Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Authentic New York-Style Pizza in Gray, TN
Stephens Pizzeria has been crafting authentic New York-style pizzas using a cherished family recipe for over five decades. Our commitment to quality begins with daily preparation of fresh ingredients, from hand-rolled dough to house-made sausage and a proprietary buttery cheese blend. Every vegetable is sliced each morning, and meats are carefully selected for their superior flavor. Our menu features beloved classics like the Big Babbo Pizza and Philly Cheesesteak Hoagie, alongside creative specialties such as the Jamaican Jerk Pizza. We pride ourselves on maintaining the integrity of traditional New York pizza while incorporating innovative touches that keep customers returning.

With a focus on community, we offer catering services, a party room for events, and take-home pizza kits for homemade enjoyment. Customer testimonials consistently highlight our dedication to excellence, with many declaring us the best pizza in the Tri-Cities area. Our team approaches every order with the same passion that has defined our pizzeria since its founding, ensuring each slice reflects our legacy of quality and care.
Services
New York Style Pizza Hoagies Salads Catering Party Room Rentals
Highlights and features
  • We use a 50-year-old family pizza recipe perfected over generations
  • All ingredients are made fresh daily in-house including dough and meats
  • Our proprietary buttery cheese blend creates a uniquely memorable flavor
  • Catering services and private party room available for special events
  • Take-home pizza kits let you recreate our New York-style magic at home
What people say
BEST PIZZA Fresh ingredients Friendly staff Authentic taste Highly recommended
Services
New York Style Pizza
Hand-tossed pizzas made with a 50-year-old family recipe featuring fresh, house-made ingredients daily. Our signature buttery cheese blend and thin crust deliver authentic New York flavor. Available in classic and specialty varieties for dine-in, pickup, or delivery.
Catering
Full-service catering for events of all sizes featuring our popular pizzas, hoagies, and salads. Custom menus available with advance ordering through our catering form. Ideal for corporate events, weddings, and private parties.
Party Room Rentals
Private party room available for birthday celebrations, baby showers, and business meetings. Accommodates various group sizes with customized food packages. Reservations require advance booking through our contact form.
Pizza Kits
Take-home pizza kits containing fresh dough, mozzarella cheese, and pizza sauce for homemade preparation. Additional toppings available for purchase. Includes detailed instructions for recreating our New York-style pizza at home.
Salads
Hand-prepared salads using daily-sliced vegetables and premium ingredients. Featured options include the Southwest Salad with barbecue chicken and the Garden Salad paired with our signature cheese toast.
Questions
What makes Stephens Pizzeria's pizza authentic New York-style?
We use a 50-year-old family recipe with hand-tossed dough, house-made meats, and a proprietary buttery cheese blend. Our preparation methods mirror traditional New York pizzerias.
Do you offer catering services for events?
Yes, we provide full catering services with customizable menus featuring our popular pizzas, hoagies, and salads. Complete our online catering form to get started.
Can I rent the party room for special occasions?
Our private party room accommodates birthdays, showers, and business events. Contact us through our website to check availability and reserve your date.
Are take-home pizza kits available?
Yes, our DIY pizza kits include fresh dough, cheese, and sauce for homemade preparation. Additional toppings available. Instructions provided for perfect results.
What are your current operating hours?
We're open Monday-Saturday 11:00 AM-9:00 PM. The pizzeria is closed on Sundays but available for special orders through our catering service.
Reviews (4)
Phyllis Thysell
Feb 02, 2022 Report
I LOVE this place! They have the BEST CALZONE! The Greek salad is great, too! You definitely get your money's worth here! Staff are friendly, too!
Michael Gibson
Jan 04, 2022 Report
My wife and I came in, grabbed a menu, and sat down. Staff did not speak to us. Went to wash up before we ordered and BOTH restrooms had a sign saying, " Out of order." We felt that this was probably the staff's way of saying we were not welcome there, so we left without ordering. Won't be back. Hope you have a Merry Christmas.
Alison Albright
Dec 31, 2021 Report
This has been our favorite place since we moved here 2 years ago. However, the past month we ordered twice. Both times the kids working were talking with friends. Once we ordered and they didn't have our order... then they made the pizza and got it wrong when we were standing there. They overcharged and when we pointed it out, the young man said, "What do you want me to do?" Seriously? The pizza wasn't cooked. Next time they said they didn't have the order, but they did. It was under someone else's name...there was no one in the shop. Got home, pizza not cooked. We loved it here, but one more chance
Tonya Jones
Dec 24, 2021 Report
The pizza and bread sticks were great. The pizzas came out piping hot and we didn't have to wait very long. Staff was very friendly. This will be our go to for pizza for now on.. The restaurant was very clean.