Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Jewelry Store in Columbus, OH
As a third-generation jeweler with nearly a century of service, we have built our reputation on superior craftsmanship and personalized customer care. Our expertise spans engagement rings, vintage jewelry, custom designs, and professional appraisals, serving Columbus and surrounding communities. With AGS-certified gemologists and state-of-the-art technology, we combine tradition with innovation to meet diverse jewelry needs.Our commitment to quality extends to restoration services, heirloom repurposing, and complimentary gift consultations. We maintain transparency in pricing, offer 20% bonuses for in-store reinvestment, and provide complimentary cleaning and repair estimates. Our team's deep local knowledge ensures tailored solutions for every client interaction.
Services
Custom Jewelry Design
Jewelry Appraisals
Vintage Jewelry Sales
Jewelry Repair & Cleaning
Heirloom Restoration
Sterling Silver Purchases
Wedding Jewelry Borrowing
Gift Services
Estate Consultations
Watch Repair
Details
- Year established: 1927
Highlights and features
- We offer 90 years of appraisal experience with AGS-certified gemologists
- Our custom jewelry services combine hand-carving with 3D CAD technology
- We provide 20% bonus payouts for in-store reinvestment when selling jewelry
- Our team maintains heritage craftsmanship while using modern design techniques
- We offer complimentary jewelry cleaning and repair estimates
Associations and certifications
- American Gem Society
What people say
Exceptional craftsmanship
Knowledgeable staff
Unique selection
Personalized attention
Quality service
Services
Custom Jewelry Design
Our Columbus store creates custom jewelry using hand-carving and 3D CAD technology. We transform client ideas into unique pieces, offering design consultations and wax prototypes. Services include remounting heirloom stones and creating personalized wedding bands with 6-8 week production timelines.
Jewelry Appraisals
AGS-certified gemologists provide insurance and estate appraisals with 90 years of combined experience. Services include detailed documentation with gem grading, measurements, and digital imaging. We offer fair market value assessments for selling purposes without requiring formal appraisals.
Vintage Jewelry Sales
We specialize in pre-1940s estate jewelry including Art Deco, Victorian, and Edwardian pieces. Our curated collection features platinum and gold items with emphasis on quality and historical significance. We also offer consignment services for vintage jewelry owners.
Jewelry Repair & Cleaning
Our repair services include ring resizing, prong replacement, and pearl restringing with complimentary estimates. We provide professional cleaning using appropriate methods for different materials, along with stone security checks. Hagerty cleaning products are available for home maintenance.
Heirloom Restoration
We restore antique jewelry to wearable condition while preserving original craftsmanship. Services include filigree repair, prong replacement, and engraving restoration. Our team provides detailed quotes before work begins and maintains jewelry integrity during the restoration process.
Questions
What jewelry services do you offer beyond sales?
We provide appraisals, custom design, repair services, heirloom restoration, and jewelry cleaning. Our AGS-certified gemologists also offer estate consultation services.
Can I sell my vintage jewelry to you?
Yes, we purchase pre-1940s estate jewelry and offer consignment services. We specialize in platinum and gold pieces but evaluate all vintage jewelry for potential purchase.
Do you offer jewelry repair services?
Yes, we offer comprehensive repair services including resizing, prong replacement, and pearl restringing with complimentary estimates for all repair work.
How can I get an appraisal for my jewelry?
Schedule an appointment with our AGS-certified gemologists who provide detailed appraisals with digital documentation for insurance or estate purposes.
What payment options are available?
We offer financing options for purchases and provide 20% bonus payouts when selling jewelry that's reinvested in-store services or purchases.
Do you offer custom jewelry design?
Yes, our designers use 3D CAD technology and hand-carving techniques to create custom pieces from client concepts with 6-8 week production timelines.
Reviews (6)
Dan Cannell
Dec 31, 2021
Report
We had the pleasure of working with Rachel and Will this December and cannot imagine a better experience. From the moment you walk in, you feel comfortable and appreciated by the entire staff of professionals. We needed to be particularly precise, but you would never know it as they were so pleasant and also wanted everything perfect as well. Im guessing thats how most of the customers are too, which is why so many return - as we will!
R. Hill
Dec 24, 2021
Report
I went in for a jewelry repair and Rachel provided outstanding customer service. She was friendly and extremely knowledgeable and took the time to discuss what options I had to repair a necklace that has a lot of sentimental value. I really appreciated her insight and time, especially since the holiday season is such a busy time for the jewlery business. I highly recommend Rachel and Argo & Lehne, thank you so much!
C. Yates
Dec 24, 2021
Report
Argo and Lehne is a wonderful store with carefully chosen, beautiful pieces of jewelry for every budget. They also have a small collection of gorgeous estate pieces which I love. The staff is very well educated in all aspects of stone quality, and are very helpful if you are trying to buy a gift within a certain budget. It's also large enough to socially distance from other shoppers if needed!
Pt
Dec 21, 2021
Report
You are always greeted with a warm smile. Janet, Anne, Rachel and Bob offer personalized service with every purchase. It is just a fun place to shop.
Theodore Kessis
Dec 21, 2021
Report
I've going to Argo and Lehne for years for anniversary and Christmas gifts for my wonderful wife. They never let me down with their wonderful quality selections for a very fair price. One of my favorite Arlington stores!
Charlotte Garcia
Dec 17, 2021
Report
Fantastic experience shopping with Anne Wilson, who is an expert on gifting and finding the perfect piece. Anne suggested a baby gift (silver animal candle holders) and housewarming gift (silver frame), both of which were perfect for friends and very well-received. I would not go anywhere else for a bespoke, specialized shopping experience, she really knows what she is doing! Great person and company.