J. R. Scott Insurance

Business Details

50+ Years

experience

Independent Insurance Agency in Columbus, OH

J. R. Scott Insurance has been a trusted independent insurance agency since 1945, serving clients in Columbus, Ohio, and surrounding areas. Our focus on building long-term relationships drives our personalized approach to helping individuals and businesses navigate the insurance marketplace. With expertise in home, auto, business, and recreational insurance, we represent multiple carriers to ensure tailored coverage solutions.

Our team prioritizes client needs, offering direct access to agents without automated systems. Located in Clintonville near The Ohio State University, we combine decades of experience with community involvement to deliver reliable, client-centric service.

Services

Home Insurance Auto Insurance Business Insurance Umbrella Liability Recreational Insurance

Details

Year established: 1945

Highlights and features

We offer 80+ years of combined insurance expertise.
Our team provides personalized policy reviews tailored to client needs.
We represent multiple regional and national insurance carriers.
Our agency maintains deep local knowledge of Columbus markets.
We prioritize direct, human-centric customer service over automated systems.

What people say

Empathetic to any problem Splendiferous service Long-lasting relationships Personalized approach Community involvement

Website

Update Listing

Services

Home Insurance

We provide comprehensive homeowners and renters insurance protecting against property damage, liability claims, and additional living expenses. Our policies cover standard risks while offering customizable options for unique needs like flood or high-value assets. Clients benefit from competitive rates through multiple carrier partnerships.

Auto Insurance

Our auto insurance solutions cover personal and commercial vehicles with options for standard liability, collision coverage, and specialized policies for classic cars or high-risk drivers. We help clients navigate state requirements while securing cost-effective protection tailored to driving habits and vehicle types.

Business Insurance

We offer business owner's policies, general liability, and commercial auto insurance protecting small to mid-sized enterprises. Our solutions address industry-specific risks while ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements. Clients receive dedicated support for policy customization and risk management strategies.

Umbrella Liability

Our umbrella insurance policies provide supplemental liability coverage beyond standard home or auto policies. This protection safeguards assets against catastrophic claims or lawsuits exceeding primary policy limits. We help clients assess appropriate coverage levels based on individual risk profiles.

Recreational Insurance

We specialize in insurance for recreational vehicles including boats, RVs, motorcycles, and ATVs. Our policies address unique risks associated with leisure assets while offering flexible terms. Clients receive specialized coverage options tailored to usage patterns and storage requirements.

People

Julie E. Schatz

Agency Owner

Julie Schatz has led J. R. Scott Insurance since 2021, bringing decades of industry experience. Active in the Columbus Northern Lions Club and Clintonville Area Business Association, she focuses on community engagement and innovative insurance solutions for clients.

TJ Hansen

Independent Agent

TJ Hansen joined the team as an independent agent, combining insurance expertise with client-focused service. Outside work, he enjoys rock climbing and photography while actively participating in local community activities through his pet-related engagements.

Jeffrey D. Bell

Retired Agent

Jeffrey Bell served clients for 44 years before retiring in 2021. A Clintonville resident, he remains active in community service through Charity Newsies and pursues historical research while maintaining industry connections through professional associations.

Questions

What types of insurance do you offer?

We provide home, auto, business, umbrella liability, and recreational insurance including boat, RV, and motorcycle coverage.

How are you different from direct insurers?

As independent agents, we represent multiple carriers to find policies matching your specific needs rather than offering only one company's products.

Do you serve areas outside Columbus?

While based in Clintonville near OSU, we serve clients throughout Ohio with specialized insurance solutions for urban and suburban locations.

Can I update policies outside business hours?

Our voicemail and email remain available 24/7, but policy changes require direct agent assistance during regular business hours.

How do claims work with your agency?

We assist with filing claims through your chosen carrier and advocate for timely resolution while providing ongoing support throughout the process.

Reviews (5)

Write a Review

Marge Fekete

Dec 14, 2021 Report

Julie Schatz with JR Scott Insurance Agency was amazing! I had a need for home insurance and needed it quickly. I had several unusual needs and Julie worked to meet those needs with great detail. Unbelievably, she found a better deal with another agent and did all this legwork for me for free and literally overnight! I feel terrible that I couldn't sign with such a hard worker but am delighted with her amazing service! Call Julie, you will be delighted! Haha, yes, insurance service with Julie was delightful!
Marge Fekete

Forko

Dec 14, 2021 Report

I had my automobile and homeowner insurance policies with JR Scott Insurance Agency for the past several years. My personal agent was Julie Schatz. I cant thank Ms Schatz enough for her help and her service to me during what has been a major change in my lifestyle. You see, I recently moved from Columbus Ohio to Cuenca Ecuador for an extended period and in doing so, I sold both my home and my car, since I dont plan to return anytime soon. Julie was very helpful and instrumental in getting my policies canceled and the unused premiums refunded to me, promptly and efficiently. She went above

Lucia Smith

Nov 20, 2021 Report

A lot of investors are confused and go into deep research, for a trusted and legit platform to trade and invest in. I was also looking for the best not until I read good reviews and recommendations about Mrs Emily Alison, With she great skill of trading and mining made a good profit for so many in their trade account. I was amazed how happy many investors wrote good comments about her. I contacted amazing account manager Mrs Emily Alison and invested with her with believe, and trust just as the way she replied me. I earned a very good profit and made my withdrawal successfully directly to my Bank

Gilman Sullivan

Jul 26, 2021 Report

Positive:Professionalism,Responsiveness
Julie is great. Always helps and does everything with a smile!

Laurie Barron

Nov 05, 2020 Report

Positive:Responsiveness
Julie Schatz has been my agent for the past 6 years and always goes above and beyond. She got me a great rate on my home and auto insurance, she even checks in with me every 6 months or so to see if she can get me a better rate. Couldnt be happier!