Which Insurance Agency Should You Choose in Toledo, OH?

Review 16 local insurance agencies in Toledo, OH and check what each business offers. Read customer feedback, compare agency information, and shortlist providers who can help with the types of personal or business insurance you need.
Midland Title Escrow provides comprehensive title insurance and escrow services for residential and commercial real estate transactions. Since 1986, we have delivered accurate title searches, secure closings, and expert legal guidance to clients in Ohio and Michigan. Our locally owned agency combines decades of experience with innovative tools like remote online notarization to ensure efficient, transparent transactions.
Title Insurance Escrow Services Residential Title
Seamless closing process Expert legal guidance Flexible remote options
RBI Insurance Agency & Financial Services is a full-service independent insurance agency in Toledo, Ohio. We specialize in personalized home, auto, life, and business insurance solutions tailored to individual and commercial needs. Our mission is to empower clients with knowledge, choice, and trusted partnerships for comprehensive risk protection.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Life Insurance
Great service Personalized solutions Trusted partnership
Rex Sims
40 Years
Emergency
7 reviews
Rex Sims
40 Years
Emergency
7 reviews
Rex Sims provides comprehensive insurance solutions in Toledo, OH. We offer personalized coverage plans for auto, home, life, and business insurance. Our agency serves Ohio and Michigan residents with professional risk management services.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Prompt claims handling Dedicated staff Affordable premiums
Matt Vierk
19 Years
Emergency
6 reviews
Matt Vierk
19 Years
Emergency
6 reviews
Matt Vierk provides comprehensive insurance solutions in Toledo, OH, offering auto, home, life, health, and business insurance products. Our agency combines State Farm's national resources with personalized local service to protect families and businesses. With over 20 years of industry experience, we deliver tailored coverage options and exceptional customer support.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Renters Insurance
Excellent customer service Saved significant money Knowledgeable professionals
6 reviews
Scott Wood
39 Years
6 reviews
Scott Wood provides comprehensive insurance solutions in Toledo, OH, specializing in auto, homeowners, life, and business insurance. With over 35 years of local expertise and 65+ years of combined team experience, we serve Northwest Ohio and Southeast Michigan. Our agency combines competitive pricing with personalized service to meet diverse insurance needs.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Fast service Great rates Personalized assistance
5 reviews
Todd Riggs
20 Years
5 reviews
Todd Riggs provides comprehensive insurance solutions in Toledo, OH. We specialize in auto, home, life, and business insurance, offering personalized coverage options tailored to individual needs. Our experienced team combines local expertise with national resources to protect families and businesses across northwest Ohio.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Wonderful and helpful Phenomenal service Great quote
4 reviews
Dana Mathewson
49 Years
4 reviews
Dana Mathewson offers personalized insurance solutions in Toledo, OH, specializing in Auto, Homeowners, Life, and Business Insurance. With 48 years of local expertise and multistate coverage, we prioritize client protection through tailored policies and exceptional service. Our team's awards and certifications underscore our commitment to reliability and customer satisfaction.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance
Very friendly, knowledgeable Saved me 50% Great customer service
Dave Walbom provides personalized auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions in Toledo, OH. With over 150 years of combined team experience, we prioritize tailored coverage, community engagement, and 24/7 client support. Our agency emphasizes transparent advice, competitive pricing, and proactive risk management for residents and businesses across Northwest Ohio.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Excellent customer service Prompt and friendly Knowledgeable and professional
Compass Insurance Services provides comprehensive personal and business insurance solutions in Toledo, OH. We specialize in assessing client needs to deliver customized coverage options from multiple providers. Our locally operated agency serves Ohio communities and Michigan, combining competitive pricing with dedicated support.
Personal Insurance Business Insurance Home Insurance
Always friendly and helpful Amazing customer service Willing to help find the best policy
2 reviews
Rachel Beranek
Emergency
2 reviews
Rachel Beranek offers personalized auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions in Toledo, OH. Specializing in tailored policies for individuals and businesses, the agency prioritizes transparent communication and comprehensive coverage. Their approach combines State Farms industry expertise with community-focused service.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Renters Insurance
Knowledgeable staff Responsive service Personalized attention
5 reviews
Cornerstone
41 Years
5 reviews
Cornerstone Broker Insurance Services Agency offers health insurance, employee benefits, and broker support services. We provide brokers with quoting tools, licensing assistance, commission management, and educational resources. Our mission is to empower brokers through expert guidance and innovative solutions like ICHRAs.
Health Insurance Employee Benefits ICHRA Solutions
Patient and professional Exceeded expectations Personalized support
Gluckle Insurance Agency offers a comprehensive range of insurance solutions for individuals and businesses. We partner with 30+ providers to secure the best coverage options at competitive prices. Our licensed agents provide personalized service, conducting annual policy reviews to ensure optimal protection and eligibility for discounts.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Business Insurance
Better coverage Lower price Excellent customer service
5 reviews
American Casualty Insurance
44 Years
Emergency
5 reviews
American Casualty Insurance offers personalized personal and commercial insurance solutions. Serving Ohio, Michigan, and Indiana since 1982, we partner with top-rated carriers to provide tailored coverage options for auto, home, health, life, and business insurance. Our independent agency focuses on competitive pricing, expert risk assessment, and personalized service to meet individual and organizational needs.
Auto Insurance Health Insurance Home Insurance
Westgate Insurance Agency offers comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions in Toledo, OH, specializing in tailored coverage since 1892. We provide auto, home, life, disability, and business insurance with personalized service and expert guidance. Backed by industry-leading carriers and experienced agents, we ensure clients receive competitive rates and responsive claims support.
Life Insurance Disability Insurance Business Insurance
Very helpful Personalized service Knowledgeable agents
House Of Insurance provides comprehensive insurance solutions to residents and businesses in Toledo, OH and surrounding areas. Specializing in automobile, renters, commercial vehicle, and recreational insurance, we help clients find affordable coverage tailored to their needs. With over 60 years of local experience and a commitment to personalized service, we work with major industry providers to ensure reliable protection for our clients.
Auto Insurance Renters Insurance Commercial Vehicle Insurance
Affordable insurance options Personalized service Face to face consultation
Not rated yet
Powell Insurance Agency
42 Years
Not rated yet
Powell Insurance Agency offers customized auto, home, Medicare, life, and business insurance solutions in Toledo and Northwest Ohio. With over 40 years of local expertise, we leverage partnerships with top carriers to deliver personalized coverage that protects clients most valuable assets. Our independent approach ensures competitive rates and comprehensive support tailored to individual and commercial needs.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance
Holland (8.6 mi) Bowling Green (20.6 mi) Perrysburg (8.3 mi) Maumee (8.6 mi) Monroe (19.2 mi) Blissfield (19.6 mi) Dundee (20.9 mi) Wayne (25.4 mi) Liberty Center (27.9 mi) Carleton (28.6 mi)