Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Trusted Insurance Solutions in Indianapolis
Founded in 1949, Tom Plummer Agency has served Indiana clients for over seven decades, establishing itself as a trusted insurance partner. Our family-owned business combines generational expertise with personalized service, offering tailored solutions for individuals and businesses. With a focus on client needs, we provide comprehensive coverage options across home, auto, commercial, life, and specialty insurance. Our team of experienced agents works directly with clients to analyze existing policies, identify coverage gaps, and deliver cost-effective protection.Backed by relationships with multiple carriers, we simplify the insurance process while maintaining local accessibility and accountability. Our commitment to ethical practices and customer-centric service has made us a reliable choice for Indiana residents seeking financial security and peace of mind.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Life Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Mobile Home Insurance
Renters Insurance
Boat Insurance
Classic Car Insurance
Workers Compensation
Details
- Year established: 1949
Highlights and features
- We offer over 70 years of Indiana insurance expertise
- Our team provides personalized policy analysis and recommendations
- We access multiple carriers for comprehensive coverage options
- We simplify claims and payment processes for client convenience
- Our family-owned agency maintains local market knowledge
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide mandatory liability coverage and optional protections for Indiana drivers. Our policies address bodily injury, property damage, and uninsured motorist scenarios while offering competitive rates. With 14% of Indiana drivers uninsured, we help clients secure comprehensive protection against financial risks from accidents.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial packages protect Indiana businesses with tailored coverage options. Services include business property insurance, general liability, commercial auto, and workers' compensation. We specialize in risk assessment for HVAC contractors, electrical contractors, and other trade professionals while offering customized policies for various industries.
Homeowners Insurance
We offer protection against fire, windstorms, and other perils for primary residences. Our policies include dwelling coverage, personal property protection, and liability insurance. With replacement cost valuation options, we ensure homeowners can recover from disasters without financial strain.
Umbrella Insurance
Our umbrella policies provide additional liability protection beyond standard coverage limits. Designed for asset protection, these policies cover legal expenses and damages exceeding primary policy amounts. This service benefits both individuals with valuable assets and businesses facing potential lawsuits.
Life Insurance
We offer life insurance solutions including term policies and permanent coverage options. Our specialists help clients protect dependents through income replacement, mortgage protection, and estate planning strategies. We also provide short-term medical plans for temporary coverage needs.
People
Tom Plummer
Founder
Established the agency in 1949 as a sole proprietor, creating a foundation for multi-generational family ownership and client-focused service.
Scott Plummer
Agent
Joined the agency in 1976, continuing the family tradition of personalized insurance service and independent carrier representation.
Julia Lang
Agent
Became an agent in 2003, enhancing the firm's capacity for new business quotes and client service efficiency.
Molly Plummer
Agent
Fourth-generation family member who joined after graduating from the University of Indianapolis, continuing the legacy of client-focused insurance service.
Questions
What types of insurance does Tom Plummer Agency offer?
We provide auto, home, commercial, life, umbrella, mobile home, renters, condo, boat, motorcycle, and classic car insurance for Indiana residents.
How does the agency personalize insurance solutions?
Our agents analyze existing policies, identify coverage gaps, and recommend tailored options based on individual risk profiles and budget considerations.
What commercial insurance options exist for contractors?
We offer specialized coverage for HVAC, electrical, plumbing, concrete, and other contractors including liability protection and equipment coverage.
How can clients file claims or make payments?
We provide simplified claims reporting and offer automatic payment/withdrawal options for policyholders' convenience.
What areas does the agency serve?
We serve Indianapolis and surrounding communities throughout Indiana from our Shelby Street office location.
Reviews (2)
Anessa
Dec 10, 2020
Report
Critical:Professionalism
After 9 yrs my car ins. had raised up twice within 5 months. Never did I get a call or notice. Explanation was " You know Anessa I'm doing what I can, now your more than welcome to check other rates." Now the same with my homeowner's policy. I found new company that seems to be how they use to be
After 9 yrs my car ins. had raised up twice within 5 months. Never did I get a call or notice. Explanation was " You know Anessa I'm doing what I can, now your more than welcome to check other rates." Now the same with my homeowner's policy. I found new company that seems to be how they use to be
Cassandra Jones
Jul 27, 2020
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
Tom Plummer Agency has handled my insurance needs for over 15 years. If I ever need anything, they are prompt and professional. I had an issue with my insurance and Molly fixed it right away and even called to followup and make sure everything worked out. I HIGHLY recommend this agency. They truly care about their clients.
Tom Plummer Agency has handled my insurance needs for over 15 years. If I ever need anything, they are prompt and professional. I had an issue with my insurance and Molly fixed it right away and even called to followup and make sure everything worked out. I HIGHLY recommend this agency. They truly care about their clients.
