Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
34 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Pizza & Cuisine in Downtown Columbus
Aracri Pizzeria has been a family-owned cornerstone of Columbus, Ohio's culinary scene since 1992. Founded by Palmo and Deanne Aracri, our establishment blends generations of Italian culinary tradition with hometown hospitality. Palmo, a Calabrian immigrant raised in a family of restaurateurs, honed his craft in his brothers' pizzerias before perfecting his own New York-style pizza techniques. Our menu features handcrafted dough, house-made marinara, and premium ingredients that reflect our commitment to authenticity. With two central Ohio locations, we serve lunch, dinner, and late-night bites while maintaining the personal touch of a family operation.

Our team includes four generations of Aracris who ensure every guest experiences the warmth of our Italian heritage through food. From classic Margherita pizzas to hearty pasta dishes, we prepare every item with the same care that defined our original 1992 Cafe Napolitana opening. Our Downtown Columbus location on Gay Street remains a testament to three decades of perfecting Italian cuisine for local and visiting patrons alike.
Services
NY Style Pizza Specialty Pizzas Pasta Dishes Italian Subs House-Made Appetizers Late Night Bites Wine & Drafts Catering Services Happy Hour Specials Takeout Orders
Details
  • Year established: 1992
Highlights and features
  • We've perfected Italian recipes across three generations of family ownership
  • Our pizzaiolo trained in Calabrian restaurants before opening in 1992
  • Daily house-made dough and marinara using traditional family techniques
  • Four generations of Aracris maintain personal service standards nightly
  • Downtown Columbus location offers lunch, dinner, and late-night options
What people say
Perfect New York slice Family-run charm Consistent quality Great happy hour deals Authentic Italian flavors
Services
NY Style Pizza
Our New York-style pizza features hand-tossed dough with a thin, crisp crust and generous cheese application. The sauce combines imported San Marzano tomatoes with secret herbs developed over three decades. Available in 10", 12", and 16" sizes with 18 premium toppings including house-made Italian sausage and fresh mozzarella. Perfect for pizza purists and adventurous eaters alike.
Specialty Pizzas
Crafted from family recipes perfected since 1992, our specialty pizzas include the Margherita with fresh basil and buffalo mozzarella, the meat-loaded Meatlovers, and the spicy Buffalo Chicken. Each 16" pie serves 3-4 people with consistent quality ensured by our fourth-generation pizzaiolo. Gluten-free crust options available upon request.
Pasta Dishes
Hand-rolled pasta paired with house-made sauces and premium proteins. Featured dishes include Chicken Parmigiana with hand-breaded chicken breast, Sausage Lasagna layered with five cheeses, and Rigatoni Bolognese with slow-cooked pork sausage. All pasta meals include garlic knots and are available with gluten-free alternatives.
Happy Hour Specials
Daily happy hour from 4-6pm offers $5 drafts and wines, $2.50 bottled beers, and half-price appetizers. Available Tuesday-Friday for dine-in customers only. Popular combinations include $8 bruschetta with craft beer or discounted wine pairings with specialty pizzas.
Late Night Bites
Serving downtown Columbus until 10pm Friday and Saturday. Late-night menu includes build-your-own pizza slices, garlic knots with marinara, and calzones filled with ricotta and mozzarella. Perfect for post-theater meals or late work shifts with quick service guaranteed.
People
Palmo Aracri
Owner-Operator
Calabrian immigrant and fourth-generation pizzaiolo who learned pizza-making in his brothers' Dayton and Cincinnati restaurants. Opened Cafe Napolitana in 1992 and Aracri Pizzeria in 2018. Maintains daily oversight of dough preparation and sauce recipes.
Deanne Aracri
Co-Owner
Business partner with Palmo since 1992, managing front-of-house operations and customer relations. Ensures the family-friendly atmosphere remains consistent with original vision. Coordinates special events and catering services.
Questions
What makes Aracri's pizza authentic?
Our New York-style pizza uses dough and sauce recipes perfected over three generations in Calabrian and Ohio pizzerias, with imported Italian ingredients.
Do you offer gluten-free options?
Yes, we provide gluten-free crust alternatives for all pizza and pasta dishes with advance notice.
Are reservations accepted?
We accept walk-ins only but offer call-ahead seating for parties of six or more during peak hours.
What are happy hour details?
Daily 4-6pm specials include $5 drafts/wines, $2.50 bottled beers, and half-price appetizers Tuesday-Friday.
Can I order online?
Currently, we accept phone orders only for pickup. Delivery options are available through local partners.
Do you cater events?
Yes, we offer full catering services with buffet-style Italian dishes for weddings, corporate events, and private parties.
Reviews (7)
Kiel VanTiem
Jan 15, 2022 Report
The pizza was astounding. I spent time looking at all of the reviews for the pizza joints around and I was very delighted with my selection. You will not be disappointed.
Mark Maldonado
Dec 14, 2021 Report
Definitely the best pizza in the area! The size is great for the price. Tastes even better the next day too!
Alex Blubaugh
Nov 27, 2021 Report
This pizza spot was a great place to stop in while walking down high street. They had many different slice options and they had a deal for 2 slices for one price. Each pizza we tried was delicious and put in the fire oven just before eating it. The Buffalo chicken pizza and the Hawaiian was particularly good. I would definitely recommend for cheap, quick, good slices of pizza. Portion sizes were definitely good for the price as well.
Lovely Shara
Oct 24, 2021 Report
Amazing pizza and wonderful atmosphere! Stopped here for lunch before our trip back home to Wisconsin, and absolutely loved it! The man working was super kind and friendly! Highly recommend this place to anyone who loves some good pizza.
Michael Spegele
May 31, 2021 Report
This place is a nice little gem I was happy to visit. The calzone I ordered was the best I've ever had. You can tell everything is made with high-quality ingredients, and there's even a cool bar setup too!
Carla Renee Meinberg
Mar 31, 2021 Report
I discovered this clean quaint establishment tossed their pizzas by hand... fresh fragrant and the best ingredients definitely went into my slices I purchased.. the BBQ chicken had chunks of real breast meat… and the Bianca was love at first bite with fresh cheeses and the right touch of garlic.. I will return.. so glad to have found this family owned location..
M. Thompson
Nov 28, 2020 Report
Fabulous pizza! This place nails it. Super friendly staff. AMAZING pie. Give it a try and don't forget about the original location downtown. Keep making the best pie!