning flight home to California so I won't be able to follow up with another order but I guarantee when I'm next in the Buffalo area I'll be back
Denise Jenkins
Jul 16, 2021 Report
Dont look at their menus for their prices. We ordered the party pack which on their menu says 54.00, when you get there they charged us 85.00 even after showing/telling them what their website says. They say oh yeah those are old prices.
Nicole S.
Jul 13, 2021 Report
We ordered a sheet and large pizza (cheese and pepperoni), 70 wings (medium, extra crispy), and a single order of plain chicken fingers (that came with yummy fries!) for a family birthday party. All of the food was tasty and reasonably priced. Thank you for a great experience.