Business Details
27 Years
experience
Authentic Mexican Cuisine & Tequila Bar in Key West
Old Town Mexican Cafe has been redefining Mexican cuisine in Key West since 1999 through Chef Gail Brockway's innovative approach to traditional flavors. Our establishment combines the vibrant essence of Southwest and authentic Mexican dishes with the tropical ambiance of Duval Street, offering a dining experience that transcends typical Tex-Mex fare. Under Chef Brockway's leadership, we've cultivated an award-winning menu that showcases regional Mexican specialties while maintaining a commitment to health-conscious options. Our tequila bar features over 200 curated selections, each representing the diverse heritage of agave-based spirits. Located in Key West's historic district, we provide both air-conditioned comfort and an inviting outdoor patio for guests to enjoy our culinary creations.We accommodate various dietary needs with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options available across our menu. Our team prioritizes exceptional service, ensuring every guest experiences the warmth of Mexican hospitality. With daily happy hour specials and Taco Tuesday promotions, we create opportunities for locals and visitors to enjoy quality dining at accessible prices. Our dedication to culinary excellence extends beyond food to include an immersive cultural experience that celebrates Mexico's rich gastronomic traditions. Since our founding, we've remained committed to being more than just a restaurant - we're a destination where every meal tells a story of Mexican heritage and innovation.
Services
Authentic Mexican Cuisine
Tequila & Mezcal Bar
Vegetarian & Vegan Options
Happy Hour Specials
Taco Tuesday
Details
- Year established: 1999
Highlights and features
- We offer award-winning Mexican cuisine since 1999
- Our tequila bar features over 200 curated selections
- We provide vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options
- We maintain a prime location on historic Duval Street
- Our air-conditioned dining area offers tropical respite
What people say
Fantastic margaritas
Delicious tacos
Lively patio
Amazing fajitas
Will be back
Services
Authentic Mexican Cuisine
Our kitchen crafts innovative Mexican cuisine that moves beyond Tex-Mex standards. Chef Gail Brockway's menu features regional specialties like Carne Adovada and grilled pineapple margaritas. Each dish combines traditional techniques with modern presentation, offering guests a culinary journey through Mexico's diverse food culture while maintaining Key West's tropical ambiance.
Tequila & Mezcal Bar
We maintain Key West's most extensive tequila and mezcal collection with over 200 curated bottles. Our bar program educates guests about agave-based spirits through tasting flights and expert pairings. The selection includes premium and rare tequilas alongside artisanal mezcals, creating an immersive experience for both connoisseurs and newcomers to Mexican spirits.
Happy Hour Specials
Our daily happy hour (4-6 PM) offers half-price appetizers and well drinks, with $2 off draft beers. This promotion combines quality and value in our lively patio setting surrounded by Key West's iconic roosters. The specials maintain our culinary standards while providing accessible pricing for both locals and tourists.
Dietary Options
We accommodate various dietary requirements with clearly marked vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options across our menu. These alternatives maintain authentic Mexican flavors while meeting modern dietary standards. Our kitchen staff receives specific training to handle special requests without compromising taste or authenticity.
Taco Tuesday
Every Tuesday features $4 tacos with traditional fillings like al pastor and carnitas. This promotion showcases our commitment to quality ingredients at accessible prices. The tacos use house-made tortillas and authentic seasonings, providing an entry point for new customers to experience our core Mexican flavors.
People
Gail Brockway
Chef
Chef Gail Brockway has led Old Town Mexican Cafe since 1999, creating an award-winning menu that redefines Mexican cuisine in Key West. Her culinary vision combines traditional Mexican techniques with modern presentation, earning recognition for innovative regional dishes and an extensive tequila program.
Questions
What makes your Mexican cuisine authentic?
Our menu features regional Mexican specialties prepared using traditional techniques and authentic ingredients, moving beyond typical Tex-Mex offerings.
Do you offer vegetarian or gluten-free options?
Yes, we provide clearly marked vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options across our menu to accommodate various dietary needs.
What tequila selection can I expect?
We maintain Key West's largest tequila and mezcal collection with over 200 curated selections, including premium and rare bottles.
Are there daily specials available?
Yes, we offer happy hour from 4-6 PM daily with half-price appetizers and drinks, plus $4 tacos every Tuesday.
What's your location like?
We're located on historic Duval Street with a tropical patio featuring lush greenery and Key West's iconic roosters.
Reviews (4)
Paul Wahrer
Jan 16, 2022
Report
As my niece and I walked down Duval Street last night, we both said at the same time..."Boy, that smells good!", as we were passing the Old Town Mexican Cafe. We had to try it, and we're NOT disappointed. It tasted as good as it smelled and the service was even better. Some of the BEST Mexican food that I've eaten in a very long time. I highly recommend, when in Key West, give them a try...you won't be disappointed!
Tyler Heverling
Jan 14, 2022
Report
I dont do a lot of reviews, but for this place I had to. I have been to a lot of Hispanic food restaurants across America, and this is at my top 10 best food places of all time. Corona on draft, reasonable prices for the area, very tasty food, and seating that is fantastic and not crowded. If I ever find myself down in the Keys again, I will be making my way over. Malika was my waitress and she was fantastic, if you arent sure what to eat just ask her for a suggestion.
Marc W.
Jan 09, 2022
Report
It has been far too long to have gotten out and about. We decided to travel by car which brought us to Key West. With still being a little concerned about crowds, out doors was perfect. We love Mexican food and thought we would give it a try. We were very happy we eat here. Usually you can count on chips but our start was not great. The chips seemed a little stale. Oh no bad choice, but wait. The food was great! Frankly the food is what we came for. It was Taco Tuesday so we had a few as Appetizers and wow. Next the main course and I had the chili relleno and it rocked! Full of flavor and
Becky Billingsley
Dec 22, 2021
Report
My pork carnitas street tacos could not have been better. And the guac! And the fresh salsa! It’s no wonder it’s constantly busy. You can watch the tortillas being made. Qué sabroso!