Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Go-To Pizza Destination in Fort Myers, FL
Leoni's Pizzeria has been redefining gourmet dining in Southwest Florida since 1956. Our commitment to quality ingredients, including 100% natural Wisconsin cheese and locally sourced produce, ensures every dish meets our exacting standards. With over 20 years of service in the region, we've perfected New England-style pizza, handcrafted Philly cheese steaks, and fresh pasta dishes using time-honored recipes. Our family-owned operation maintains a dedication to culinary excellence, offering diverse menu options from award-winning wings to house-made desserts. We combine traditional techniques with modern innovation to deliver exceptional flavors across multiple locations.

Our experienced team prioritizes customer satisfaction through consistent quality and attentive service. From casual dining to catering special events, we maintain the same rigorous standards established in our founding year. Our menu reflects decades of culinary refinement, featuring over 50 years of combined pizza-making expertise. We remain committed to community engagement while upholding the authenticity that earned our reputation. Every meal reflects our philosophy that food should be both delicious and made with integrity.
Services
Gourmet Pizza Philly Cheese Steaks Catering Services Pasta Dishes Salads
Details
  • Year established: 1956
Highlights and features
  • We've perfected pizza-making since 1956 with authentic family recipes
  • Our menu features 100% natural Wisconsin cheese in every pizza
  • Award-winning wings with eight sauce options available for delivery
  • We offer online ordering with customizable toppings and flavors
  • Family-owned operation maintains consistent quality across all locations
Services
Gourmet Pizza
Our signature pizzas feature 100% natural Wisconsin cheese, homemade dough, and a special blend of pizza sauce. Available in three sizes with over 20 toppings including premium options like steak and shrimp. Customers can create custom combinations or choose from 15 specialty pizzas like the Margherita and Buffalo Chicken.
Philly Cheese Steaks
Authentic Philly cheese steaks made with USDA Choice 100% steak and melted cheese on a toasted roll. Available in regular or deluxe versions with fried onions, green peppers, and mushrooms. Served with potato chips or as a hoagie with lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing.
Catering Services
Full-service catering for events of all sizes featuring our popular menu items. Options include family-style platters, buffet setups, and custom menus for weddings or corporate events. We provide delivery, setup, and cleanup services for events in Fort Myers, Bonita Springs, and Naples.
Pasta Dishes
Homemade pasta specialties including lasagna, fettuccine Alfredo, and shrimp scampi spaghetti. Dishes feature fresh ingredients like house-made marinara sauce and imported cheeses. Options range from classic spaghetti with meatballs to premium seafood pasta combinations.
Salads
Gourmet salad options with crisp greens, vine-ripened vegetables, and premium toppings. Choose from eight signature salads including Caesar, Greek, and Spinach varieties. All salads feature homemade dressings and can be upgraded with grilled chicken, shrimp, or gyro meat.
People
Thomas Venetis
Owner
Co-owner Thomas Venetis brings decades of restaurant experience to Leoni's Pizzeria. He oversees daily operations and maintains quality control across all three locations. His commitment to authentic recipes and customer satisfaction drives the business's continued success.
Joanne Venetis
Owner
Co-owner Joanne Venetis manages front-of-house operations and community relations. With over 20 years in the hospitality industry, she ensures every customer receives personalized attention. Her leadership helps maintain the pizzeria's reputation for exceptional service.
Questions
What are your most popular menu items?
Our award-winning wings, New England-style pizza, and Philly cheese steaks are top favorites. Customers also love our homemade lasagna and shrimp scampi spaghetti.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide full catering services for events with options ranging from casual platters to formal buffet setups across all our locations.
What are your delivery hours?
Delivery is available during regular operating hours: 11 AM - 10 PM Monday-Thursday, 11 AM - 11 PM Friday-Saturday, and 12 PM - 10 PM Sunday.
Can I customize my pizza toppings?
Yes, we offer 20+ toppings including premium options like steak and shrimp, with prices starting at $1.50 per topping depending on pizza size.
Do you have gluten-free options?
We offer gluten-free pizza crusts and pasta alternatives to accommodate dietary restrictions while maintaining our signature flavors.
Are there kid-friendly menu options?
Yes, our kids menu features chicken tenders, spaghetti with meatballs, and cheese quesadillas with appropriate portion sizes for children.
Reviews (6)
Wendy Grimm
Dec 31, 2021 Report
I have been a frequent customer for 20 years. Last week I ordered 30 medium wings and ate 1. I hoped that I was mistakenly given hot wings instead of medium. I ordered (30) again last night and they were awful again. I called today to ask if this was a permanent change and was told they did change their supplier. I wasn't asked for my name. I wasn't offered a reimbursement or a discount on a future order. I'm done with Leoni's. Your prices are much to high to be treating loyal customers like that and my money spends anywhere.
Michael Smith
Dec 15, 2021 Report
We are visiting here and were looking for spaghetti takeout. We ordered the tray of Spaghetti and meatballs. When we got back from picking it up we were so disappointed with the meal. Sauce was smashed tomatoes with the core and skins. There wasnt much of the sauce. The meatballs seemed like they were made out of soybeans or something yuck. The bread was sub rolls and had spaghetti seasoning instead of garlic bread. We threw the whole meal in the trash. Rated it a 2 star because the girl at the counter was nice.
Lisa Nardello
Oct 24, 2021 Report
Consistently great, best cheesesteak in SWFL, friendly service. They go the extra mile with their thoughtful delivery team. I work at a local arena and they deliver to us on time and the food is always hot and delicious!
Ellen Perris
Oct 12, 2021 Report
The supreme pizza was AMAZING! Tons of toppings, excellent crust and loads of cheese. The perfect pie! Greek salad was excellent as well. Loads of feta and toppings. The bonus was the hard boiled egg. Never seen that on a Greek before and we loved it. Fabulous food while watching the Penn State game! Thats Amore!
John Henahan
Sep 22, 2021 Report
Our family used to love Leonis but the last two times weve ordered from them they severely undercooked our pizza to the point of it being inedible. Raw dough, slice falls apart instantly, just horrible lack of quality recently.
Kelli
Sep 05, 2021 Report
Mmmm pizza was delicious, tasty,. Had the supreme and all toppings stayed on the pizza!!! Impressed by the quality.. Hands down best pizza I have tasted since I moved to Florida 3 years ago. You have a new loyal customer and friend!!