Business Details
Authentic Italian Dining Experience in Lewiston
Casa Antica is a family-run Italian dining establishment rooted in the heart of Lewiston, NY. Since our founding, we have dedicated ourselves to delivering authentic Italian cuisine crafted from recipes passed down through generations. Our chefs, Calogero and Jack Soldano, bring decades of combined experience in traditional and innovative Italian cooking techniques, specializing in both southern and northern Italian dishes. We source only the freshest ingredients to create homemade meals, from hand-rolled pasta to wood-fired pizzas, complemented by an extensive wine list featuring selections from Italy and global vineyards.Our commitment to quality extends to our catering services, which provide custom menus for events of all sizes. The warm, welcoming atmosphere of our dining room and outdoor patio reflects our belief that dining should be a shared, joyful experience. We prioritize reservations to ensure optimal service but remain dedicated to accommodating walk-ins whenever possible. With over 30 years of culinary expertise, we continue to serve as a cornerstone of authentic Italian dining in the Lewiston community.
Services
Italian Dining
Catering Services
Takeout Orders
Wine Pairing
Private Events
Highlights and features
- Family-run with over 30 years of Italian culinary tradition.
- Chefs specialize in both southern and northern Italian cuisine.
- Daily preparation of dishes using fresh, high-quality ingredients.
- Extensive wine list featuring Italian and international selections.
- Custom catering services for events with tailored menus.
What people say
Outstanding service
Delicious food
Fantastic server
Great wine selection
Excellent red sauce
Services
Italian Dining
Experience authentic Italian cuisine in a warm, family-friendly atmosphere. Our menu features homemade pasta, wood-fired pizzas, and traditional entrees crafted from regional recipes. Dine indoors or enjoy seasonal al fresco dining on our patio.
Catering Services
Custom catering for weddings, corporate events, and private gatherings. Choose from la carte options or curated packages with traditional Italian dishes. Available for delivery or pickup with advance notice.
Wine Pairing
Explore an extensive wine list featuring Italian varietals and international selections. Our sommeliers recommend pairings to enhance the flavors of your meal, from rich pasta dishes to delicate seafood.
Takeout Orders
Order freshly prepared Italian dishes for pickup. Enjoy homemade pasta, pizzas, and entrees at home with our convenient takeout service. Gluten-free and allergy-friendly options available upon request.
Private Events
Host intimate gatherings or special occasions in our restaurants private spaces. We offer customized menus, dedicated service, and a charming ambiance for celebrations like anniversaries or holiday parties.
People
Calogero Soldano
Head Chef
With over 30 years in Italian cuisine, Chef Calogero crafts daily dishes using traditional recipes passed through generations. His expertise spans southern and northern Italian cooking techniques.
Jack Soldano
Co-Chef
Co-Chef Jack collaborates with Calogero to blend traditional methods with modern flair. His culinary background ensures every dish meets Casa Anticas standards of authenticity and quality.
Questions
What Italian regional cuisines do you specialize in?
We specialize in both southern and northern Italian dishes, including Sicilian carbonara, Neapolitan pizzas, and northern-style risottos.
Do you offer catering services for private events?
Yes, we provide custom catering with both à la carte and package options for weddings, corporate events, and family gatherings.
Are reservations required for dining?
Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends, but we accommodate walk-ins based on availability.
What wine options are available?
Our wine list includes Italian varietals like Chianti and Barolo, plus international selections from France, Spain, and California.
Do you have gluten-free menu options?
Yes, we offer gluten-free pasta substitutions and allergy-friendly dishes upon request with advance notice.
What are your outdoor dining hours?
Seasonal patio dining is available during regular operating hours when weather permits.
Reviews (7)
Gina Pasquantino
Oct 18, 2021
Report
Wont let me leave a no stars....This wasnt the 1st time there. Will be our last. Ordered an appetizer, salad and entree. Portion size was very large. But quality of food was very bad. Starting with the bread...garlic knots were hard as a rock, rice balls were cold is spots an very Luke warm in others. Salad was good ( hard to ruin a salad) The entree was chicken parmigiana...chicken was tough and pasta over cooked. They brought the plate it was enough to feed a family of 4 or 5. But I could find a taker for the left overs, because of the poor quality of food. Staff was horrible. Not friendly
Mark Riggi
Sep 04, 2021
Report
The food is fabulous and the service is excellent. Our server was a delight and had a contagious smile. The food came out in a very reasonable amount of time. The food presentation and taste was excellent. Will go again a must stop.
Stephanie Smart
Aug 18, 2021
Report
The server said the cook (the owner's son) puts his blood, sweat and tears into the food. It seemed an accurate description, since that's the only flavoring we could taste. This place was positioned as a high end Italian restaurant, it left much to be desired. We began our evening (first night of our honeymoon, btw) with the waitress checking her watch as we walked in the door, an hour before closing. We were asked twice, on a Monday night, if we had a reservation even though the were many empty tables. We were treated as an inconvenience the entire time we were there. I thought, 'ok, hopefully
Carlos Diaz
Aug 13, 2021
Report
Amazing food and atmosphere. Would have loved to have found this day one we were here instead of the last night. We wouldn't have eaten here more often.
Matthew G.
Aug 03, 2021
Report
If I could give this place more than five stars I would, they have a very unique menu but their specials are to die for! Not sure I'm supposed to mention this but if you want a real treat ask for the P'nut special it's a Gnocchi mac and cheese with steak. It's Not on the menu but it's to amazing. It's one of the best Italian restaurants I've ever been to! I also had the cowboy ribeye which is in the picture, probably one of the best steaks I've ever had.
Anna DiNoto
Jul 23, 2021
Report
First time coming here. The food was really good, big portions for the entrees. A little over priced, paid $20 for 4 mini fried goat cheese balls thought that was a little crazy. The fried goat cheese balls were very good though and I definitely would get them again. The gnocchi pesto was absolutely amazing, it tasted so good. My boyfriend got that filet and he loved it Atmosphere was cute. They do have a patio too. Overall it was a good experience and I do recommend, just be prepared for the prices.
Christina Carter
Jul 18, 2021
Report
Nice Italian restaurant in Lewiston. I wasn't entirely sure what to order so I got a personal pizza which was huge. Depending on how hungry you are you could very well share the pizza.