Business Details
Homestyle Chicken & Sandwiches in East Islip, NY
Buttermilk's Chicken has been serving homestyle chicken dishes to the East Islip community since our founding. Our commitment to quality ingredients shines through our all-natural, hormone and antibiotic-free chicken prepared using traditional buttermilk brine and 100% canola oil. We specialize in crafting signature chicken sandwiches that combine classic flavors with innovative combinations, complemented by a selection of fresh salads and house-made sides. Our team of experienced kitchen professionals maintains consistent quality across our menu items, from crispy tenders to jumbo fried shrimp.With 7-day-a-week service and extended hours from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, we provide convenient access to our homestyle meals. Our online ordering system and delivery partnerships ensure seamless access to our offerings, whether dining in, taking out, or ordering delivery. We maintain strict quality control over our food preparation processes while preserving the authenticity of our Southern-style recipes.
Services
Chicken Sandwiches
Crispy Tenders
Jumbo Fried Shrimp
Southern Fried Chicken
Chicken Combos
Salads
Sides
Online Ordering
Delivery Service
Family Meals
Highlights and features
- We serve all-natural, hormone and antibiotic-free chicken prepared in 100% canola oil
- Enjoy 7-day-a-week service with extended operating hours from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM
- Our signature chicken sandwiches combine traditional Southern flavors with modern twists
- Multiple online ordering options through trusted delivery platforms and our own website
- Consistently rated for quality by 180+ Google reviewers for our crispy tenders and fried chicken
What people say
Delicious chicken tenders
Huge chicken sandwiches
Fantastic chicken
Excellent customer service
Outstanding service
Services
Chicken Sandwiches
Our signature chicken sandwiches feature all-natural, hormone-free chicken marinated in buttermilk brine. Available in classic crispy or grilled preparations with multiple flavor combinations. Each sandwich comes on a fresh brioche bun with house-made sauces and premium toppings.
Crispy Tenders
Hand-breaded chicken tenders made from all-natural meat, fried to golden perfection. Served with choice of dipping sauces and available in multiple portion sizes. Perfect for families or individual meals with customizable combo options.
Jumbo Fried Shrimp
Large, premium shrimp battered and fried to crispy perfection. Available in half-dozen or combo meals with traditional sides and house-made sauces. Each order includes lemon wedges and multiple dipping sauce options.
Southern Fried Chicken
Traditional Southern-style fried chicken available in white or dark meat options. Served in various portion sizes from 4-piece meals to family feasts. Each order includes fresh sides and cornbread for an authentic dining experience.
Salads
Hand-prepared salads featuring baby mixed greens and premium toppings. Options include classic Caesar, garden salad, and specialty combinations with grilled chicken or falafel. All salads include house-made dressings and fresh ingredients.
Questions
What makes your chicken different from other fried chicken restaurants?
Our chicken is marinated in buttermilk brine and cooked in 100% canola oil, with all-natural, hormone and antibiotic-free ingredients.
Do you offer catering services for events?
Currently we focus on dine-in, takeout, and delivery options but do not offer catering services at this time.
Are there vegetarian options available on your menu?
Yes, we offer a Falafel Salad and multiple vegetarian side options including cornbread and mac & cheese.
What are your regular business hours?
We're open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM for dine-in, takeout, and delivery orders.
How can I place an order for pickup or delivery?
Order through our website, mobile app via DoorDash, Postmates, Grubhub, or Uber Eats, or call us directly at 631-581-3000.
Reviews (6)
Kimberly Daino
Jan 25, 2022
Report
I had the Roadhouse sandwich and it was soooo delicious. You could tell it was made with fresh ingredients and homemade. Best part was that I didn't feel like I was going to go into a coma like I do when I eat chicken sandwiches from fast food joints Can't wait to go back and try the classic I had the pleasure of meeting the owners and they were so nice and down to earth. I'll definitely be back and would highly reccomend!
Artburg
Nov 29, 2021
Report
Didn't even know this place existed until 2 hrs ago. Local to me. Just ordered 3 sandwich combo's and a 2 piece chicken meal. Everything tasted great.Only thing waffle fries that are listed on menu were substituted with regular fries without being told.. did'nt know til we got home to eat. I was REALLY looking forward to waffle fries... Will definitely order from them again
John Ziegler
Oct 01, 2021
Report
My family & I stopped off to pick up lunch & go to Hecksher State Park. This place is awesome! The best chicken sandwich I ever had. Great service & atmosphere. Will definitely be back soon!
Tamara DesJardins
Aug 03, 2021
Report
Probably the best chicken I've EVER had. I got 4 chicken fingers, fries & cornbread. Perfectly seasoned & awesome service. I shared this new found gem with my coworkers & they'll be eating here too. It was delish!
Melissa Faust
Jul 15, 2021
Report
It all started with my boss telling her department about a fried chicken place one day and we decided to try it for lunch. The group order started with 4 people, then quickly increased as more and more coworkers caught a scent of the amazing fried chicken from here. Thank you, Charlie, Jen, and team, for always making amazing food each time, and for always being so friendly!
John Fickes
Jul 09, 2021
Report
Stopped in at 7:15 pm to get some onion rings. I heard they were fantastic. I was informed that they weren’t taking anymore orders. I was shocked. I left and went to the OConee to get my onion rings. This was my first time there and it was my last!!!! Their loss