Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
14 Years
experience
Authentic American Dining Experience in Pompton Lakes
Mack's American Bar & Grill has been a cornerstone of the Pompton Lakes community since 2012, building on a rich legacy of hospitality that began with the Pompton Lakes Volunteer Fire Department's founding in 1895. Our establishment combines historical significance with modern American dining, offering a menu crafted from fresh ingredients to ensure every meal reflects our commitment to quality. With a warm, comfortable atmosphere and professional staff, we specialize in classic American dishes, including burgers, steaks, seafood, and Sunday brunch served in a setting that balances casual dining with sophisticated touches.

Our extensive beverage selection features signature cocktails, local beers, and wines, complementing every occasion from casual meals to private events. As a family-owned business, we prioritize customer satisfaction through consistent food quality, attentive service, and a dedication to creating memorable dining experiences that keep guests returning. Our commitment to excellence is demonstrated through our 50-year reputation in the region, though our physical location at 300 Wanaque Avenue has been serving the community since 1902 as part of the town's historical fabric.
Services
Burgers Steaks Seafood Cocktails Sunday Brunch Private Events Happy Hour Takeout Gift Cards Wine List
Details
  • Year established: 2012
Highlights and features
  • Warm, comfortable atmosphere with historical charm
  • Professional staff with decades of local hospitality experience
  • Consistent high-quality dishes using fresh ingredients
  • Signature Macks Tails cocktails and curated beverage selection
  • Private banquet facility for special events
Services
Burgers
Our made-to-order burgers feature premium cuts of meat, fresh toppings, and house-made sauces. Customers can customize their perfect burger with cheese, bacon, crispy onions, or avocado for a personalized meal. The menu includes specialty options like the Mack's Burger with fried egg and herb aioli, showcasing our commitment to American comfort food with elevated touches.
Cocktails
Mack's Tails signature cocktails blend classic techniques with innovative flavors. Featuring premium spirits, house-made syrups, and creative garnishes, each drink offers a unique experience. Highlights include the Espresso Martini with Stoli Vanil and the Pineapple Crush with St Germaine. Our bartenders prioritize quality and presentation for every hand-crafted beverage.
Seafood
We source high-quality seafood daily to ensure optimal flavor and texture. Dishes like Pan Seared Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes and Sauted Jumbo Shrimp highlight our coastal influences. Each plate pairs with house-made sides like Yukon Gold mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables, creating balanced meals that satisfy seafood enthusiasts.
Private Events
Our dedicated private room accommodates groups for celebrations or business gatherings. The space features AV capabilities, customizable seating, and exclusive menu options. Whether hosting cocktail parties or plated dinners, our team ensures seamless execution with professional service that maintains our restaurant's warm atmosphere for special occasions.
Sunday Brunch
Weekly brunch service offers hearty breakfast dishes and lighter lunch options. Highlights include Steak and Eggs, Breakfast Sandwiches, and house-made omelets served with fresh fruit or potatoes. The menu balances traditional favorites with creative twists, providing weekend guests with a leisurely dining experience in our welcoming environment.
Questions
What are Mack's American Bar & Grill's operating hours?
We're open Monday-Thursday 3 PM–10 PM, Friday-Saturday 12 PM–10 PM, and Sunday 12 PM–9 PM, with extended bar hours on weekends.
Does Mack's offer takeout or delivery options?
Yes, takeout is available during all operating hours. Call directly at 973-513-9543 to place your order for pickup.
Are reservations required for dining?
Reservations are available but not mandatory. We recommend booking for weekend dinners or private events through our website or phone.
Can I purchase gift cards for special occasions?
Yes, both physical and digital gift cards are available for any amount. They make perfect presents for birthdays, holidays, or corporate gifting.
Does Mack's host private events or parties?
Our banquet facility accommodates groups with customizable menus, AV equipment, and dedicated service for weddings, birthdays, or business functions.
What makes Mack's cocktails unique?
Our Macks Tails signature cocktails feature premium spirits, house-made ingredients, and creative presentation. Bartenders craft each drink with attention to balance and flavor profiles.
Reviews (7)
Sobeyda Romero
Oct 27, 2021 Report
Loved the food and drinks. The service was amazing the ladies were very attentive and we had a party of 20. Thank you
Richard Boult
Sep 24, 2021 Report
Amazing food. i was so full but didnt want to stop eating. bartender was awesome!!! first time there would go back with friends for sure
Gary Castan
Aug 23, 2021 Report
Very welcomingmanagement, great customer service, was me & my family 1st time going, will be going back
Bluenito
Jun 04, 2021 Report
A great place to stop by for a quick bite, and the food is worth the price. However, the service could've been a bit better by checking in more often than once every 30 minutes.
Cactus Jack
Apr 03, 2021 Report
The food was good. The server we had was very helpful and recommended a delicious entree for me. I will definitely be back.
Hugo Sanchez
Feb 18, 2021 Report
When I came here for the first time, in 2012, I made a review in which I said this was (and still is) by far the best restaurant around. Today, January 16th 2021. They blew my mind, and my palate... (again) with the absolutely best meal I have ever had here (this is a big statement because everything here is delicious) in almost a decade of delight. You must try the surf & turf chimichurri with broccoli and tostones - Drinks where on point too. The Martini and a campirinha. Well done guys and gals...
Oh, wait, the service is as good as everything else there!
The Critical J.
Dec 20, 2019 Report
PROS: This place was a very neat bar/restaurant. It was very clean, had a nice bar set up along with a nice dining setup. The food was good and the prices were right. Our waitress, Suzanne had to be one of the most friendly waitresses that have ever served us. The owner, Craig, was also very upbeat and helped her out. The bathrooms were also very clean and had individual towels and a laundry basket rather than the air blowers that take 7 years to dry your hands
CONS: The bathrooms were one person bathrooms which can cause a line and there was only street parking
OVERALL: Excellent place to eat