Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
29 Years
experience
John's of Times Square - New York's Best Coal-Fired Pizza Since 1997
John's of Times Square was founded in 1997 by Madeline Castellotti, whose vision transformed a historic church into New York's largest and most unique pizzeria. Our commitment to quality is evident in every coal-fired brick oven pizza, crafted using fresh ingredients and time-honored techniques passed down through generations. With over 28 years of experience, we've become a culinary landmark, hosting events ranging from Broadway openings to private weddings.

Our team of expert pizza makers undergoes rigorous training to master the art of cooking at 800 degrees without thermostats, ensuring each pie develops distinct flavors through seasoned ovens. As a family-owned business, we continue Madeline's legacy by maintaining the highest standards of excellence while adapting to serve modern diners' evolving tastes.
Services
Coal-Fired Pizza Event Catering Gluten-Free Options Takeout & Delivery Gift Certificates
Details
  • Year established: 1997
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 28 years of pizza-making expertise
  • Our coal-fired brick ovens create unique, award-winning flavors
  • We use fresh, high-quality ingredients in every pizza
  • Our historic church location offers a one-of-a-kind dining experience
  • We host events for up to 400 guests in our spacious venue
Services
Coal-Fired Pizza
Our signature coal-fired brick ovens reach 800 degrees, creating perfectly charred pizzas with unique flavors. Each pie uses fresh ingredients and traditional recipes perfected over 28 years. The seasoned ovens ensure no two pizzas taste exactly alike, offering a dining experience that combines history with modern culinary excellence.
Event Catering
Host celebrations for up to 400 guests in our historic church venue. We offer customized party menus and full-service event planning for corporate functions, weddings, and special occasions. Our team accommodates groups of 15+ with reservation options and themed packages for memorable experiences.
Gluten-Free Options
We provide gluten-free pizza options using dedicated preparation areas to maintain quality standards. Our menu includes gluten-free pasta and carefully prepared dishes that maintain the same attention to flavor as our traditional offerings while noting potential cross-contamination risks.
Takeout & Delivery
Enjoy our award-winning pizzas through convenient takeout and delivery services. Partnering with Grubhub expands our reach while maintaining the integrity of our coal-fired creations. We ensure proper packaging to preserve quality for customers dining off-premises.
Gift Certificates
Purchase digital or physical gift certificates in various denominations for any occasion. Our gift program allows recipients to experience New York's best pizza at their convenience, making perfect presents for food lovers and special celebrations.
Questions
What makes John's pizza unique?
Our coal-fired brick ovens and historic church setting create a distinctive pizza experience with each pie developing unique flavors through seasoned ovens.
Do you offer gluten-free options?
Yes, we provide gluten-free pizza and pasta options while maintaining strict preparation standards to accommodate dietary needs.
Can I host large events at John's?
Our venue accommodates groups up to 400 people with customized party packages and reservation options for groups of 15+.
Are gift certificates available?
Yes, we offer digital and physical gift certificates in multiple denominations for any occasion.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept cash and credit card payments with a 3.25% discount applied to cash transactions.
Do you offer delivery services?
Yes, we provide delivery through Grubhub and offer takeout options for customers who prefer off-premises dining.
Reviews (7)
Nelson Monterrosa
Dec 02, 2021 Report
Best John's there is. Time Square WISHES it could be this location. Where does all the love from the John's in NY come from? Like everything else that makes NY great, JERSEY! So if you ever are around the area and are in the mood for Italian. Please come and sit. Have a glass and enjoy, because you will enjoy. I recommend the Chicken Franaise, unless you're in the mood for something creamy, then their chicken Alfredo will have you begging for more, though you will leave some in your plate still because of how much they serve you. Pricy? A little bit. Worth it? EVERY PENNY! So yea... Go to this
Talitha James
Oct 17, 2021 Report
-I placed an order of creamy fettuccine pesto with shrimp for $28.
-I picked up the order within the time window given, 25-30 mins later
- there were 4 shrimp, the pasta needed more seasoning and was really watery.
SUMMARY: for the price and wait time I had higher expectations. I wouldn't order here again.
Alex Brown
Sep 04, 2021 Report
Great little neighborhood pizzeria with some awesome pies and apps. The wait staff is super friendly and its definitely a place to go out of your way for in Jersey City.
Dena H.
Jul 22, 2021 Report
Wow I am stuffed!! The appetizer (garlic rolls) is definitely meant to share across numerous people. Its so amazing and stuffed with melted cheese great for all cheese lovers. I also got the margarita pizza which was great too but Im definitely interested in trying out their pastas next time. Follow me on IG: @traveling.pharmacistt
David Rhee
Jun 16, 2021 Report
Food was good but nothing out of ordinary.. the linguine alle vongole was a bit bland and watery.. Added parmesan cheese to make it salty and not make it watery
Nathan Hauge
Jun 13, 2021 Report
Ordered from here probably a dozen times. The pizza itself is very good but the service is one of the worst in the area. If you order online or over the phone for pickup, double the amount of time they tell you it will be. If you order in person, prepare to wait an hour for a pizza. Its good but probably not worth the wait.
Colin Valentini
Sep 16, 2020 Report
Down to earth spot serving American and traditional pizza. Recommended for a low key lunch or dinner. The service comes with a smile and friendly NJ dad jokes. Pricing is fair and sizing is generous. Plenty of drinks to choose from (do yourself a favor and get some sangria), as well as a large pizza menu. They also serve non-pizza Italian entrees. I docked them one star as our pizza took an unusually long time to be prepared. Luckily we had a full carafe of sangria while we were waiting!