Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Italian Kosher Restaurant in Atlanta
At Formaggio Mio, we have dedicated ourselves to crafting a unique culinary experience that seamlessly blends the rich traditions of Italian cuisine with the meticulous standards of kosher dietary laws. Our establishment prides itself on using fresh, premium ingredients to create dishes that honor both Italian flavors and Jewish culinary traditions. Every meal we prepare adheres to strict kosher principles, including our commitment to Cholov Yisroel standards for dairy purity. Our menu features handcrafted pastas, thin-crust pizzas, and a variety of other Italian specialties, all prepared with the utmost attention to quality and authenticity. We strive to provide not only exceptional food but also a warm, inviting atmosphere where families and friends can gather for memorable dining experiences.

Our dedicated team ensures every visit reflects our passion for culinary excellence and adherence to tradition. For those seeking convenient options, we offer catering services and online ordering through multiple platforms. Located in Atlanta's Briar Vista Shopping Center, we serve the local Jewish community and all patrons who appreciate authentic Italian cuisine prepared to the highest kosher standards. Our operating hours accommodate diverse schedules, including extended Sunday hours and post-Shabbat Saturday service. We remain committed to evolving our offerings while maintaining the integrity of our core values and culinary traditions.
Services
Italian Kosher Dining Thin-Crust Pizzas Fresh Pastas Catering Services Online Ordering
Highlights and features
  • We adhere to Cholov Yisroel kosher standards for dairy purity
  • Our menu features handcrafted pastas made with fresh ingredients
  • We offer catering services for Jewish community events
  • Our team maintains strict kosher preparation protocols
  • We operate extended hours including post-Shabbat Saturday service
Services
Italian Kosher Dining
Our Italian kosher dining experience combines traditional Italian flavors with strict adherence to Jewish dietary laws. We prepare all dishes using certified kosher ingredients, maintaining Cholov Yisroel standards for dairy products. The menu features house-made pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and seasonal specials that cater to both casual diners and special occasions.
Thin-Crust Pizzas
Our thin-crust pizzas feature hand-tossed dough fermented for optimal flavor, house-made sauces, and premium kosher-certified toppings. Each pizza is cooked in a wood-fired oven to achieve perfect crispness while maintaining chewy texture. Specialties include classic Margherita and custom combinations that showcase our commitment to both Italian tradition and kosher integrity.
Fresh Pastas
We craft all pastas in-house daily using fresh eggs and imported Italian flour, following strict kosher guidelines. Our menu includes traditional favorites like fettuccine Alfredo and innovative creations that incorporate seasonal ingredients. Each pasta dish demonstrates our dedication to authentic Italian techniques while maintaining compliance with Jewish dietary regulations.
Catering Services
Our catering division provides kosher-certified Italian cuisine for weddings, bar mitzvahs, and corporate events. We offer customizable menus featuring signature dishes, buffet-style service, and full event coordination. All catering meals maintain Cholov Yisroel standards and are prepared in our dedicated kosher kitchen to ensure proper separation and handling protocols.
Online Ordering
We provide multiple online ordering platforms including our website and third-party apps like Uber Eats and GrubHub. Customers can place takeout or delivery orders for our full menu of kosher Italian dishes with real-time tracking and contactless payment options. The system supports advance ordering for pickup during regular business hours.
Questions
What does Cholov Yisroel certification mean for your dairy products?
Our Cholov Yisroel certification ensures all dairy products are produced under rabbinical supervision, maintaining strict kosher standards for milk and cheese used in our dishes.
Do you offer catering for Jewish community events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering for Jewish celebrations including weddings, bar mitzvahs, and holiday gatherings with customized menus of kosher Italian dishes.
What are your Saturday operating hours?
We open 20 minutes after Shabbat concludes and serve until 11:00 PM, with our kitchen closing at 10:00 PM for food preparation.
How can I place an order for takeout or delivery?
Order through our website, Slice app, Uber Eats, or GrubHub for contactless delivery and pickup options during regular business hours.
Are your pastas made fresh daily?
Yes, all our pastas are handmade daily in-house using fresh eggs and imported Italian flour following strict kosher preparation guidelines.
Do you accommodate special dietary requirements?
While we specialize in kosher dining, we can accommodate certain dietary preferences within our menu framework while maintaining proper separation protocols.
Reviews (6)
Elena K.
Jan 25, 2022 Report
Rude girl behind the cash register. Will go back and forth with you when an order is wrong insisting she is right and when proven wrong there are no apologies or even the rechecking of her attitude. I'll never spend money here again. I'm a waitress myself but this business is making a mistake letting a young girl run FOH by herself with no manager to let her know that she shouldn't be so defensive and rude when an order was made wrong. I know she didn't cook or prepare the food herself. Even if the order was made wrong, it was okay since its literally a $8 mistake and something
Jay J.
Dec 29, 2021 Report
Had a Groupon for a large specialty pizza and fries.
Had Mexican pizza which had jalapeos and siracha and was honestly pretty darn good. A little bit sweet and a lot bit spicy! Was pleasantly surprised. Oven fired pizza. Typically these crusts are too thin for me but this one was good thickness.
Spicy fries were basically just out of the bag fries with crushed red pepper.
Pro tip: throw these in the air fryer for 5 minutes and it'll change your whole experience. Worker was nice enough too. Groupon worked nicely. Would return and try other things. Nice that this place is kosher and
Edward B.
Dec 23, 2021 Report
Not a good experience, rude staff, got the order wrong. Kept me waiting at the sign that says "Order Pickup." 10 minutes after standing there, another lady walks in and stands behind me. They look around me and ask her if she has a pickup order. They help her then turn their back on me and walk away. I say I need to pick up an order. The lady at the counter was incredibly rude. The order was completely wrong, cold and not very good. Won't go back.
A. Q.
Nov 15, 2021 Report
We live in the neighborhood and try to support our local businesses.Two months ago we ordered a pizza and it wasn't good. No problem. I will give them one more try. I ordered a pizza today. It was HORRIBLE. There were so much grease the bottom of the pizza was like a wet sponge.We had to trash the whole pizza. I won't be returning NEVER.
Robert Diaz
May 11, 2021 Report
The service is amazing. The people are kind and friendly. The food is very delicious and the place is always clean. Overall, it is a very welcoming atmosphere for all.
Kouhei M.
Feb 05, 2021 Report
Oh my God, Formaggio Mio was truly superb. The price is perfectly affordable as well. Sensational flavor. Staff are super lovely and service is very swift. Anyway, they have a good thing going here and I'm glad I stopped in.