Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Authentic Pizza & Italian Favorites in Lancaster, NY
At The Pizza Heist, we combine traditional Italian techniques with American culinary innovation to deliver a diverse menu of handcrafted pizzas, fresh subs, and flavorful sides. Our kitchen specializes in creating bold combinations like the Stinger Pizza, featuring steak, chicken fingers, lettuce, and tomato, alongside classic favorites such as Hawaiian and White Pizza. With over 16 unique pizza options, daily specials from Monday to Friday, and a variety of appetizers including funnel cake fries and mozzarella sticks, we cater to every palate. Our commitment to quality ingredients, from golden crusts to fresh toppings, ensures every bite delivers exceptional taste.

Whether you're craving a quick slice or a family-sized sheet pizza, our team prioritizes speed, consistency, and customer satisfaction. We operate seven days a week with extended hours on weekends to accommodate busy schedules, and our online ordering system ensures convenience for takeout or delivery. Located in Lancaster, NY, we pride ourselves on being a local favorite for delicious, affordable meals that keep customers returning.
Services
Pizza Subs Wings Salads Tacos Wraps Appetizers Chicken Fingers Hoagies Combos
Highlights and features
  • We offer 16+ unique pizza options, including the exclusive Stinger Pizza.
  • Our daily Monday-Friday specials provide exceptional value on fresh meals.
  • We serve handcrafted subs, wings, and salads with quality ingredients daily.
  • Online ordering ensures quick, convenient takeout or delivery options.
  • Positive customer reviews highlight our consistent quality and friendly service.
What people say
Delicious pizza Best in the area Great value Amazing food Meal for a steal
Services
Pizza
Our pizzas feature hand-tossed crusts, house-made sauces, and premium toppings like steak, chicken fingers, and fresh vegetables. Choose from 16+ varieties including the Stinger Pizza with lettuce and tomato or build your own. Available in personal, small, large, and sheet sizes to suit any appetite.
Subs
Toasted Costanzo's rolls filled with meats, cheeses, and fresh toppings like lettuce, tomatoes, and seasoned oil. Options include cold subs, hot subs, and specialty items like the Stinger Sub with steak and chicken. Served as mini or whole portions for customizable meals.
Wings
Available bone-in or boneless with nine sauces including Hot BBQ, Garlic Parm, and Honey Mustard. Served in portions from 10 to 50 pieces, wings come with bleu cheese and celery. Regular and char-broiled options cater to diverse flavor preferences.
Appetizers
Shareable appetizers include mozzarella sticks, onion rings, and unique options like funnel cake fries and pizza logs. Larger sampler platters combine multiple items for groups. Sizes range from small to party portions for gatherings.
Salads
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomatoes, and premium proteins like grilled chicken or tuna top our salads. Choose from classic options like Chef or Antipasto, or customize with add-ons. Available in small, large, or party trays for events.
Questions
What are The Pizza Heist's operating hours?
We're open Sunday-Thursday 11AM-9PM, Friday 11AM-11PM, and Saturday 11AM-10PM.
Do you offer online ordering?
Yes! Visit our website to place takeout or delivery orders for our full menu.
What pizza sizes are available?
We offer personal, small (12"), large (16"), and sheet pizzas for individual or group orders.
Are there vegetarian options on the menu?
Yes! Try our Veggie Pizza, Antipasto Salad, or customize a meat-free sub or wrap.
Do you cater events?
Contact us directly to discuss catering options for parties, office events, or gatherings.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, debit cards, and cash for in-store purchases.
Reviews (4)
Jessica Peck
Jan 12, 2022 Report
I have in wny most of my life and after 8 yrs away I thought maybe it just tasted so good because I missed buffalo pizza. Then I orderd somewhere else and nope.. This place is by far one of the best pizzas I've ever had.. The sauce, the bubbly crust, just amazing !
Alisa M. Oldacre
Nov 10, 2021 Report
Food is really good, just wish that they offered wheat sub rolls like many of the other local pizzerias.
Steven Konieczek
Sep 29, 2021 Report
Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and 20 wings online, which is a pretty simple order. Got home and found a cheese pizza, no pep. Double checked the email confirmation and even the paper slip on the pizza box and both confirmed that a pepperoni pizza was ordered. I usually let a careless error or two slide but theyve made quite a few of them over the years so Im done with this place. A cheese pizza might be fine if youre a child at 8 year olds birthday party but I wanted pepperoni and like any reasonable person, I want to receive what I ordered and what I paid for. The only saving grace
Gregory Gelz
Sep 15, 2021 Report
Sloppy pie. Nothing remarkable about the cheese and pepperoni. Chicken finger pizza was not as good as some other local places.