Business Details
Authentic New York-Style Pizza & Italian Cuisine in Smyrna
At Siracusa's New York Pizzeria, we pride ourselves on delivering the finest quality food with exceptionally friendly service that mirrors the neighborhood pizzerias of Upstate New York. Since our founding, we have specialized in hand-tossed New York-style thin crust pizza, crafted with homemade tomato sauce and Grande mozzarella cheese, alongside a diverse menu of Italian specialties including pasta, lasagna, eggplant, and chicken parmigiana. Our commitment to quality extends to our catering services, designed to bring our signature flavors to events of all sizes, from intimate gatherings to corporate functions. With a focus on fresh ingredients and authentic recipes, we ensure every dish reflects the traditions of Italian cuisine while adapting to modern tastes. Our lunch specials, including paninis, toasted subs, and jumbo cheese slices, offer convenient options without compromising on flavor or quality.The positive feedback from our customers, who consistently praise our crispy eggplant pizza, flavorful calzones, and welcoming atmosphere, underscores our dedication to excellence. We maintain transparent operations and prioritize customer satisfaction, evident in our responsive service and attention to detail. Our establishment features multiple dining areas, including a bar/kitchen, patio, and private nook, accommodating both casual meals and special occasions. By combining decades of culinary expertise with a passion for Italian cooking, we strive to be the premier destination for New York-style pizza and Italian cuisine in Smyrna. Our team's deep understanding of local preferences ensures every visit delivers an experience reminiscent of the authentic neighborhood restaurants we grew up with.
Services
Catering Services
New York-Style Pizza
Italian Cuisine
Online Ordering
Event Hosting
Draft Beer Selection
Lunch Specials
Kids Menu
Dessert Options
Wine & Beverages
Highlights and features
- We offer hand-tossed New York-style pizza crafted with homemade tomato sauce since 1995
- Our catering services accommodate events from small gatherings to large celebrations
- We use fresh mozzarella, crispy eggplant, and premium toppings in every dish
- Our menu features 14+ specialty pizzas and 10+ Italian entrees beyond standard offerings
- We maintain a welcoming neighborhood atmosphere with private dining options available
What people say
Best NY pizza
Fresh ingredients
Excellent catering
Great service
Authentic flavor
Services
Catering Services
Our catering services bring authentic New York-style pizza and Italian cuisine to your special events. We accommodate gatherings of all sizes with customizable menus featuring our signature thin-crust pizzas, pasta dishes, and Italian specialties. Clients receive personalized service from menu selection to event execution, ensuring fresh, high-quality food presentation that matches restaurant standards in any venue.
New York-Style Pizza
Hand-tossed thin-crust pizzas made with homemade tomato sauce and Grande mozzarella cheese form our core offering. Available in 10", 14", and 18" sizes, specialty options include The Cuse (meat & vegetable combination), The Meathead (multiple meats), and The Whitey (white pizza with ricotta and provolone). Customers may create custom pizzas with 20+ toppings ranging from classic pepperoni to premium grilled chicken and artichoke hearts.
Italian Cuisine
Beyond pizza, our menu features traditional Italian dishes including Chicken Parmigiana served over pasta, Eggplant Parmigiana, Fettuccine Alfredo, and Baked Ziti. We prepare pasta dishes with homemade marinara or pesto sauce, offering gluten-free options. Additional entrees include calzones stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella, stromboli with marinara filling, and lunch specials featuring paninis on toasted focaccia bread with premium ingredients.
Lunch Specials
Daily lunch specials (Tuesday-Sunday 11am-3pm) provide affordable dining options without compromising quality. Choose from Jumbo Cheese Slices with drink ($4.49-$8.99) or combination plates including side salads. Kids menu options feature pasta, cheese ravioli, and chicken tenders. All lunch items use the same high-quality ingredients as our dinner menu, maintaining consistent flavor profiles throughout service hours.
Dessert Options
Our dessert menu showcases traditional Italian confections made in-house daily. Featured items include Homemade Tiramisu with layered espresso-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cream, Fresh Cannoli with ricotta filling and chocolate chips, and Zeppoles - fried dough tossed in powdered sugar with chocolate dipping sauce. These desserts complement our main offerings, providing authentic finishing touches to complete the Italian dining experience.
Questions
Do you offer catering services for special events?
Yes, we provide full catering services for events of all sizes with customizable menus featuring our New York-style pizza and Italian specialties.
What gluten-free options are available?
We offer a 10" gluten-free crust option for any specialty pizza and gluten-free pasta upon request for select menu items.
Are there lunch specials available?
Yes, daily lunch specials (Tuesday-Sunday 11am-3pm) include Jumbo Cheese Slices with drink options starting at $4.49 and combination plates.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, debit cards, and mobile payment options for both in-restaurant and online orders.
Do you have a kids menu?
Yes, our kids menu features pasta, cheese ravioli, cheese pizza, and chicken tenders with fries, priced between $5.95 and $8.95.
Can I order online for pickup or delivery?
Yes, our website provides 24/7 online ordering for pickup or delivery of all menu items including pizza, pasta, and catering options.
Reviews (5)
James Johnson
Jan 26, 2022
Report
I love everything about this place. Especially the people behind it. Theyll treat you like gold. The staff gave myself and my daughter a cannoli on the house while we waited for our pizza. On top of that they matched me w Nacho Libre quotes. That alone deserve 5 stars.
Hey, the pizza is delicious as well. Go here if youre nearby.
Hey, the pizza is delicious as well. Go here if youre nearby.
Heather L.
Jan 19, 2022
Report
This is real NY style pizza, and boy was it tasty. Thursday is ladies night where we get half off a bottle. I had a glass while I wanted for my pizza to cook and she bagged the bottle up for me to take to go.
Mark Z.
Jan 14, 2022
Report
This pizzaria was recommended by our daugther. We decided that we would order pizza pies from Siracusa for the wedding evening family event this past Saturday. We ordered over $140 worth of pizza and they were cold, over charred on the botton, and like rubber. I placed an on-line order for 6:15 pm but I'm guessing that they made the pizza early and left it sitting. However, I'm not sure why they were over charred, really burnt. Pic is below. We are from NJ and know a great pizza pie and this wasn't it. I have been calling for the past few days and keep getting the voicemail message
Morrow Daye
Dec 29, 2021
Report
I ordered delivery for my family and it did not disappoint: house salad, calzone, kids pasta and meatball, wings, medium pizza. All items were cooked as requested. My salad was forgotten, and a driver brought one out to me to complete the order. Their salads are always fresh. We will order deliver again. No photos because we ate it all.
S. M.
Oct 30, 2021
Report
The SLICE app doesn't want to let you order for pick up. That aside the service is always good & the pizza is always good. 100% get the chicken bbq. I never liked chicken on pizza before EXCEPT their chicken bbq. Fix the online app & its 5 stars