Siracusa's New York Pizzeria

I love everything about this place. Especially the people behind it. They’ll treat you like gold.
The staff gave myself and my daughter a cannoli on the house while we waited for our pizza. On top of that they matched me w Nacho Libre quotes. That alone deserve 5 stars.
Hey, the pizza is delicious as well. Go here if you’re nearby.

This is real NY style pizza, and boy was it tasty. Thursday is ladies night where we get half off a bottle. I had a glass while I wanted for my pizza to cook and she bagged the bottle up for me to take to go.

This pizzaria was recommended by our daugther. We decided that we would order pizza pies from Siracusa for the wedding evening family event this past Saturday. We ordered over $140 worth of pizza and they were cold, over charred on the botton, and like rubber. I placed an on-line order for 6:15 pm but I'm guessing that they made the pizza early and left it sitting. However, I'm not sure why they were over charred, really burnt. Pic is below. We are from NJ and know a great pizza pie and this wasn't it. I have been calling for the past few days and keep getting the voicemail message

I ordered delivery for my family and it did not disappoint: house salad, calzone, kids pasta and meatball, wings, medium pizza.
All items were cooked as requested. My salad was forgotten, and a driver brought one out to me to complete the order. Their salads are always fresh.
We will order deliver again. No photos because we ate it all.

The SLICE app doesn't want to let you order for pick up. That aside the service is always good & the pizza is always good. 100% get the chicken bbq. I never liked chicken on pizza before EXCEPT their chicken bbq. Fix the online app & its 5 stars

I ordered a pepperoni pizza, but they made a pepperoni and mushroom pizza instead. I did not get the young lady 's name, but she offered to remake my order. Instead I just took the one they made, cause I was in a rush. The pizza was good and there was a nice atmosphere while I waited, so 4 stars it is.

Worst spaghetti and meatballs I’ve had in my life. We ordered spaghetti with extra meat sauce add meatballs. This was my first time here. Just tasted it and at first bite, I had to spit the meatball out. No seasoning what whatsoever, and the meat tastes processed. The noodles were dry and the sauce was absolutely flavorless. I tried 3 bites then gave up and threw my whole plate away. Will not be back.

The pizza here is the bomb! Fresh ingredients and less marinara sauce make it a great pizza, with awesome dough. I tasted their marinara sauce and it was a bit too strong for me. This leads me to believe that the lasagna and spaghetti would not be to my liking. My wife had the Stromboli with meat and spinach and it was excellent too.

How dare they put New York on their name. This is the worst food ever. The pizza is dryer out. The toppings are old and dedicatedly not fresh. I don't even know what to say about the cannoli. The shells are half filled and dripping in watery chocolate.

The pizza is so good! Fresh ingredients without excess Mariana sauce. The dough is great. You will love the simplicity and the deliciousness. Garlic rolls are good too. Nice to get such good pizza in Smyrna. Definitely will be back.

I've always gotten delivery from Siracusa's and loved it. This was the first time in the restaurant. Pizza is just as delicious, simple sausage and mushrooms are my go-to. Waitress was attentive also. Keep it up guys.

I ordered calamari and they were out so they substituted with burned (literally black) fried zucchini.
WTH. No one should have ever let this leave the kitchen. Makes you think there's no QC. The pizza was doughy. Not my favorite. MTH, Antico , Zucca, Bella's, Crispina...all far better. The wings are excellent though!

Man, when I first moved here Siracusa's was one of my go-tos. But I feel like their quality has gone downhill, but the prices have gone up? Maybe not, but my last order of two 10-inch pizzas was well over $30. That's enough to make me *shudder* want to call Domino's.

The bbq chicken pizza wasn't good at all. Crust spongey and doughy, the chicken and sauce SO SO salty (it tasted like canned chicken!). Just really disappointing. I don't think we'll be ordering from them in the future, which is a shame because we did like them back in 2018-2019. I don't know if

Staff was so awesome and so nice. The owner was nice. The salad was good. The wings were awesome. The patrons of the restaurant were even nice. But the pizza was just bad I wanted to love it because they were all so awesome. But it was so soggy and greasy it was really hard to even eat. It's the first time ever I've really had to throw away a pie. The slice was so soggy it just fell apart with soggy grease there was grease coming through the box. I'd say try the wings have a salad and a drink but the pizza I'd avoid. Thanks again sorry I had to leave a harsher review for the pizza.

I used to LOVE Siracusa's. Unfortunately, the quality of the pizza has severely declined over the past few months/years. The pizza sauce is far too salty, the cheese is gummy, and the crust manages to taste both overdone and underdone at the same time. Such a disappointment since I used to love this pizza place a lot. But lately it tastes like lunchroom pizza.

