Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Authentic Italian Restaurant in New Rochelle, NY
We are a family-run Italian restaurant that has served the Wykagyl community of New Rochelle for over three decades. Our establishment prides itself on delivering authentic Italian cuisine crafted with traditional recipes and high-quality ingredients. Our menu features an extensive selection of pasta dishes, wood-fired pizzas, fresh seafood, and house-made meat specialties, all prepared to satisfy discerning palates. With generous portion sizes and competitive pricing, we ensure exceptional value without compromising flavor or quality.

Our attentive staff creates a welcoming atmosphere that enhances every dining experience, whether in our dining room or through our convenient takeout service. As a locally owned business, we remain committed to maintaining the culinary traditions that have made us a neighborhood favorite while continuously adapting to meet our customers' evolving preferences.
Services
Italian Cuisine Catering Services Takeout Orders Pasta Dishes Seafood Specialties
Highlights and features
  • We have served authentic Italian cuisine in New Rochelle for over 30 years
  • Our menu features house-made pastas and traditional Italian recipes
  • We offer competitive pricing with generous portion sizes
  • Our staff provides attentive, personalized service in a welcoming environment
  • We maintain quality standards through strict ingredient sourcing
Services
Italian Cuisine
Our Italian cuisine features traditional recipes passed down through generations. We prepare classic dishes using imported ingredients and time-honored techniques. Our menu showcases regional specialties from across Italy, including handmade pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and slow-cooked meats.
Catering Services
We provide full-service catering for events of all sizes with authentic Italian dishes. Our catering menu includes antipasti platters, pasta stations, and family-style entrees. We offer delivery, setup, and service options for weddings, corporate events, and private parties.
Takeout Orders
Our takeout service delivers restaurant-quality Italian meals directly to your home or office. We offer online ordering with real-time tracking for convenience. All dishes are packaged to maintain freshness and temperature during transport.
Pasta Dishes
We prepare over 20 varieties of pasta dishes using fresh, house-made noodles. Our menu includes classic preparations like Bolognese and carbonara, as well as regional specialties. All sauces are made daily from scratch using traditional methods.
Seafood Specialties
Our seafood menu features daily deliveries of fresh fish and shellfish. We prepare traditional Italian seafood dishes using Mediterranean recipes. Options include grilled fish, seafood pasta, and specialty dishes like Zuppa di Pesce with mixed seafood.
Questions
What type of cuisine do you serve?
We specialize in traditional Italian cuisine featuring handmade pastas, wood-fired pizzas, fresh seafood, and house-prepared meats using authentic recipes.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide full-service catering for events with Italian dishes, antipasti platters, and family-style entrees available for delivery and service.
Can I order takeout online?
Yes, our website offers online ordering with real-time tracking for all menu items, including pasta dishes, pizzas, and seafood specialties.
What are your specialty dishes?
Our specialties include house-made pastas, wood-fired pizzas, Chicken Parmigiana, Eggplant Parmigiana, and fresh seafood preparations like Shrimp Scampi.
Do you have vegetarian options?
Yes, we offer several vegetarian dishes including Vegetable Lasagna, Penne Primavera, and seasonal vegetable preparations as part of our regular menu.
Reviews (6)
Catherine Trapani
Sep 24, 2021 Report
Wonderful service and generous portion of flavorful and meaty lasagna! Hot bread and fresh bread included. We ended with a red velvet cake, cream cheese icing, and whipped cream garnish. Fantastic evening.
Ryan Cola
Jul 20, 2021 Report
Ordered Uber Eats from this restaurant last night. The food was amazing. This is a nice local hidden Gem in New Rochelle. Going to actually go there and try the food. Uber eats came on time and the food was amazing. You can tell that this restaurant takes there time with the food, and true Italian's cook it.
Luciano Castro
Jan 05, 2021 Report
Whenever I visit New Rochelle, I must stop at Maestro's for lunch or dinner. This family owned restaurant has been in business for at least 30 years. The menu has a variety of choices from pasta, pizza, meat, and seafood. I am hungry by just thinking about their food. I totally recommend them. Ask them about their Chicken Maestro dish.
Carlos Mennea
Oct 31, 2020 Report
Went out to dinner last night with a friend and we decided to stop at this Gem! Maestro's is always consistent when it comes to whipping up the Italian classics and the staff is welcoming and kind. We ordered the Mozzarella Spedini and Calamari Arrabiata to start. My favorite appetizers on the menu! For the main course I asked our waiter Anthony to whip me up something different. I wasn't in the mood for pasta, but I wanted their Vodka Sauce. He mentioned to me their special of Veal Chop Parm, but he substituted the Marinara for Vodka Sauce and I instantly jumped on that. The plate arrived with
Ellen Shain
Sep 27, 2020 Report
We have been eating at Maestro's for 20 years. Consistently great food with many menu choices & daily specials! Dont miss out! Order take-out now and be ready to make a reservation when dining in reopens!
J. E.
Jun 10, 2020 Report
I spent $80 on a delivery from here yesterday and I couldn't believe how bad everything was. The penne vodka was covered in pork I couldn't even taste anything else. The fried Mozzarella tasted like fish. WHY? The chicken scarpriello had no flavor. The veal was inedible. I don't know where all these good reviews come from.