Business Details
14 Years
experience
Authentic Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizza in Key West
Since 2012, Roostica Wood-Fired Pizzeria Wood-Fired Pizzeria has been dedicated to bringing authentic Neapolitan pizza to Key West, rooted in the traditions of Naples, Italy. Our founders, Bobby and Michelle Mongelli, traveled extensively through pizza capitals across the U.S. and Italy before identifying Stock Island as the ideal location for a family-style gathering spot centered around wood-fired cuisine. We adhere strictly to Denominazione di Origine Controllata (D.O.C.) standards, using only soft-grain flour, Italian plum tomatoes, mozzarella di bufala, and extra-virgin olive oil, all baked in traditional Earthstone ovens.Our commitment to quality extends beyond pizza, offering rustic Italian dishes that reflect generations of culinary heritage. With nightly specials and a focus on fresh, locally sourced seafood, weve become a cornerstone for both residents and visitors seeking genuine Italian flavors in a relaxed island atmosphere. Our team combines decades of hospitality experience with a passion for preserving culinary authenticity, ensuring every guest experiences the true taste of Naples.
Services
Wood-Fired Pizza
Italian Cuisine
Catering Services
Wine Pairing
Takeout Orders
Private Events
Lunch Specials
Seafood Dishes
Family Meals
Detroit-Style Pizza
Details
- Year established: 2012
Highlights and features
- We adhere to D.O.C. standards for authentic Neapolitan pizza using imported Italian ingredients.
- Our wood-fired Earthstone ovens replicate traditional Neapolitan baking methods for perfect crusts.
- Nightly family-style specials feature locally sourced seafood and classic Italian recipes.
- Owners bring decades of culinary experience from top pizza destinations worldwide.
- Consistently ranked among Key Wests top Italian dining experiences by local patrons.
What people say
Fantastic pizza
Best pasta
Perfect crust
Fresh ingredients
Vibrant atmosphere
Services
Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizza
Authentic Neapolitan pizzas baked in traditional 900F wood-fired ovens using D.O.C.-certified ingredients. Our thin-crust creations feature imported Italian plum tomatoes, mozzarella di bufala, and house-made dough. Each pie adheres to strict Neapolitan standards while incorporating local flavors, offering both classic and innovative toppings for discerning palates.
Italian Pastas
Freshly made pasta dishes combining traditional Italian recipes with Florida Keys ingredients. Menu highlights include baked lasagna with San Marzano tomatoes, chicken cacciatore with house-made pappardelle, and seafood linguini with local catch. All pasta is prepared daily using time-honored techniques passed down through generations.
Catering Services
Full-service catering for private events featuring wood-fired pizzas, antipasti platters, and Italian specialties. Our team brings mobile pizza ovens to your location, serving customized menus for weddings, corporate events, and family gatherings. Available for groups ranging from intimate dinners to large celebrations with advance booking.
Wine Pairing
Curated wine list featuring Italian varietals and international selections complementing our wood-fired cuisine. Our sommeliers offer pairing recommendations for both traditionalists and adventurous diners, with options ranging from bold Barolos to crisp Verdicchios. House-made limoncello provides a perfect citrus-forward finish to any meal.
Takeout Orders
Convenient takeout and delivery options for our most popular dishes, including whole pizzas, pasta containers, and specialty appetizers. Orders can be placed via phone for curbside pickup or delivered locally using temperature-controlled packaging to maintain optimal quality during transport.
People
Bobby Mongelli
Co-Owner
Co-founder with extensive culinary research experience, traveling extensively through pizza capitals to perfect Roostica Wood-Fired Pizzeria Wood-Fired Pizzeria's authentic Neapolitan approach before launching the restaurant in 2012.
Michelle Mongelli
Co-Owner
Co-founder instrumental in transforming a Stock Island warehouse into Key West's premier Neapolitan pizzeria, combining hospitality expertise with a passion for traditional Italian cuisine since 2012.
Questions
What makes your pizza authentic Neapolitan style?
We follow D.O.C. standards with imported Italian ingredients, wood-fired ovens, and traditional dough preparation methods perfected over generations.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide full-service catering with mobile pizza ovens for weddings, corporate events, and private gatherings across the Florida Keys.
Are takeout orders available?
Yes, we offer curbside pickup and local delivery for our full menu including wood-fired pizzas and Italian specialties.
What nightly specials do you offer?
Weekly rotating specials include family-style Sunday gravy, spicy rigatoni vodka, seafood dishes, and Detroit-style square pies.
Do you have wine pairing options?
Yes, our curated wine list features Italian varietals and international selections that complement our wood-fired cuisine.
Is the restaurant kid-friendly?
Yes, we welcome families with kid-friendly menu options and a relaxed atmosphere suitable for all ages.
Reviews (4)
Paige B.
Jan 04, 2022
Report
We have been here twice and plan at least two trips more before we go. It's within walking distance of the Perry Hotel so we got to get off the boat, have a little exercise and a great meal- what could be better? Everything here is 'fired' and so delicious!
Alexa R.
Jan 02, 2022
Report
We were on a week long vacation with a group of friends, and one of the days the guys went off on a little fishing boat adventure. Well, they caught limit and their captain recommended this restaurant to cook their catch. We went here for dinner and were absolutely blown away with the service AND the food/preparation AND the ambiance. We were asked to wait a few moments until our table would be ready, and sat outside in this beautiful little area under lights and vines... So we asked if we could just sit there and guess what? We did! Our waitress was the hostess who was just so fun, inviting
Ian H.
Dec 21, 2021
Report
The red wine sangria was super good! The pizza was fine. Nothing special. Also the service was questionable. We had to wait 20 minutes even though there were several empty tables. It took a long time to get our drinks. We got the food without getting plates or silverware, and when I asked for silverware, the server treated it as a chore.
Ben Solove
Dec 17, 2021
Report
Roostica Wood-fired Pizzeria is one of the very best restaurants in Florida! Authentic Neapolitan pizza and other fantastic Italian dishes. Beautiful restaurant with a welcoming atmosphere and a friendly staff.