Which Jeweler or Watch Store Should You Choose in Columbus, OH?

Review 5 local jewelers and watch stores in Columbus, OH and check what each business offers. Read customer feedback, compare store information, and shortlist retailers or repair specialists that carry the products or provide the services you need.
6 reviews
The Smithery
12 Years
6 reviews
The Smithery creates handcrafted, sustainable jewelry in Columbus, Ohio, specializing in custom engagement rings and wedding bands made from recycled metals and ethically sourced gemstones. We offer artisanal design workshops and maintain a commitment to traditional goldsmithing techniques while prioritizing environmental responsibility in all aspects of our craft.
Custom Engagement Rings Wedding Band Workshop Jewelry Repair
Exquisite craftsmanship Ethical sourcing commitment Unique design options
6 reviews
Argo & Lehne
50+ Years
6 reviews
Argo & Lehne is a trusted Columbus-based jewelry store offering engagement rings, vintage pieces, custom designs, and professional appraisal services. With 98 years of heritage, we combine traditional craftsmanship with modern technology to serve Central Ohio. Our commitment to quality includes AGS-certified evaluations and personalized customer support.
Custom Jewelry Design Jewelry Appraisals Vintage Jewelry Sales
Exceptional craftsmanship Knowledgeable staff Unique selection
Koulian Jewelers creates custom jewelry and provides repair services in Columbus, Ohio. Established in 2003, we offer engagement rings, designer collections, and watch repairs with personalized attention. Our team combines technical expertise with customer-focused service to deliver quality jewelry solutions.
Jewelry Design Jewelry Repair Custom Jewelry
Exceptional custom designs Personalized service experience Skilled repair work
Alexanders Jewelers is a full-service luxury jewelry and watch boutique established in 2000. We specialize in engagement rings, custom-designed jewelry, and premium timepieces from brands like Rolex and Patek Philippe. Our services include expert jewelry and watch repair, complimentary appraisals, and personalized consultations.
Engagement Rings Custom Design Wedding Bands
Personalized experience Knowledgeable staff Trusted quality
Not rated yet
Marsala Manufacturing
49 Years
Not rated yet
Marsala Manufacturing is a leading fine jewelry manufacturer established in 1977, specializing in private label collections for retail partners. We combine handcrafted artistry with innovative design to create sterling silver, gold, and gemstone jewelry that meets market demands. Our commitment to quality and trend-driven solutions has made us a trusted supplier to major retailers nationwide.
Private Label Jewelry Sterling Silver Design Gold Jewelry Manufacturing
Grove City (7.4 mi) Dublin (11.3 mi) Pickerington (14.0 mi) Marysville (27.2 mi)