Business Details
27 Years
experience
Authentic Pizza & Cheesecake in Sarasota, FL
At Rico's Pizzeria, we've been crafting exceptional pizza experiences since May 29, 1999. As a family-owned establishment in Gulf Gate, Sarasota, we take pride in making every item to order with fresh, hand-tossed dough prepared daily on our premises. Our commitment to quality extends to our homemade cheesecakes, available in classic and innovative flavors like Key Lime and Salted Caramel. We specialize in customizing dishes to meet individual preferences, ensuring every customer finds exactly what they crave. Our team takes personal responsibility for customer satisfaction, offering a Rewards Program with exclusive benefits.Recognized among America's top 20 pizzerias, we also provide catering services for events ranging from birthdays to corporate functions. The Big Richie Challenge invites adventurous eaters to conquer our 12-pound pizza for a free meal and commemorative T-shirt. Located at 6547 Gateway Avenue, we serve Sarasota daily from 11 AM to 10 PM, maintaining direct customer relationships through our owner-managed operations.
Services
Pizza Catering
Fresh Cheesecake
Private Events
Takeout Orders
Rewards Program
Details
- Year established: 1999
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 1999 with consistent quality
- Fresh dough made daily on premises
- Fully customizable pizza creations available
- Award-winning catering for special events
- Unique Big Richie Challenge for pizza enthusiasts
What people say
Best pizza in Sarasota
Amazing cheesecake varieties
Great event catering
Loved the Big Richie Challenge
Perfect customization options
Services
Pizza Catering
We provide professional pizza catering for events of all sizes, from intimate gatherings to large corporate functions. Our mobile catering setup brings fresh, hand-tossed pizzas directly to your venue with customizable toppings and dietary options. Clients receive personalized menu planning assistance and event coordination support to ensure perfect execution.
Fresh Cheesecake
Our homemade cheesecakes feature premium ingredients in both classic and innovative flavors. Available in Original New York, Chocolate Peanut Butter, and seasonal varieties like Pumpkin and Peppermint. Each cheesecake is prepared fresh daily in our Gulf Gate kitchen using traditional baking methods for consistent quality and texture.
Private Events
We specialize in creating memorable pizza-themed events for birthdays, school functions, and corporate gatherings. Our staff assists with menu customization, venue setup, and service coordination for both dine-in and off-site events. Clients receive dedicated event management support and flexible ordering options for group sizes of any scale.
Takeout Orders
Our takeout service provides freshly prepared pizzas and cheesecakes for convenient home enjoyment. Customers can customize orders for pickup with full topping flexibility and special requests. We maintain strict quality control during packaging to ensure optimal freshness and presentation for all off-premise orders.
Rewards Program
Our customer rewards program offers exclusive benefits for frequent patrons. Members earn points on purchases that convert to discounts, receive special offers, and gain access to limited-time promotions. The program provides personalized value through targeted incentives while maintaining simplicity in point accumulation and redemption.
People
Mark Riley
Owner
Mark Riley founded Rico's Pizzeria in 1999 with a vision to create Sarasota's best pizza. As owner, he maintains hands-on oversight of quality control and customer satisfaction, personally addressing feedback to ensure exceptional dining experiences.
Questions
What catering options do you offer for large events?
We provide full-service pizza catering for events up to 100+ guests with customizable menus, on-site preparation, and staff assistance. Clients receive personalized menu planning and event coordination support.
What are your regular business hours?
We're open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM for dine-in, takeout, and catering services at our Gulf Gate location.
What cheesecake flavors do you currently offer?
Our regular cheesecake menu includes Original New York, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Double Chocolate, White Chocolate Raspberry, Key Lime, Salted Caramel, Butterfinger, and Oreo varieties with seasonal options available.
Can I customize my pizza order beyond standard toppings?
Yes, we welcome special requests for pizza modifications. Our made-to-order approach allows complete customization of toppings, crusts, and preparation methods to meet individual preferences.
What is the Big Richie Challenge?
The Big Richie Challenge features a 12-pound pizza that two people must finish together within 45 minutes. Successful participants receive the meal free and commemorative T-shirts.
Do you offer delivery services?
We provide self-managed delivery for local orders and maintain our own delivery fleet to ensure quality control, but do not use third-party delivery platforms.
Videos
Reviews (4)
Shawn D.
Jan 31, 2022
Report
It was very unorganized when we went in to pick up our 4 meals. When we got home we realized they had forgotten to give us our salads. There was hardly any sauce on our pasta which made everything pretty bland. We were hoping that this would be our new place for takeout. I'm wondering if the pizza is any better than the meals, but not so sure I'm willing to try.
Buffalo Bills Report
Jan 29, 2022
Report
I ordered a pizza and Stromboli at lunch time today and when I ate it, the pizza and stromboli was raw! It was the most disgusting food Ive ever had. A complete waste of over $40!
Dan Gregor
Jan 29, 2022
Report
Reminded me of that small neighborhood pizza shop that excels at what they do... Don't expect a spacious restaurant with dozens of tables and the red and white checkered table cloths... This is a carryout/delivery pizza joint that squeezed in 4 or 5 tables for a few lucky sit down patrons. Super people, great food.
Myles B.
Jan 16, 2022
Report
As usual I ordered the King Neptune, best one yet! Tons of seafood and right amount of garlic. Wife got the sampler and loved it. Great place great Owner, great staff.