Business Details
Authentic Italian Pizza & Restaurant in Wayne, NJ
At Neil's Pizzeria, we have dedicated over three decades to perfecting the art of Italian cuisine. Our commitment to using only the freshest ingredients in every dish reflects our belief that exceptional food starts with superior components. As a family-owned establishment, we welcome guests to experience our authentic, old-world flavors paired with modern hospitality. Our BYOB policy allows customers to enjoy their preferred beverages alongside our handmade pizzas and traditional Italian dishes, while our catering services bring the Neil's experience to events of all sizes.From quick takeout slices to sit-down family meals, we combine generations of culinary tradition with contemporary service standards to create memorable dining experiences. Our team takes pride in treating every customer as part of the Neil's family, ensuring both longtime locals and new visitors receive the same attentive care. Through consistent quality and community focus, we have maintained our position as Wayne's premier Italian dining destination since opening our doors.
Services
Pizza
Pasta Dishes
Catering
Takeout
Delivery
BYOB Service
Sandwiches
Salads
Appetizers
Highlights and features
- We offer over 30 years of dedicated Italian culinary expertise
- Our menu features fresh, house-made dishes using premium ingredients daily
- We provide full-service catering with customizable menus for any event
- Our family-owned operation maintains personal oversight of quality standards
- We maintain flexible service options including dine-in, takeout, and delivery
What people say
Fresh ingredients
Generous portions
Authentic Italian
Friendly service
Excellent catering
Services
Pizza
Our pizza features hand-tossed dough topped with premium ingredients. From classic cheese to specialty combinations like Buffalo Chicken and White Pizza, each pie uses fresh mozzarella and house-made sauces. Gluten-free and cauliflower crust options accommodate dietary preferences while maintaining authentic flavor.
Catering
We provide full-service catering for events with customizable menus. Options include tray-sized portions of popular dishes like Chicken Parmigiana and Baked Ziti. Our team handles food preparation and presentation for occasions ranging from office luncheons to wedding receptions.
Pasta Dishes
Traditional Italian pasta selections include house-made Baked Ziti, Lasagna, and Lobster Ravioli. Diners can choose from classic preparations like Fettuccine Alfredo or modern twists such as Cavatelli Verrazzano with broccoli and cream sauce. All pasta dishes use fresh ingredients daily.
BYOB Service
As a BYOB establishment, we welcome guests to bring their preferred beverages. This service allows customers to pair personal wine selections with Italian cuisine while enjoying the restaurant's warm, family-friendly atmosphere without additional corkage fees.
Sandwiches
Hot and cold sandwich options feature premium meats and house-made components. Signature items include Chicken Napolitano and specialty combinations like the Prosciutto & Fresh Mozzarella sandwich. Large foot-long options serve as shareable platters for groups.
Questions
What makes Neil's pizza different from other local pizzerias?
Our pizza uses hand-tossed dough and premium ingredients with daily fresh preparations. We offer traditional New York-style slices alongside unique specialty pizzas.
Do you offer catering services for special events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering with customizable menus for events of all sizes, including weddings, corporate events, and family gatherings.
Can I bring my own wine to dinner?
As a BYOB establishment, we welcome guests to bring their preferred wine, beer, or spirits to enjoy with their meal.
What are your most popular menu items?
Our top sellers include classic cheese pizza, Chicken Parmigiana, Baked Ziti, and specialty sandwiches like the Chicken Napolitano.
Do you offer gluten-free options?
Yes, we provide gluten-free pizza crusts and select menu items to accommodate dietary restrictions while maintaining authentic Italian flavors.
What are your current operating hours?
We serve Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 9 PM, and Sunday from 11 AM to 9 PM.
Reviews (5)
Jehann D.
Jan 14, 2022
Report
This place is great. I'm not in the area often but a friend recommended this place and now it's my "go to" when I'm in the area. I went a while ago but still remember my first bite, the owner confidently said it was the best... he wasn't kidding!! I love their buffalo chicken pizza the service was fairly quick.. it's a hidden gem!!
Anthony I.
Dec 18, 2021
Report
Lousy food as the pizza is often undercooked, they go cheap on the quantity of food for sandwiches, the veal is made from roadkill, the people working there (quite a few) are obnoxious and they should just reform the place. Angelo's father in law Neal would not be happy with what his business turned into. Of course he still does his dirty because he gives freebies for the local Roman Catholic Church. This is what makes Wayne township look bad
Benjamin G.
Nov 26, 2021
Report
I needed to change the rating because it wasn't fair enough. This man working at Neil's made fun of me with his coworker because I calmly asked him for a second refill. I completely understand he cannot give me another one and he is doing his job. I am not disappointed by that at all. He felt the need to make fun of me with his coworker right in front of me. The employees at this restaurant need to be put in order because I may never step foot into this place ever again. I proudly present this place with one star.
Greg V.
Nov 02, 2021
Report
I for one think they do a great job here. I've ordered plain pies and sandwiches recently and was never disappointed. The food was cooked just enough for my liking, people who prefer it closer to burnt/crispy might be turned off. I thought the way they made it was perfectly fine.
Peter B.
Aug 01, 2021
Report
Pizza was OK, but not a very friendly owner and seem unappreciative of my business. Charged an extra .60 cents on a $16.00 plus tax order. Never informed me of their service charge for using a credit card.