Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
26 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Restaurant & New York-Style Pizza
Santino's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria has been a staple of the Johns Creek community since 2000, offering authentic Italian cuisine crafted with decades of culinary expertise. As local owners, we prioritize quality ingredients, traditional recipes, and personalized service to create memorable dining experiences. Our New York-style thin-crust pizza, voted #1 by Atlanta City Search, showcases our commitment to excellence through fresh dough, house-made sauces, and premium toppings. Beyond dining in, we provide catering services for corporate and private events, supporting 18-20 guests with full trays of lasagna, baked ziti, and other Italian classics.

Our team actively participates in community initiatives, proudly sponsoring the Centennial Knights Football Team and local schools. With a focus on family-friendly hospitality, we've maintained a loyal customer base through consistent quality, extended hours for lunch and dinner, and carefully curated menus featuring pastas, calzones, and house specialties like Chicken Marsala. The manager, Carlos Cisneros, ensures daily operations uphold our standards for authenticity and customer satisfaction, balancing efficiency with the warmth of a neighborhood establishment.
Services
New York-style Pizza Italian Catering Dine-in Dining Take-out Orders Corporate Lunches Specialty Pasta Calzones & Stromboli Homemade Soups Buffalo Wings Family Feasts
Details
  • Year established: 2000
Highlights and features
  • Voted #1 pizza by Atlanta City Search with New York-style thin crust
  • Locally owned for 24 years with active community involvement
  • Full-service catering available for corporate and private events
  • Hand-crafted Italian dishes using family recipes and quality ingredients
  • Manager on-site daily to ensure consistent quality and service standards
What people say
Best pizza south of New York Excellent sauce and cheese blend Attentive manager on-site daily Generous toppings and crispy crust Local community support
Services
New York-style Pizza
Our award-winning pizza features hand-tossed thin crust with house-made marinara sauce, premium cheese blend, and quality toppings. Voted #1 in Atlanta by City Search, slices come generously sized for folding or sharing. Available by the pie or specialty combinations like Manhattan Meat.
Italian Catering
Santino's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria provides full-service corporate and private catering with 48-hour notice. Menu includes full trays of lasagna, baked ziti, and chicken parmesan serving 18-20 guests. Delivery available within 5-mile radius for $10 fee.
Specialty Pasta
Classic Italian pasta dishes include penne alla vodka, fettuccine alfredo, stuffed shells, and seafood linguine. All pasta is cooked fresh-to-order with house-made sauces and served with garlic bread or house salad. Gluten-free options available upon request.
Buffalo Wings
Fresh-made buffalo wings come in eight flavor varieties including traditional, BBQ, honey BBQ, and Asian sesame. Served with ranch or blue cheese and celery. Available in 10-piece or 20-piece portions for dine-in or takeout.
Calzones & Stromboli
Hand-stuffed calzones feature ricotta, mozzarella, and choice of meat or vegetables. Stromboli wraps savory fillings in thin crust dough with marinara for dipping. Both items are cut in half for sharing and available as lunch or dinner options.
People
Carlos Cisneros
Manager
Carlos Cisneros oversees daily operations at Santino's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, ensuring quality standards and customer satisfaction. With extensive restaurant management experience, he maintains the venue's New York-style authenticity while fostering community relationships through event sponsorships and local partnerships.
Questions
What are Santino's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria current operating hours?
We're open Monday through Saturday from 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM. We're closed on Sundays.
Do you offer catering services for special events?
Yes, we specialize in corporate and private catering with minimum order requirements and delivery fees based on location.
What makes your New York-style pizza unique?
Our hand-tossed thin crust features a house-made sauce blend and premium cheese combination developed over 24 years of perfecting the recipe.
Are there options for large group dining?
We accommodate groups with advance reservations and offer banquet-style catering packages serving 18-20 guests per full tray.
Do you participate in community events?
We actively support local schools and sports teams, including serving as Silver Sponsor for the Centennial Knights Football Team.
Reviews (7)
S. Bg
Jan 28, 2022 Report
1st time visiting. Had low carb grilled chicken with parmesan cheese & tomatoes sauce over it with a salad. Delicious! The pic is after I ate it
Nothing Channel
Dec 23, 2021 Report
The food here is so good. I love their pizza and their anti pasta salad is beyond amazing. Customer service has gone done since Covid but the food here makes up for it
R. Huyck
Dec 18, 2021 Report
Worst pizza I've ever had. I managed to eat a piece and a half only because I hadn't eaten all day but normally this would have gone straight to the trash
Ashley Steinecke
Oct 13, 2021 Report
Lovely food. I ordered gluten free spaghetti with my choice of sauce and meat. It was great! It even came with some custom made gluten-free garlic bun. Very nice touch.My husband had their calzone and was very impressed. I will definitely be ordering from here again.
Shirley Rillie
Oct 11, 2021 Report
I was just there t the other day. Kept very clean. Workers are very courteous. Best Me York pizza. I like very thin sliced.
Maria Aguirre
Sep 17, 2021 Report
Not impressed. I had pasta with Italian sausage, but sausage did not taste right. Very disappointed! First and last time going there. Frozen Lean Cuisine tastes better.
Paula Dinkins
Sep 03, 2021 Report
The food was pretty good. However the woman that served us was very abrupt, almost rude. She seemed bothered by any question. Not one smile to be found. But, the ravioli was good.