2.5 stars total is where they sit on my final verdict. The pizza was super expensive for two 10 inches for 30 bucks plus tip. For the money, the quality was completely downhill. I would expect fresh olives not canned. I can't really say much good about the experience. Nothing stood out other than the price. The pizza lacked flavor and creativity. The bar/ dining area appears busy, small and dark. The person handling the order was mask-less. I was a little concerned with that but we are in a time and space where all things are uncertain. What is certain is that this spot is not meant for

If I could give this place 10 stars I would. I just happened to see the sign and give this place a try for gluten free pizza, instead I had the wings. And oh my were they on point! They were well seasoned, with the right amount of crunch and moisture. The best lemon pepper wings I've had in years! I was told that they have .50 wings Wednesday. I'll be back for sure. I HIGHLY recommend this place.

I had been craving bruschetta for WEEKS - so I performed a Yelp search looking for bruschetta. The first place I called said they stopped serving bruschetta a couple of years ago and the second place I called, Meza Luna was closed until 5pm - so I decided to give Siracusa's a try.

Upon walking in, there were 2 folks at the bar. One guy was having a bear and the other patron, a lady, was having dinner. The server / bartender handed me a damp, paper menu then disappeared. At this time - there were no other employees visible at all. Another gentleman arrived while I was waiting to place my

Moved to this area over a year ago and really wanted to like this place as it was the closest to my home. Last night was my last time I will give them a chance and rather drive further for edible food.

Last night's order was burnt and quality of food is not their concern. Clearly only care about their regulars who by the way, stare at you like you don't belong when you go in.

Only pleasant person in the place is the young lady cashier. Hence the one star.

My exposure to Siracusa's is entirely accidental, as a dinner delivered to my home was completely my neighbors, which we found out after I interrogated their delivery guy that evening to be sure he was at the right house and he insisted that he was and my neighbor checked with me later only to confirm that my suspicious were right. Go figure, right? Anyway, the cheese pizza, Fettuccine pasta, and the wings were the bomb. All of it was good. The pizza has an authentic flavor and taste that all belongs to Siracusa's, and I simply love their wings. I wonder if they have Lemon Pepper

I've been ordering and comparing pizzerias in my area. This one is a huge disappointment.

I don't believe there's any difference between this plain cheese pizza and a Domino's Brooklyn Style. They get a star for the real sliced mushrooms vs shaved ones like a lot use. The crust was tasteless and gummy and the cheese didn't taste at all fresh.

They got a second star for offering additional food choices. Although for a ($4.95) side salad I did not expect to get old, wilted greens. The highlight was their canolli, somewhat small but delicious. At $3.95, it's about

This pizza is sooooo good!! It's the closest the REAL NY style pizza I've had since moving here 3 years ago. The only thing I've ordered from here is the pizza but I can't wait to try out other the pasta and salads.

Yummy! Give it a try if you like super thin but not. Love the cheese too. Very tasty and not greasy.

I ordered a fest and tomato pizza and my hubby and son had pepperoni. My son has claimed to hate pizza until he tried this place! Enjoy!

UPDATE: now they aren't on Grubhub or any delivery service that I can figure out so I hope they're making bank!

Soggy zucchini fritters. I called & owner said they sweated, free order next time. NEXT TIME! waisted time & $36 No next time. Waitress didn't know the difference between Stromboli & calzone, Cheap, temporary labor aka ANYBODY off the street.
Eggplant Parmesan was horrible. Only thing NYC about this place is place is it needs cleaning. Disappointing.

Went last night with a group of six it was a last minute birthday dinner. The restaurant is really 3 in one and all are really super cool. There is the Bar/kitchen area, a Patio it looked really great as well we didn't get to sit there a party was there camping out, and finally a little nook where they had a 10 top which is where we sat. The area we were in was ample for a group great circulation..... I'm the guy always hot. The server was one of the owners and she was fantastic. It was the first time for a few of us but the bulk of the group were pros.

Everything was really

Our favorite local pizza place! You see a lot of the same locals over and over. Great NY style pizza. Fantastic crust quality with just the right amount of crunch near the outside and foldable goodness closer to the center!
It's a small restaurant and the service can get a bit slow when they are busy, but they wouldn't be busy if the food wasn't good, so I can live with it.

We had two of their Specialties Pizza. One the meat lovers and one the Cuse. Those pizzas were very good their cross was fairly crispy not the best I've ever had but definitely not the worst. Very flavorful sauce and great toppings.
However the wait was horrendous. It was a good 45 minutes from the time we ordered until the food actually arrived. The restaurant itself is pretty small and cramped not a lot of available seating. Overall it was a decent meal that was worth the money that we paid for it