Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Premier Destination for Classic American Cuisine in East Aurora
Old Orchard Inn has been a cornerstone of East Aurora's dining scene since 1931, offering a unique blend of historical charm and modern culinary excellence. Our family-owned establishment, operated by the Romanello family since 1997, combines generations of experience with a commitment to fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Chef Abigail Prior oversees our kitchen operations, personally cultivating produce from our 12-acre farm to create signature dishes like our famous pot pie and traditional Romanello-family manicotti. We maintain a steadfast dedication to preparing every menu item from scratch, ensuring authentic flavors that have made us a regional favorite. Our venue accommodates both intimate gatherings and large events, with private spaces ranging from 10 to 180 guests.

We maintain rigorous health and safety standards while offering flexible dining options including indoor seating, curbside pickup, and special event catering. Our team's expertise in crafting seasonal menus and hosting memorable occasions has earned us a reputation as a premier dining destination in Western New York. We remain committed to preserving our legacy while continuously innovating to meet our guests' evolving expectations. Our service area spans East Aurora, Buffalo, Cheektowaga, Lancaster, Hamburg, Orchard Park, Elma, Alden, and West Seneca, NY.
Services
Dining Catering Gift Cards Curbside Pickup Event Hosting
Details
  • Year established: 1931
Highlights and features
  • We've served Western New York with farm-fresh cuisine since 1931
  • Our chef personally cultivates produce from our 12-acre farm
  • We maintain authentic family recipes passed through generations
  • We offer versatile event spaces accommodating 10-180 guests
  • We provide both dine-in and convenient curbside pickup options
Services
Dining
Our restaurant offers a classic American dining experience with farm-fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes. We serve lunch and dinner Wednesday through Sunday, featuring seasonal menus and weekly specials. Our dishes are made from scratch daily using produce grown on our 12-acre farm.
Catering
We provide full-service catering for weddings and special events with customizable menus for 10-180 guests. Our packages include hors d'oeuvres, buffet options, and plated dinners featuring our signature dishes. Our experienced staff handles all event details from planning to execution.
Gift Cards
Purchase discounted gift cards available in $50 or $100 denominations. Our gift cards can be used for dining, special events, or curbside pickup orders. They make perfect gifts for any occasion with flexible redemption options.
Curbside Pickup
Order from our full menu for convenient curbside pickup during operating hours. We require 30 minutes notice for order preparation and maintain strict food safety protocols. Our takeout options include family-style meals and individual portions.
Event Hosting
Host private events in our historic venue with spaces accommodating 10-180 guests. We offer complete event packages including venue setup, catering, and beverage service. Our staff assists with all event planning details for weddings, corporate events, and family celebrations.
People
Melissa Romanello
Owner & General Manager
Third-generation restaurant operator continuing the Romanello family legacy since 1997. Oversees daily operations and maintains the establishment's commitment to quality and tradition.
Chef Abigail Prior
Head Chef
Manages kitchen operations and cultivates produce from our 12-acre farm. Creates seasonal menus featuring scratch-made dishes using traditional techniques and fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
Questions
What are your current operating hours?
We serve Wednesday-Saturday 4-8pm and Sunday 1-6pm. Closed Mondays and Tuesdays.
Do you offer curbside pickup options?
Yes, we provide curbside pickup during operating hours with 30 minutes notice required for orders.
Can I purchase gift cards for future visits?
Yes, we offer $50 and $100 gift cards available for purchase at 20% discount.
What event spaces do you have available?
We offer private rooms for 10-180 guests with customizable catering and beverage packages.
Are reservations required for dining?
Reservations are recommended but not required for regular dining hours.
Where do your ingredients come from?
We grow produce on our 12-acre farm and source ingredients locally whenever possible.
Reviews (6)
Denise J.
Nov 07, 2021 Report
I attended my nephews wedding rehearsal dinner on October 29th. I found the restaurant to be very cozy with a. Countrylike ambiance. I ordered the Blackened Salmon which was served with a fresh corn salsa and drizzled with a Poblano Crema sauce.. it was delicious. My nephew ordered the Banana Pepper Stuffed Chicken and said it was outstanding. My niece orders the manicotti . It was a very large manicotti served with a meatball that was very moist and well seasoned. My sister in law had the house specialty Chicken Pot Pie it had large chunks of chicken with vegetables and gravy and topped with
Hank W.
Oct 22, 2021 Report
We recently celebrated my Mother's 91st birthday at the Inn. They sat us right in front of the fireplace. The owner Melissa and her staff were absolutely fantastic!! Seated in front of the fireplace was special for my Mother because that is where my parents would sit when they came on date nights back in the 50's while they were dating. The food was excellent!! Our server was delightful!! I cannot thank Melissa and her team enough for making my Mother's night so special. We will be back for sure.
Amanda Popovski
Oct 21, 2021 Report
5 stars! We went as a corporate group and the food was absolutely delicious. Beautiful property with twinkling lights and a great cozy atmosphere to chat and get to know each other. Thank you for an awesome experience! -Buffalo Chiropractic, Acupuncture & Physical Therapy, PLLC
Thomas Needell
Oct 04, 2021 Report
I went with a friend to celebrate her birthday. The setting was nice and it looks like the current owner is trying to bring it back to it's original elegance. My friend had the chicken pot pie which was loaded with chicken,etc. She said it was very good. Unfortunately, I had the $30 stuffed chicken breast. It was the smallest I can ever remember being served- much smaller. That would not have bothered me so much if it had been tasty - it wasn't. The server seemed unconcerned when I brought it to her attention. This might have been a$10 meal, not a $30 meal.
John H.
Oct 03, 2021 Report
We had reservations for a party of four for Saturday night October 2nd. Reservations were made almost 4 weeks in advance due to being closed all the Saturdays in between for private parties. After the long wait, we were disappointed withour experience. Past visit was very good, unfortunately this one was not. I checked the menu online and found the Macadamia nut glaze sea bass entree. I had this previously and looked forward to ordering it again. Upon reviewing the menu on site, that particular entree was no longer offered. The online and in person menus were different. I asked the server
Ray K.
Sep 25, 2021 Report
Quaint but disappointing. Building is somewhat run down, food was pretty good. Service was a little slow.