Which Restaurant Should You Choose in Montauk, NY?

Review 2 local restaurants in Montauk, NY and check what each location offers. Read customer feedback, compare menus and dining details, and shortlist places that serve the type of cuisine or dining experience you want.
Harvest on Fort Pond is a top-rated Montauk restaurant specializing in Italian cuisine made with local seafood and seasonal produce. Since 1994, we've offered creative dishes, craft cocktails, and scenic garden dining overlooking Fort Pond. Our commitment to quality ingredients and exceptional service makes us a beloved destination for both residents and visitors.
Appetizers Salads Grilled Pizzas
Top-rated Local favorite Creative cocktails
Inlet Seafood Restaurant is a waterfront dining destination in Montauk, NY, owned and operated by six local fishermen. Specializing in ultra-fresh seafood directly sourced from their own fishing vessels, the restaurant offers a diverse menu featuring sushi, raw bar selections, and classic dishes with both oceanic and terrestrial options. With panoramic views of Block Island Sound and a commitment to quality, it provides an authentic maritime dining experience that connects guests to the source of their meal.
Seafood Restaurant Sushi Bar Raw Bar
Freshest sushi Breathtaking sunsets Owned by local fishermen
Stonington (20.9 mi) Sag Harbor (17.8 mi) New London (23.3 mi) Westerly (24.5 mi) East Lyme (26.1 mi) Cutchogue (27.7 mi) North Stonington (28.2 mi) Old Saybrook (28.7 mi)