Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Go-To Diner for Freshly Made Meals in Massapequa
Since 1963, Nautilus Diner has been a cherished culinary landmark in Massapequa, NY, serving generations of locals and visitors with fresh, made-to-order meals. Our historic diner reopened in 2014 after a meticulous renovation, preserving its nostalgic charm while modernizing our offerings. We specialize in classic American comfort food, serving breakfast, lunch, dinner, and late-night snacks daily. Our team prioritizes compliance with all health regulations to ensure a safe dining experience. With a full-service bar featuring premium wines and craft beers, we cater to casual gatherings and special events.Our private catering room accommodates up to 100 guests for celebrations or business meetings. Customer testimonials consistently highlight our welcoming staff, generous portions, and attention to dietary preferences. From homemade paninis to decadent desserts, every dish reflects our commitment to quality ingredients and culinary excellence. The diners retro design has even attracted film productions seeking authentic mid-century aesthetics. Whether youre stopping in for a quick coffee or hosting a milestone event, we aim to make every visit memorable through exceptional food and service.
Services
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Bar Services
Private Events
Late Night Snacks
Takeout
Details
- Year established: 1963
Highlights and features
- Established in 1963 with deep roots in the Massapequa community
- Offers private catering for events up to 100 guests
- Maintains strict compliance with CDC and New York State health regulations
- Features consistently praised staff known for personalized service
- Serves made-to-order meals with dietary preference accommodations
What people say
Friendly staff
Delicious meals
Clean and welcoming
Generous portions
Perfect for events
Services
Catering
Our soundproof private room with HD TV accommodates events from intimate gatherings to parties of 100. We specialize in customized menus for showers, business meetings, holiday celebrations, and religious events. Our team handles all details from setup to cleanup.
Bar Services
Enjoy premium wines from Santa Margherita and Kendall Jackson, craft cocktails like Stoli Doli, and eight tap beer varieties. Our bar features nightly drink specials and large-screen TVs for sports viewing. The curated wine list includes reds and whites from renowned vintners.
Breakfast
Savor made-to-order breakfasts daily from 6 AM. Popular items include Florentine omelets, old-fashioned French toast, and tomato basil soup. We accommodate special requests and offer kid-friendly options. Coffee is freshly brewed and served in generous portions.
Lunch
Our lunch menu features burgers, salads, and specialty platters with fresh ingredients. Guests praise the generous portions and presentation quality. The dining room and outdoor seating provide comfortable spaces for casual meals or takeout orders.
Dinner
Dinner service includes classic entrees, homemade paninis, and late-night munchies until 11 PM. The menu balances traditional diner fare with modern twists. Desserts are baked fresh daily, including customer favorites like New York-style cheesecake.
Questions
What are Nautilus Diner's operating hours?
We're open daily from 6:00 AM to 11:00 PM, including weekends and holidays.
Can I host large events at Nautilus Diner?
Yes, our private catering room accommodates up to 100 guests for celebrations or business events.
Does the diner offer takeout options?
Yes, we provide takeout service for all menu items during regular business hours.
Are gift cards available?
We offer beautifully packaged gift cards redeemable for any dining experience at our Massapequa location.
What makes the diner unique?
Our historic 1963 design combines with modern amenities, making us popular for both regular dining and film productions.
Reviews (7)
Carol Lynch
Jan 14, 2022
Report
Have been coming here since July with my son. There hasn't been a thing I have ordered that I didn't like. The fried shrimp dinner is one of the best I've had in a long time.
Colleen Mullins
Jan 09, 2022
Report
I ordered through Uber eats I order the hot open face turkey sandwich. I also paid for a priority delivery. So upon receipt the turkey and gravy were cold. I had to microwave to heat it up. Also I ordered peas as my side and received mixed veggie. I also ordered and paid for extra poultry gravy and never received it. This diner used to be a go to for me. But unfortunately I will never order from this diner again. I spent 32 dollars on a dinner that I wouldnt feed to my dog. Super disappointed
Jamie Maloney
Dec 22, 2021
Report
Food was way overcooked, over priced and staff was unfriendly. Bill was over $135 for 2 peoples dinner which you couldn't even eat. Should have complained but will just never go back
Robin D.
Dec 20, 2021
Report
Food is fabulous, and staff is friendly. Full compliance with Covid mandates which is very much appreciated
Jeffrey Waybright
Dec 18, 2021
Report
By far the customer service I've ever encountered. Ordered multiple dinners through grubhub for delivery, Yet when they arrived one of them was completely missing and replaced with something else. When we called the restaurant, they basically told me too bad, what we gave you cost costs more so we're not doing anything about it. Then tried blaming it on the language barrier of grubhub. This is the 2nd time ordering delivery from this restaurant, the last time all of our entrees were missing vegetable and potato and we were asked "do you actually want it?"
Definitely not worth the price or aggravation
Definitely not worth the price or aggravation
Tom K.
Nov 23, 2021
Report
Lets start off by saying I do like the food there. I went there enough that I knew the wait staff and certain waiters would want us in their section when we visited. What I dont like is when a manager is cheap. As we were walking out my son asked for a black and white cookie. I said no problem, we just paid a $100.00 bill plus a tip and for a dollar or two, no problem. They charged the kid 5 bucks (and change) for a cookie. When I said something about it ,I get an excuse about how much icing is and payroll tax etc. Seriously? I can go to a bakery and get them for a buck or
Desi Pilla
Nov 23, 2021
Report
The portions at Nautilus Diner are HUGE. You can bank on not needing to eat for the rest of the day after one of their pancake selections. Aside from the size, the taste was great (I recommend the nutella/banana pancakes!). The wait staff wasn't very organized and we had to wait quite a while for our food, but in the current hiring environment that may not be Natuilus's fault.