Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Real Estate Partner in Dayton, OH
M R Real Estate has been a trusted name in the real estate industry since 1970, dedicated to providing exceptional services to home sellers and buyers in the Greater Dayton, OH area. Our team of experienced professionals, including Broker/Appraiser Mel Rutherford and Realtor Judy McCartney, combines decades of local market expertise with a commitment to personalized service. We specialize in maximizing property value for sellers and helping buyers find their ideal homes, supported by comprehensive real estate appraisals and tailored guidance. Our reputation for integrity, professionalism, and results-driven strategies has solidified our position as Dayton's premier real estate brokerage.With a focus on transparency and client satisfaction, we offer innovative solutions like the Zero Cash Down Payment Program to make homeownership accessible. Our affiliations with the National Association of Realtors and local boards underscore our dedication to industry excellence. Whether you're buying, selling, or seeking appraisal services, our team's deep understanding of residential and commercial real estate ensures you receive expert support throughout every transaction.
Services
Real Estate Services
Home Seller Representation
Home Buyer Representation
Real Estate Appraisals
For Sale by Owner (FSBO)
Details
- Year established: 1970
Highlights and features
- We offer over 50 years of combined real estate experience in the Dayton market.
- Our team includes certified professionals with GRI, ABR, and CDPE designations.
- We provide expert real estate appraisals with a two-day turnaround guarantee.
- Our Zero Cash Down Payment Program makes homeownership accessible without upfront costs.
- We serve 10+ communities across the Greater Dayton area with localized expertise.
Associations and certifications
- Accredited Buyer's Representative (ABR)
- National Association of Realtors
What people say
Professional courtesy
Bottom-line results
Tremendous energy
Appropriate pricing
Prompt sales
Services
Real Estate Services
M R Real Estate provides comprehensive real estate solutions for residential and commercial properties. Our services include market analysis, pricing strategies, and negotiation expertise to ensure optimal outcomes. With over 50 years of local experience, we help clients buy, sell, and appraise properties across the Greater Dayton area.
Home Seller Representation
We specialize in maximizing home values through targeted marketing and strategic positioning. Our team offers professional staging advice, digital marketing campaigns, and access to 10,000+ listings. Sellers benefit from our deep understanding of local market trends and proven track record of successful transactions.
Home Buyer Representation
Our buyer specialists help clients find ideal properties matching their specific needs. We provide access to exclusive listings, mortgage guidance, and negotiation support. The Zero Cash Down Payment Program enables qualified buyers to purchase homes without upfront costs, making homeownership more accessible.
Real Estate Appraisals
State-licensed appraisers deliver accurate property valuations for residential and commercial properties. Services include market value analysis, probate appraisals, and bankruptcy assessments with a two-day turnaround guarantee. Appraisals help clients determine fair pricing and secure financing.
For Sale by Owner (FSBO)
We support homeowners selling properties without traditional representation. Services include pricing guidance, marketing tools, and contract assistance. Our expertise helps FSBO sellers navigate transactions while maintaining control over the sales process and potentially saving on commission fees.
People
Mel Rutherford
Broker / Appraiser
With over 50 years in real estate, Mel Rutherford combines broker and appraiser expertise. He holds GRI, ABR, and CDPE certifications, specializing in property valuations and seller representation across Dayton.
Judy McCartney
Realtor / Office Manager
Judy McCartney brings extensive experience in real estate transactions and client management. As Office Manager, she ensures smooth operations while assisting buyers and sellers with personalized service and market insights.
Questions
What real estate services do you offer?
We provide home buying, selling, appraisals, and For Sale by Owner (FSBO) support across the Greater Dayton area.
Can I buy a home with no down payment?
Yes, our Zero Cash Down Payment Program allows qualified buyers to purchase homes without upfront costs.
How quickly do you complete property appraisals?
We guarantee appraisals within two business days for residential and commercial properties.
Do you serve areas outside Dayton?
We serve 10+ communities including Miamisburg, Centerville, Springboro, and Kettering.
Are your agents certified professionals?
Yes, our team includes GRI, ABR, and CDPE designations for specialized expertise.
Reviews (5)
Kelly Hart
Sep 04, 2021
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
I had a great experience selling my house with Mel. It was a real pleasure to work with him. Friendly and professional! Does things old school. Highly recommend!
I had a great experience selling my house with Mel. It was a real pleasure to work with him. Friendly and professional! Does things old school. Highly recommend!
Molly Lawson
Feb 26, 2021
Report
As a long time family friend of ours, Mel with M R Real Estate was the obvious choice when my husband and I decided to buy our first home. He has more experience and industry knowledge than any realtor in the Dayton area, and he truly cares about the people he works with. No other realtor will be able to provide you with the level of information and customer service that you will receive at M R Real Estate. I cannot recommend them enough!!!!
Karin Turowski
Nov 06, 2020
Report
We found Mel thru the recommendation of another client of his, and we're SO glad we did. He's a professional thru and thru, with our best interest in mind. He was available to meet with us immediately, took pictures and had us listed promptly. We had multiple offers after being on the market only one dsy, and he helped us pick the most solid offer. We sold for 100% of asking price and the transaction was trouble free.
Mel guided us thru the negotiations and made it clear that he knows his trade. We'd also like to thank Judy, who is a great back up should Mel be unavailable.
Mel guided us thru the negotiations and made it clear that he knows his trade. We'd also like to thank Judy, who is a great back up should Mel be unavailable.
Clyde Golden
Sep 30, 2020
Report
Working with Mel in selling our home was a great experience. He is a gentleman with extensive realty knowledge and widely respected in the community. Even with listing as the pandemic response was beginning, he kept us comfortable in our encounters. We were pleased to get full listing price. His comforting demeanor was truly appreciated during a stressful time. We recommend him to anyone needing a fully experienced professional.
Bradley Brewer
Jun 08, 2020
Report
Mel is the consummate professional and it's clear he cares about the clients that rely on him to guide them in the right direction. As my dad was selling his house after 48 years of living there, Mel made sure he explained what was going on every step of the way and guided us through the entire process. I think my dad's going to have yet another good friend for life. Although he is a professional, he's always fun and enjoyable to work with.
