Which Insurance Agency Should You Choose in Indianapolis, IN?

Review 13 local insurance agencies in Indianapolis, IN and check what each business offers. Read customer feedback, compare agency information, and shortlist providers who can help with the types of personal or business insurance you need.
Multiline Insurance Agency is an independent insurance broker in Indianapolis, IN, offering personalized coverage solutions from over 20 top-rated providers. We specialize in auto, home, business, and life insurance, focusing on tailored policies that adapt to clients' evolving needs. Our team prioritizes transparency, competitive pricing, and exceptional service to ensure comprehensive protection for individuals and businesses.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Business Insurance
Lowered my rates Great price Timely responses
6 reviews
Connie Mortensen
13 Years
Emergency
6 reviews
Connie Mortensen provides personalized auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions to residents and businesses in Indianapolis and surrounding areas. With over 45 years of combined experience, our team delivers tailored risk management plans and exceptional customer service. We prioritize community engagement, offering free quotes and 24/7 support while supporting local nonprofits through our 'Quote for Good' initiative.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance
Excellent customer service Highly recommend Awesome
John Elbin State Farm State Farm Insurance Agent in Indianapolis, IN provides auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions tailored to individual and business needs. With over 12 years of experience, our team offers personalized coverage recommendations, community-focused service, and 24/7 accessibility to protect clients' assets and loved ones.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Helpful and trustworthy Saved us money Quick and easy process
Gagen's House of Insurance offers personalized auto, home, life, and Medicare insurance solutions in Indianapolis. Since 1964, our licensed agents have helped clients save money by comparing policies from multiple providers. We provide expert guidance to ensure comprehensive coverage at competitive rates.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance
Oldham Insurance Agency is an independent insurance provider offering personalized coverage solutions for individuals and businesses in Indianapolis. Specializing in auto, home, life, and commercial insurance, we help clients navigate risk management with tailored policies. Our consultative approach ensures clients receive comprehensive protection from trusted carriers.
Personal Insurance Commercial Insurance Life Insurance
4 reviews
Jim Metzler, Agent
45 Years
Emergency
4 reviews
Jim Metzler, Agent provides personalized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in Indiana. Specializing in Auto, Homeowners, Life, and Business Insurance, we combine local expertise with nationwide resources to create customized protection plans. Our team prioritizes transparent communication and budget-conscious coverage strategies for clients across central Indiana.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Condo Insurance
Excellent service Knowledgeable staff Prompt and professional
Caitlin Morgan specializes in niche insurance programs and alternative risk solutions for independent agents and their clients. We provide workers' compensation, captive insurance, healthcare facility coverage, and risk management services across the United States. Our expertise combines underwriting control, multiple A-rated carriers, and customized program development for specialized industries.
Workers Compensation Captive Solutions Healthcare Insurance
Indy Health Agent helps individuals and businesses navigate health insurance options with personalized, independent brokerage services across Alabama, Indiana, and surrounding states. We specialize in ACA plans, Medicare solutions, short-term coverage, and faith-based health shares while maintaining strict privacy protections. Our face-to-face consultations and virtual support ensure clients receive tailored guidance at no additional cost, as we work with nationally recognized insurers to find optimal coverage matching specific healthcare and budgetary needs.
Health Insurance Medicare Plans Dental Coverage
6 reviews
Kellie Taylor
7 Years
Emergency
6 reviews
Kellie Taylor offers comprehensive insurance solutions in Indianapolis, IN. Specializing in Auto, Homeowners, Life, and Business Insurance, we provide personalized coverage tailored to individual needs. With 24/7 service and community-focused expertise since 2019.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Professional and friendly service Prompt claims resolution Personalized policy guidance
United Home Life offers simplified life insurance solutions without medical exams, serving diverse health profiles. Our portfolio includes whole life, term life, and accidental death coverage with flexible underwriting options. Backed by 80+ years of experience and A.M. Best's A financial strength rating, we provide reliable protection tailored to individual needs.
Whole Life Insurance Term Life Insurance Accidental Death Insurance
Tom Plummer Agency delivers personalized insurance solutions for Indiana individuals and businesses. Specializing in home, auto, commercial, and life insurance, we simplify complex coverage needs through tailored advice and competitive rates. With over 70 years of local expertise, our family-owned agency prioritizes client protection and financial security.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Commercial Insurance
Not rated yet
Enterprise Title
33 Years
Not rated yet
Enterprise Title provides comprehensive real estate title services and secure closings for residential and commercial properties. With over 30 years of experience, we specialize in title insurance, escrow services, and transaction management while prioritizing client education and fraud prevention. Our team of seasoned professionals ensures smooth, transparent processes for homebuyers, sellers, lenders, and real estate agents across Central Indiana.
Residential Services Commercial Services Lender Services
Global Atlantic offers a portfolio of annuity and insurance products designed to deliver guaranteed income and market-linked growth. Our solutions provide taxadvantaged wealth transfer and longterm financial security for individuals and institutions. We aim to empower clients to achieve peace of mind through reliable, purposedriven financial strategies.
Fixed Index Annuities Registered Index-Linked Annuity Pension Risk Transfer
Carmel (14.6 mi) Greenwood (11.0 mi) Avon (12.8 mi) Plainfield (13.6 mi) Fishers (15.1 mi) Mooresville (15.7 mi) Franklin (20.6 mi) Greenfield (20.6 mi) Noblesville (20.7 mi) Pendleton (26.9 mi)