Which Insurance Agency Should You Choose in Columbus, OH?

Review 21 local insurance agencies in Columbus, OH and check what each business offers. Read customer feedback, compare agency information, and shortlist providers who can help with the types of personal or business insurance you need.
We’re local, independent insurance professionals with over 25 years of experience in Medicare planning. Dedicated to our community, we focus on helping you understand your options and choose a plan that suits your needs. As independent agents, we prioritize you, not any particular insurance company. Whether you need Medicare or a supplement plan, we’ll provide expert guidance and personalized support every step of the way.
Medicare Supplements Medicare Advantage Medicare Part D
Outstanding service Thorough explanations Personalized guidance
Pam Lewis-Kidder State Farm Insurance provides comprehensive auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions in Columbus, Ohio. Our agency specializes in creating personalized protection plans that address individual and commercial risk management needs. With 24/7 client support and a focus on local community service, we deliver State Farm's industry-leading coverage options with personalized attention.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Very reliable, I do recommend! Thank you for helping me save money!!! Kind and extremely helpful
Ohio Insurance Agents Association (OIA) is Ohio's leading trade association for independent insurance agencies. Since 1897, we've provided advocacy, professional development, business solutions, and industry thought leadership to our members. Our core mission protects and advances the independent agency system through legislative efforts, educational programs, and specialized resources for insurance professionals.
Advocacy Professional Development Business Consulting
Fantastic resource Exceptional to work with Quick responses
Cor-Ben Consultants offers customized employee benefits solutions, including health insurance, dental and vision plans, and third-party administration services. Since 1972, weve prioritized personalized service, helping businesses navigate complex healthcare regulations. Our team provides expert guidance on HSA/FSA accounts, COBRA compliance, and voluntary benefits, ensuring clients achieve cost-effective, compliant benefit programs.
Health Insurance Dental & Vision Plans HSA & FSA Accounts
Personal service Knowledgeable team Prompt assistance
Soller Insurance Agency specializes in comprehensive insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in Columbus, Ohio. As an independent agency since 1955, we partner with top-rated carriers to provide auto, home, life, health, business, farm, workers' compensation, and disability insurance. Our mission is to deliver personalized coverage that meets unique client needs at competitive prices.
Homeowners Insurance Auto Insurance Life Insurance
Theresa Bush-State Farm Insurance Agent State Farm Insurance Agency delivers customized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in Bexley, Ohio and surrounding areas. We specialize in auto, homeowners, life, and commercial insurance products backed by State Farm's industry-leading support. Our agency combines local expertise with national resources to provide personalized risk management strategies that protect what matters most to our clients.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Knowledgeable and helpful Fast friendly service Competitive rates
J. R. Scott Insurance is an independent insurance agency established in 1945, specializing in home, auto, business, and recreational insurance policies. Based in Columbus, Ohio, we serve clients by providing personalized coverage solutions through multiple carriers. Our commitment to building relationships ensures tailored service for both personal and commercial needs.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Business Insurance
Empathetic to any problem Splendiferous service Long-lasting relationships
Alta Vista Benefits provides honest, client-centered Medicare and health insurance solutions in Columbus, Ohio. Specializing in Medicare Supplement, Advantage, and Part D prescription drug plans, we offer personalized guidance to help clients navigate complex coverage options. Our team delivers fee-free, obligationless consultations, prioritizing transparency and client advocacy.
Medicare Supplement Medicare Advantage Prescription Drug Plans
Supremely helpful Extremely knowledgeable Highest level of service
Grandview Insurance Agency provides personalized insurance and financial planning services in Columbus, Ohio. We specialize in home, auto, life, business, and retirement solutions tailored to individual and corporate needs. Our independent agency model ensures access to multiple providers for competitive pricing and comprehensive coverage.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance
Progressive Insurance provides comprehensive personal and business insurance solutions in Ohio. Specializing in home, auto, life, and commercial coverage since 1968, we combine expert advice with competitive pricing to protect clients' assets. Our family-owned agency emphasizes education, transparency, and personalized service to help policyholders navigate insurance complexities.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Business Insurance
Courteous and knowledgeable staff Prompt and accurate answers Trusted advice
Doug Yglesias-State Farm Insurance Agent provides personalized insurance solutions in Upper Arlington, OH. We offer auto, home, life, business, and pet insurance with tailored pricing plans. Our agency combines local expertise with 24/7 service to meet diverse client needs.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance
Very knowledgeable Excellent customer service Quick to respond
Bepler Insurance Agency is an independent insurance provider offering personalized risk management solutions for individuals and businesses across Ohio. We specialize in matching clients with customized coverage options from multiple carriers to ensure comprehensive protection. Our services span personal insurance, business insurance, pet insurance, and health insurance open enrollment assistance.
