Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
32 Years
experience
Your Trusted Destination for Italian Cuisine in Montauk
Since 1994, Harvest on Fort Pond has been a cornerstone of Montauk's culinary scene, offering a unique blend of Italian-inspired cuisine crafted from locally sourced seafood and seasonal produce. Our executive chef, Jake Williams, curates a menu of sharable dishes that highlight the region's natural bounty, complemented by an extensive selection of creative cocktails and wines. The restaurant's ambiance combines seasonal garden dining with panoramic views of Fort Pond, creating an unforgettable experience for both locals and visitors.

With over 25 years of dedication to quality and innovation, we remain committed to delivering exceptional service and culinary excellence. Our team prioritizes fresh, regional ingredients to ensure every dish reflects the flavors of Montauk, while our reservation system and walk-up patio accommodate diverse dining preferences. From intimate dinners to casual gatherings, Harvest on Fort Pond strives to be the premier destination for authentic Italian cuisine in a scenic setting.
Services
Appetizers Salads Grilled Pizzas Mains Pasta Seasonal Garden Dining
Details
  • Year established: 1994
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 25 years of culinary expertise in Montauk Italian cuisine
  • Our menu features locally sourced seafood and homegrown seasonal produce
  • Executive Chef Jake Williams crafts innovative, sharable Italian-inspired dishes
  • We provide scenic garden dining with sunset views over Fort Pond
  • Our reservation system accommodates parties up to 10 for indoor dining
What people say
Top-rated Local favorite Creative cocktails Amazing food Scenic garden
Services
Appetizers
Our appetizers feature locally sourced ingredients like PEI mussels, char-broiled oysters, and fresh burrata. These small plates are designed to share, showcasing Montauk's seafood and produce. Each dish highlights seasonal flavors while preparing guests for the main course experience.
Grilled Pizzas
Handcrafted pizzas combine traditional Italian techniques with Montauk ingredients. Options include oven-roasted tomato with mozzarella, artichoke-spinach-mushroom medleys, and gourmet sausage-gorgonzola combinations. The wood-fired crust provides a perfect base for these creative flavor pairings.
Mains
Our main courses feature premium proteins like 42oz porterhouse steak, swordfish piccata, and free-range chicken breast. Each dish incorporates regional ingredients such as littleneck clams, seasonal vegetables, and locally caught seafood. The menu balances classic Italian preparations with modern culinary innovations.
Pasta
Handmade pasta dishes include veal bolognese, shrimp-spaghetti combinations, and asparagus-mushroom penne. Traditional techniques meet local ingredients in every preparation, from rustic farfalle to refined linguini with clams. The pasta menu changes seasonally to reflect available produce.
Seasonal Garden Dining
The outdoor patio offers sunset views over Fort Pond with no reservations required. This casual dining option features the full menu in a relaxed atmosphere, allowing guests to enjoy Montauk's natural beauty while experiencing our Italian-inspired cuisine.
People
Jake Williams
Executive Chef
Executive Chef Jake Williams brings decades of culinary expertise to Harvest on Fort Pond, creating innovative Italian dishes that highlight Montauk's local seafood and seasonal produce.
Questions
What type of cuisine do you offer?
We specialize in Italian-inspired cuisine using Montauk seafood and seasonal produce, with creative dishes designed for sharing.
Do you have outdoor seating available?
Yes, our outdoor patio offers walk-up seating with sunset views over Fort Pond, available daily during operating hours.
What are your dinner service hours?
We serve dinner Tuesday through Sunday starting at 5pm, with kitchen closing times varying by season.
Can I make reservations for large groups?
We accommodate parties up to 10 people for indoor dining, but cannot split groups or accept reservations for larger parties.
Are there vegetarian options available?
Yes, our menu includes multiple vegetarian dishes like artichoke-spinach pizza and seasonal vegetable sides.
Reviews (5)
Katie F.
Jan 18, 2022 Report
Visited MTK during the holiday MLK weekend and was so glad to see Harvest was open and could take us after our reservation fell through elsewhere. Calamari salad was the best part of the meal as well as the service we received from Kamoree (spelling). She was super sweet and made the dining experience feel homey and relaxed. Would definitely come back, best for groups given portion size and that everything is intended to be served family style.
Michael Kuhner
Jan 11, 2022 Report
We went there by the recommendation of my in-laws. We were there at night but I'm sure in the light of day the view is beautiful. We ate at the bar which holds about 8 to 10 people. Are bartender Ann was helpful attentive and very personable. We chose the porterhouse for two and the garlic fries. The steak was cooked perfect pre-sliced and as soft as butter. The fries were delicious. And made our drinks exactly the way we asked. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone.
Karen M.
Jan 08, 2022 Report
The best restaurant for every occasion. Family gatherings or an anniversary dinner. Does not disappoint!
Alexandra Rozhdestvenskaya
Dec 31, 2021 Report
Great service, cozy atmosphere, family style portions, fresh, and delicious seafood!
Brenden Bishop
Dec 24, 2021 Report
TLDR; High end prices, okay food, poor service. Dont recommend.
Went here for our 10th year anniversary, was really looking forward to it, and was incredibly disappointed. This restaurant just doesnt make the cut for what it tries to be. The food was just okay, service was poor. I went to give back my fork I used for a Buffalo mozzarella with balsamic vinaigrette and was told to keep it for my chicken parm. Not sure what high end or expensive Italian restaurant wants you to mix your balsamic fork with marina, but I assure you its not good. Not to mention, when they messed up our