Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Authentic Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Midland Park, NJ
Brothers Pizzeria has been serving authentic Southern Italian cuisine since 1970, rooted in family tradition and culinary heritage. Founded by Nino Mazzola, a self-taught pizzaiolo who transitioned from construction work to pizza-making, our establishment has grown from a small pizzeria to a beloved dining destination in Midland Park, NJ. Over 45 years, we've maintained a commitment to quality ingredients, traditional Sicilian recipes, and a welcoming atmosphere that reflects our family values. Our menu features brick-oven pizzas, homemade dishes, and catering services that showcase the expertise passed down through generations. Led by Anthony Mazzola and Roberto Mannino, our team blends old-world techniques with modern hospitality to create memorable dining experiences.

We prioritize fresh, seasonal ingredients and time-honored preparation methods that have remained unchanged for decades. Our rustic farmhouse setting accommodates both intimate and communal dining, with outdoor seating available seasonally. Catering services extend our culinary excellence to private events, offering customized menus and full-service support. As a family-owned business, we treat employees and customers alike as part of our extended family, fostering a culture of dedication and care. This enduring approach has made us a trusted local institution while maintaining the authenticity that defines our brand.
Services
Brick Oven Pizza Catering Services Gift Cards Online Ordering Family Dining Event Hosting Seasonal Outdoor Dining
Details
  • Year established: 1970
Highlights and features
  • We've served authentic Italian cuisine since 1970 with family recipes unchanged for decades
  • Our chefs combine Sicilian heritage with modern culinary techniques
  • We offer full-service catering with customized menus for any occasion
  • Our brick-oven pizzas use time-honored preparation methods from Southern Italy
  • We maintain a family-friendly atmosphere with both traditional and communal seating
Services
Brick Oven Pizza
Our signature brick oven pizzas feature traditional Southern Italian preparation with hand-tossed dough and fresh ingredients. Each pizza cooks to perfection in our custom-built ovens, maintaining the authentic texture and flavor passed down through generations. The menu includes classic combinations and specialty pies that showcase our Sicilian heritage.
Catering Services
Full-service catering for events up to 80 guests combines our Southern Italian specialties with professional service. We offer customizable menus with options for both on-site and off-site events, including chafing dishes, equipment rentals, and optional servers. Our experience hosting weddings and private functions ensures memorable culinary experiences.
Family Dining
Rustic farmhouse setting accommodates both intimate and communal dining experiences. The family-friendly environment features traditional seating and communal tables in a warm atmosphere decorated with custom millwork. Outdoor patio dining available seasonally April through October complements the indoor spaces.
Gift Cards
Refillable gift cards provide flexible gifting options for any occasion. Available in any denomination with no expiration date, these cards work for food purchases but not gratuities. Customers can order physical cards by phone for direct mailing to recipients.
Online Ordering
Convenient online platform enables digital ordering for pickup or delivery. The system maintains menu accuracy and order tracking while preserving our commitment to quality. Customers access the same traditional recipes and portions through digital channels as in-restaurant experiences.
People
Nino Mazzola
Founder
Founder of Brothers Pizzeria, Nino transitioned from construction work to pizza-making in 1970. He established the restaurant's traditional approach using self-taught techniques that remain unchanged. Now semi-retired, he still contributes by working Friday nights in the kitchen.
Anthony Mazzola
Co-Owner
Son of Nino and Anna, Anthony learned pizza-making from his father while studying international business. He led the 2012 expansion that created Pizzaiolo Brothers. Combines business acumen with culinary tradition to maintain quality across all operations.
Roberto Mannino
Co-Owner
Sicilian-born Roberto mastered traditional pizza-making at his cousin's pizzeria before joining the family business in 2000. His expertise in Sicilian techniques influences many menu items. Contributes both culinary skills and operational management.
Vera Mannino
Head Chef
Daughter of Nino and Anna, Vera developed her culinary skills in Sicily before returning to help expand the business. Her recipes form the foundation of many menu offerings. Oversees kitchen operations while maintaining traditional cooking methods.
Questions
What type of cuisine does Pizzaiolo by Brothers serve?
We specialize in Southern Italian cuisine with a focus on traditional Sicilian dishes and brick-oven pizzas made using family recipes from 1970.
Do you offer catering services for private events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering for events up to 80 guests with customizable menus, equipment rentals, and optional servers for both on-site and off-site locations.
Are gift cards available for purchase?
We offer refillable gift cards with no expiration date, available in any denomination through our restaurant or by phone order for direct mailing.
What dining options are available?
We provide traditional and communal seating in our rustic farmhouse setting, seasonal outdoor patio dining from April to October, and online ordering for pickup or delivery.
Reviews (6)
Adam Domo
Jan 02, 2022 Report
Top notch high quality new jersey Pizza. Good selection of slices. Zero complaints. Definitely one of the more consistent nj pizza joints.. I definitely miss the old brothers location though (its been almost 15+ years at this point I think).
Alex Plasencia
Dec 10, 2021 Report
I ordered a pepperoni pizza and garlic knots. It's a very simple order, but what I received was absolutely terrible. Cheese immediately fell off the pizza as soon as you picked it up, the thickest layers of semi-melted mozzarella you've ever seen, puddles of grease, and crust that was enveloped in cheese and sauce. Simply put, it was a sloppy, bad pizza. On top of that, the garlic knots were overcooked and bitter. I will never order from this restaurant again. They have a lot of nerve charging as much as they do for bad food. Thankfully, I ordered through Slice and they have excellent customer
Jacob Zimer
Oct 24, 2021 Report
Always have enjoyed their blackened salmon Caesar salad. Pizza is ok too. Would recommend for anyone in the MP, Wyckoff and Ridgewood area.
Rebecca Madero
Aug 29, 2021 Report
They keep me coming back for more! Amazing food, wonderful staff, prompt delivery and did I mention how great their food is? We had ordered a chicken cesar salad, they forgot our chicken. Called back and delivered it quick :)
Yves Cloarec
Aug 22, 2021 Report
Unpretentious, tasty Italian-inspired fare. Friendly staff. Their thin-crust pizza are delicious but don t be fooled: a "personal" pizza ($16 and up) easily feeds 2, maybe 3. Bring your own wine, as they allow it and don't have a liquor license. Note: Friday and Saturday night they don't make the personal pizzas so, yes, pricier; but one pie feeds more people, so it works out...Nice place for a casual meal but to my mind the decor is probably not "romantic" enough for date night--though that depends on your date, I guess...
Andrew Antropow
Aug 21, 2021 Report
Great Italian food. I love their chicken marsala, one of my favorites in the area. Food is really fresh and tasty. Sauce is really good. I think it's a family operation.