Personal Insurance Business Insurance Pet Insurance
W.E. Davis Insurance Agency provides personalized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in Ohio. Specializing in commercial and personal coverage, including auto, home, life, and business insurance, we prioritize client needs through tailored policies and expert guidance. With over 86 years of combined experience, our family-owned agency delivers reliable protection and exceptional service.
Commercial Insurance Auto Insurance Home Insurance
Exceptional customer service Trusted insurance provider Personalized service
Hyers & Associates is an independent insurance brokerage offering customized coverage solutions for individuals and businesses. We specialize in Medicare supplements, life insurance, annuities, disability insurance, and long-term care policies. With nationwide service and partnerships with major carriers, we provide clients with competitive quotes and personalized guidance to help protect their financial futures.
Medicare Supplements Medicare Advantage Health Insurance
Knowledgeable agents Personalized approach Competitive pricing
David Grant
30 Years
Emergency
5 reviews
David Grant
30 Years
Emergency
5 reviews
David Grant provides comprehensive auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions in Columbus, OH. With personalized service since 1996, we offer competitive rates and 24/7 emergency support. Our experienced team delivers tailored coverage options for individuals and businesses.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Knowledgeable staff Timely quotes Excellent service
A.A. Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio specializes in personalized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses. We offer auto, renters, homeowners, commercial vehicle, and motorcycle insurance across Columbus, Ohio. Our team connects clients with trusted carriers to secure quality coverage at competitive rates.
Auto Insurance SR-22 Bonds Renters Insurance
This company provides auto insurance comparison services, helping customers find low-cost policies from top-rated carriers. We offer free quotes, personalized coverage recommendations, and educational resources about insurance requirements and discounts. Our platform supports drivers in all 50 states with various needs including minimum liability coverage, non-owner policies, and high-risk insurance solutions.
Auto Insurance Quotes Liability Coverage Non-Owner Insurance
Easy to use Great savings Quick quotes
Not rated yet
Reidel Insurance
50+ Years
Not rated yet
Reidel Insurance provides comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions in Ohio. Established in 1962, we offer auto, home, business, life, and specialty insurance policies tailored to individual client needs through multiple carrier partnerships. Our experienced team delivers personalized service with a focus on risk management and client education.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance
Professionalism Quality Responsiveness
Independent Title Services provides expert residential and commercial title searches in Ohio's Franklin and Delaware counties. With over 30 years of experience, we deliver accurate, reliable, and timely title examination services tailored to the needs of title companies, attorneys, and real estate professionals.
Residential Title Searches Commercial Title Searches Title Examinations
Not rated yet
Ward & Connolly
9 Years
Not rated yet
Ward & Connolly provides expert life insurance consulting and sales services in Columbus, Ohio. Specializing in policy analysis, coverage customization, and estate planning, we serve financial professionals and individual clients. Our 30+ years of combined experience ensures tailored insurance solutions through multiple carrier partnerships.
Life Insurance Consulting Policy Review Analysis Disability Insurance
Madsen Insurance Agency provides independent Medicare insurance solutions across Ohio. Our agency partners with national and regional carriers to offer customized plans focusing on affordability and comprehensive benefits. Clients receive personalized guidance to make informed decisions about Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D Prescription coverage.
Medicare Advantage Plans Medicare Supplement Plans Medicare Part D Prescriptions
Reynoldsburg (9.9 mi) Dublin (11.3 mi) Westerville (12.0 mi) Powell (14.2 mi) Delaware (23.6 mi) Lancaster (27.2 mi) Grove City (7.4 mi) Groveport (9.5 mi) Hilliard (9.8 mi) Canal Winchester (12.6 mi)